CHAPTER 361 Pathobiology of Intracranial Aneurysms
Aneurysms are classified according to their shape and pathogenesis. Saccular aneurysms are berry-shaped or multilobed outpouchings on a blood vessel and are generally associated with cerebral artery bifurcations in the circle of Willis. Fusiform aneurysms are blood vessel dilations that usually result from dissections when blood ruptures into the wall of an artery. Infectious aneurysms arise from focal necrosis of an arterial wall after bacterial or fungal infection. Aneurysms are solitary lesions in about 70% to 75% of patients, whereas multiple lesions occur in about 25% to 30%.1 The majority of aneurysms develop spontaneously, but a small fraction (1% to 2%) are associated with trauma,2 infection,3 or tumor.4
About 85% of cases of subarachnoid hemorrhage are caused by rupture of saccular aneurysms.5 The most frequent sites for saccular aneurysms related to the circle of Willis are the internal carotid artery, anterior communicating artery, and middle cerebral artery.6 When subarachnoid hemorrhage occurs, the subarachnoid space is filled with arterial blood, and nerve fibers within the leptomeninges are stimulated, which can potentially cause intense pain and headache. Arteries located in the subarachnoid space may undergo spasm and result in poor cerebral perfusion and ischemia, which in turn may cause infarction. Flow of cerebrospinal fluid may be impeded as blood becomes organized into scar tissue that blocks the subarachnoid space. When drainage of cerebrospinal fluid is impeded, hydrocephalus with dilation of the cerebral ventricles occurs.7 The reported mortality of patients in whom subarachnoid hemorrhage is diagnosed is about 40% within the first 30 days. Among those who survive, less than 25% have a good functional outcome.8
Pathobiology of Saccular Intracranial Aneurysms
Saccular intracranial aneurysms are thought to arise as a result of disrupted balance between local hemodynamic stress and arterial wall strength.9–11 An understanding of the biologic changes that occur at the tissue, cellular, and molecular levels associated with aneurysm growth and rupture and their impact on the health of the patient is important in developing strategies for prevention, diagnosis, and treatment. Most of our knowledge of the pathology of intracranial aneurysms is based on histologic study of specimens obtained during surgery or autopsy. Such studies indicate that the structural integrity of aneurysm walls is compromised by a number of factors, such as changes in the matrix, hypertension, atherosclerosis, aging, gender, and genetic factors. Current evidence on the pathogenesis of intracranial aneurysms suggests that arterial wall proteolysis by matrix metalloproteinases, apoptosis, and chronic inflammation play a key role in disease progression.
Histology of Normal Intracranial Arteries
Intracranial arteries vary in size from fine communicating arteries (0.25 mm) to the basilar and internal carotid arteries (3 to 5 mm). Like all arteries, intracranial arteries are composed of three distinct microscopic layers: tunica intima, tunica media, and tunica adventitia, commonly referred to as the intima, media, and adventitia (Fig. 361-1A and B). The innermost layer is the intima, which is composed of a monolayer of endothelial cells on the luminal side in direct contact with blood flow, followed by a subendothelial connective tissue layer. A membrane of elastic fibers called the internal elastic lamina separates the intima from the media. The media is composed mainly of concentric sheets of smooth muscle cells and collagen fibers.12,13 Medial collagen, apparently predominantly type III, can be stretched despite its highly aligned arrangement.12 The outermost layer is the adventitia, which consists primarily of a complex network of type I collagen fibers, some elastin, nerves, fibroblasts, and the vasa vasorum. Adventitial collagen fibers adjacent to the media are oriented in a circumferential fashion and gradually change to a longitudinal orientation toward the outer layer.14–16 Adventitial collagen fibrils, 50 to 100 nm in diameter,17,18 have a wavy appearance and are unstretched at physiologic pressure levels.16,19 In most arteries, the adventitia is separated from the media by another layer of elastic fibers called the external elastic lamina. However, this structure is not present in intracranial arteries.
A substantial portion of the connective tissue in the arterial wall is filled with extracellular matrix, a complex and dynamic meshwork of proteins and proteoglycans that provide structural support to the vessel wall, as well as participate in various biologic activities such as cell proliferation, differentiation, and migration.20 Synthesized and secreted by resident cells, extracellular matrix molecules become highly organized to adapt to the functional requirements of the particular tissue. Examples of extracellular matrix components are collagen, elastin, fibronectin, laminin, nidogen/entactins, perlecan, and syndecans.
About 80% to 90% of the total arterial collagen, composed of collagen types I and III, consists of fibrillar collagen, which provides tensile strength to blood vessels. The defining structural feature of collagen is a triple-stranded helical structure (designated procollagen) of three polypeptide chains, referred to as α chains. Once secreted, propolypeptides of procollagen are removed by proteolytic enzymes. This allows the formation of higher order polymers called collagen fibrils (10 to 30 nm in diameter), which often aggregate into even larger bundles called collagen fibers (500 to 3000 nm in diameter). The remaining 10% to 20% of arterial collagen (types IV, V, VI, and VIII)21 is composed of network-forming collagen that gives rise to net-like structures, such as in the basement membrane.
Elastin is the core component of elastic fibers and it provides resilience to blood vessels. On secretion, elastin precursor molecules become highly cross-linked to one another and form networks of elastin fibers and sheets. Microfibrils, composed of glycoproteins, are thought to provide scaffolding for elastin molecules and are subsequently displaced as elastin is deposited into the growing fiber. Elastin makes up about 90% of elastic fibers, with microfibrillar glycoproteins accounting for the remaining 10%.22
Fibronectin is a multifunctional glycoprotein that provides stability to vessel walls and is involved in intercellular contact and repair mechanisms.23,24 Fibronectins connect cells with collagen fibers, thereby allowing cells to move through the extracellular matrix. They bind collagen and cell surface receptors called integrins, which causes reorganization of the cell cytoskeleton and cell movement. Fibronectins are secreted in an inactive form. Binding to integrins allows them to dimerize and become active. Fibronectins also help at the site of tissue injury by binding to platelets during blood clotting and facilitating movement of cells to the affected area during wound healing.
Laminins, a family of heterotrimeric glycoproteins that are usually found in basement membranes, function in migration, adhesion, and cell signaling.25,26 They are formed from the assembly of three subunits (α, β, and γ). Several laminin isoforms are derived from the combination of five α, four β, and six γ subunits. Vascular endothelial cells have been shown to produce the laminin-8 and laminin-10 isoforms.25,27,28
In 1930, Forbus described the presence of discontinuities in the smooth muscle layer of arterial vessels, especially at the apex of vessel bifurcations. For many years, these medial gaps were believed to represent congenital medial defects that contribute to the development of intracranial aneurysms.29 In 1983, Stehbens demonstrated that the so-called medial defects could be visualized under light microscopy and that they are actually physiologic intersections of two muscle layers rather than defects.30 This finding is in agreement with more recent studies showing that highly organized tendon-like collagen is consistently found in the region of the medial gap, which would provide strength and stability to the vessel, and is inconsistent with the concept of defect.17 Accordingly, experimentally induced intracranial aneurysms in rats were shown not to originate at the site of these medial gaps.31 The histologic characteristics of these medial gaps are shown in Figure 361-1.32
Histology of Intracranial Arteries from Patients with Aneurysms
In contrast to the highly ordered structure of a normal arterial wall, aneurysms have a disorganized wall structure with less distinct layers. A common feature of intracranial aneurysm walls is loss or rupture of the internal elastic lamina (Fig. 361-2A).33–36 Other characteristics include intimal thickening resembling myointimal hyperplasia, muscle fiber disarray, depletion of cellular components (Fig. 361-2B and C), and irregularities in the luminal surface (Fig. 361-3).33,34,36–42 Atherosclerotic lesions have also been identified in some aneurysms.38,43–45 Immunohistochemical studies on 18 intracranial aneurysm specimens showed intermingling of collagen type I and fibronectin throughout the aneurysm wall. This finding is in contrast to parent and normal arteries, in which collagen and fibronectin are limited to the adventitia and media, respectively.46 Expression of laminin, collagen types III and IV, and the angiogenic growth factor transforming growth factor-α has been found to be decreased in some aneurysm samples when compared with normal vessels (Fig. 361-4).47
Changes in the medial smooth muscle cell phenotype have also been reported in intracranial aneurysms. In control cerebral arteries, α-smooth muscle actin, desmin, and the smooth muscle myosin heavy-chain (MHC) isoforms SM1 and SM2 were strongly expressed, whereas another MHC isoform, SMemb, was weakly expressed. In aneurysm walls, no expression of desmin was observed. In some aneurysms, SMemb expression was higher or SM2 expression was lower than in control arteries. Desmin is the major intermediate filament of skeletal, cardiac, and smooth muscle tissue48 and is believed to be important for strengthening and maintaining the integrity of smooth muscle cells.49 These observations suggest that a phenotypic switch in smooth muscle cells is associated with vascular remodeling in the aneurysm wall.50
Histologic differences have been noted between ruptured and unruptured aneurysms. A denser expression of fibronectin has been observed in ruptured aneurysms than in unruptured aneurysms.47 Ruptured walls appear to have more pronounced endothelial damage and loss of wall density.41,51–53 In a study involving 44 ruptured and 27 unruptured aneurysms, Kataoka and colleagues found that unruptured aneurysms had thick walls resembling myointimal hyperplasia whereas ruptured aneurysms had thin, hyalinized, and hypocellular walls.41 In a series of 66 intracranial aneurysm samples, Frosen and associates identified four histologic aneurysm wall types and described morphologic changes in the aneurysm walls that correlated with rupture. These wall types were endothelialized wall with linearly organized smooth muscle cells (42% ruptured) (Fig. 361-5A), thickened wall with disorganized smooth muscle cells (55% ruptured) (Fig. 361-5B), hypocellular wall with myointimal hyperplasia (64% ruptured) (Fig. 361-5C), and thin, hyalinized, and hypocellular wall (100% ruptured) (Fig. 361-5D).51
Structural and biochemical changes have also been noted in the nonaneurysmal tissue of aneurysm patients. In a study of the intracranial arteries of 70 normal individuals and 35 patients with intracranial aneurysms who died of aneurysm rupture, a dense, uniformly distributed network of reticular fibers surrounding the smooth muscle cells was observed in the media of normal individuals. This pattern did not appear to change with age, at least until the age of 50. In contrast, a decreased number of reticular fibers was observed in the arteries of aneurysm patients, all of whom died before the age of 50.54 Similar results were obtained in two other independent investigations.55,56 Aside from decreased numbers, irregular distribution and shorter reticular fiber length were also noted.55,56 Biochemical studies have shown that the skin fibroblasts and intracranial and temporal arteries of some aneurysm patients are deficient in collagen type III relative to collagen type I.57–60 These observations led to the hypothesis that “intrinsic” abnormalities in the walls of intracranial arteries lead to conditions that favor the formation and rupture of intracranial arteries.
Mechanisms of Aneurysm Wall Degeneration and Rupture
In normal arteries, myointimal hyperplasia is an adaptive mechanism in response to hemodynamic stress or mechanical injury. Pads of myointimal hyperplasia are formed when endothelial damage from injury or stress induces a change in the phenotype of medial smooth muscle cells that promotes their migration to and proliferation at the damaged endothelial lining.61 The histopathologic resemblance of unruptured intracranial aneurysm walls to myointimal hyperplasia suggests that the aneurysm wall reacts similarly to hemodynamic stress by increasing cell proliferation and matrix synthesis. However, it is still unclear whether the myointimal hyperplasia in aneurysms is an adaptive mechanism of the vascular wall to compensate for excessive stress or whether it contributes to weakening of the wall.
Histologic studies suggest that intracranial aneurysm walls rupture as a consequence of matrix degeneration and decellularization, which may be the result of direct vascular stress or injury or correspond to defective homeostatic maintenance or repair mechanisms.62,63 Although it is still unclear how risk factors for subarachnoid hemorrhage, such as smoking, hypertension, female gender, previous subarachnoid hemorrhage, and age, contribute to rupture, data suggest that proteolysis, programmed cell death, inflammation, and hemodynamic stress are events that are associated with aneurysm wall degeneration and rupture.
Proteolysis and Intracranial Aneurysms
Extracellular matrix components are constantly being synthesized and degraded. When compared with normal intracranial arteries, aneurysm tissue, especially ruptured aneurysm tissue, displays increased activity or expression (or both) of matrix-degrading proteases that regulate remodeling of the arterial wall. Prominent in aneurysm walls are matrix metalloproteinase-2 (MMP-2) and MMP-9, which are classified as gelatinases and are capable of degrading both elastin and denatured collagen. In a series of 23 patients with intracranial aneurysms, Bruno and associates found focal areas of gelatinase activity attributable to MMP-2 and MMP-9 in both ruptured and unruptured aneurysms. Increased protease activity correlated with increased expression of MMP-2, plasmin (Fig. 361-6), and membrane-type MMP,11 with the latter two being involved in activation of MMP-2. Increased serum levels of elastase have also been observed in aneurysm patients.64,65