Dementias
INTRODUCTION
Diseases causing dementia are among the commonest neurologic conditions encountered in clinical practice (Table 31.1). The importance of establishing a neuropathologic diagnosis dementia can be linked to the following:
Table 31.1
Prevalence of dementia at different ages
Age (years) | Prevalence (%) |
<75 | 4 |
80 | 12 |
85 | 27 |
90 | 40 |
Clinical diagnosis of the type of dementia may be unreliable, particularly outside specialist units.
Some diseases have a genetic basis and a precise diagnosis facilitates counseling.
New causes of dementia are still being discovered by applying new diagnostic methods.
TEMPOROPARIETAL AND FRONTOTEMPOROPARIETAL DEMENTIAS
AD is the commonest cause of dementia and increases in incidence with age. It accounts for 50–75% of all cases of dementia, the precise figure depending on the criteria used to establish the diagnosis. There are five main groups, with different molecular genetic associations (see p. 628):
Sporadic late-onset AD (commonest).
Familial late-onset AD (uncommon).
Familial early-onset AD (rare).
About 10–20% of patients have a first-degree relative with dementia.
MACROSCOPIC APPEARANCES
The brain shows atrophy and the weight is usually in the range of 900–1200 g. There is shrinkage of cerebral gyri and widening of sulci, most prominently in the medial temporal regions (particularly the hippocampus) but also in the frontal and parietal regions. Generally, the occipital lobe and the motor cortex are relatively spared. This pattern of atrophy occurs in several dementing diseases and is not specific for AD (Fig. 31.2).
31.2 Macroscopic appearance of brain in AD.
The pattern of atrophy typically seen in AD is characteristic, but not specific for the disease. In this case, the leptomeninges have been stripped from one half of a brain to show the regional atrophy clearly. (a) Lateral view showing severe atrophy of the temporal lobe with less severe atrophy of the parietal and frontal lobes. The occipital lobe is spared. (b) The severity of atrophy of the mesial temporal lobe structures is better appreciated in this view of the inferior surface. (c) The relative sparing of the primary motor cortex (arrow) and occipital lobe (OL) can be appreciated in this view of the superior surface.
In slices of fixed brain, the cortical mantle may appear thinned (Fig. 31.3). The white matter is of normal color and texture, but reduced in volume. There may be significant dilatation of the ventricular system, especially of the temporal horn of the lateral ventricles. In the midbrain, the substantia nigra is usually normally pigmented but can appear pale. The locus ceruleus is often paler than normal. Cerebral infarcts or hemorrhages may be encountered and can be related to cerebrovascular amyloid deposition or coexistent arteriosclerotic disease.
31.3 Macroscopic appearance of brain in AD.
In this picture the slice on the left is from a normal patient aged 70, while the one on the right is from a patient with AD. Note that there is a reduction in the volume of white matter with cortical atrophy, mild sulcal widening and gyral thinning, the hippocampus is atrophic.
HISTOPATHOLOGY OF ALZHEIMER’S DISEASE
AD is characterized by several histologic abnormalities, none of which is specific to this disease. Special stains are required for evaluation (Table 31.3).
Table 31.3
Stains used in the histologic assessment of Alzheimer’s disease
Much of the pathology associated with Alzheimer’s disease cannot be easily seen without special stains
Sections stained with H&E are used for general morphology and can be used to evaluate neuronal loss as well as any general morphological changes, e.g. associated areas of infarction. Granulovacuolar degeneration and Hirano bodies are also easily seen (Figs 31.5, 31.6)
Silver stains are still used in diagnosis and can be divided into:
Methods that are very sensitive for amyloid (e.g. modified methenamine silver techniques). These detect all plaques and a minority of tangles (Fig. 31.7)
Methods that are very sensitive for the detection of tangles and the abnormal nerve processes around plaques but do not tend to stain amyloid (e.g. the Gallyas technique, several modifications of the Palmgren silver impregnation (Fig. 31.8), and some modifications of Bodian and Bielschowsky methods)
Methods that are optimized to detect both plaques and tangles. These tend to underestimate the density of either plaques or tangles. This is true of most modified Bodian and Bielschowsky techniques, which underestimate the total amount of amyloid in sections
In most laboratories, specific staining of plaques and tangles is now performed by immunohistochemistry with commercially-available antisera:
Plaques are detected with antisera to Aβ peptide after formic acid pretreatment of sections. This will also detect vascular amyloid (Fig. 31.9)
Tangles, plaque neurites and neuropil threads are detected by immunostaining for phosphorylated tau protein, the main protein constituent of tangles (Fig. 31.9)
Parenchymal extracellular deposits of a specific amyloid in the brain. The amyloid is composed of Aβ peptide, derived by proteolytic breakdown from a normal neuronal membrane protein called amyloid-β precursor protein (APP). There are both diffuse and focal forms of amyloid deposits.
Intraneuronal filamentous inclusions termed neurofibrillary tangles (NFTs). EM shows these to have a paired helical filamentous structure. The main constituent of the filaments is the microtubule binding protein, tau, with other protein components decorating the filaments.
Distortion of neuronal processes to form structures termed dystrophic neurites and neuropil threads (NTs). These structures also contain tau protein.
Loss of synapses and, in late stages, of neurons from the cerebral cortex.
Associated pathologic changes are:
Amyloid (also derived from Aβ peptide) deposition in arteries and arterioles in the cerebral and cerebellar cortex and leptomeninges (congophilic angiopathy/cerebral amyloid angiopathy) is demonstrable in over 90% of cases, although the extent of this is very variable (Fig. 31.4). Small amounts of Aβ may also accumulate in the walls of small veins.
31.4 AD cerebral amyloid (congophilic) angiopathy.
(a) In H&E stained sections, as here, the vessels affected by amyloid are thick-walled and have a homogeneous pink appearance. (b) In this preparation stained with Congo red, amyloid in the wall of a vessel in the cerebral cortex stains orange. (c) The amyloid nature can be confirmed by polarizing light microscopy, which reveals apple-green birefringence and dichroism. (d) The amyloid in the cerebral vessels shows Aβ peptide immunoreactivity.
Granulovacuolar degeneration (Fig. 31.5) affects greater numbers of hippocampal pyramidal neurons in AD than in age-matched controls and may also be seen in subcortical nuclei. These represent autophagic activity.
31.5 Two neurons contain basophilic granules surrounded by non-staining vacuoles, termed granulovacuolar degeneration (GVD).
Some GVD granules contain tau protein and also can be immunostained for ubiquitin.
Hirano bodies, composed of actin-binding proteins, tend to be more numerous in AD than in age-matched controls in neurons in the hippocampal CA1 field and subiculum (Fig. 31.6).
31.6 This composite image shows Hirano bodies in longitudinal (top) and cross-section (bottom).
Hirano bodies are brightly eosinophilic and appear to overlap neuronal structures in the plane of section.
There is increased accumulation of lipofuscin in neurons (see Chapter 1).
Corpora amylacea may be seen in large numbers (see Chapter 1).
Diffuse Aβ deposits
Diffuse deposits of Aβ peptide are seen on immunostaining as loose structures with irregular, ill-defined margins. In this form of deposit, the majority of protein is not aggregated as amyloid filaments (Table 31.4). Diffuse deposits are the main type of plaque seen in normal aging. Some diffuse Aβ deposits are described as fleece- or lake-like. Diffuse deposits may be seen in the subpial region in the cerebral cortex.
Table 31.4
Focal Aβ deposits
Neuritic changes in plaques
Neuritic plaques include tau-immunoreactive dystrophic neurites (see Neuritic abnormalities in AD, below, and Fig. 31.11). In some neuritic plaques there are dystrophic neurites that contain chromogranin A and ubiquitin, but not tau protein; of the sparse neuritic plaques that may be present in the brains of cognitively normal elderly subjects, this form predominates. A variety of other plaque amyloid-related proteins can be demonstrated immunohistochemically, including apolipoprotein E (apoE), α1-antichymotrypsin, serum amyloid-P protein, growth factors, heparin sulfate, and complement factors.
31.7 Methenamine silver stain in AD.
Cerebral cortex stained with methenamine silver to reveal plaques and NFTs. This technique provides a sensitive means of staining plaques. It is less effective for staining NFTs, and is relatively poor for demonstrating plaque-related neurites.
31.8 Palmgren silver impregnation in AD.
Silver impregnation of cerebral cortex reveals a plaque and NFTs. This type of stain is not sensitive to amyloid, seen in the center of the plaque as a yellow background, but is good for detecting NFTs and plaque-related neurites.
31.9 Aβ and tau in AD.
These are serial sections showing the hippocampus. The top section has been immunostained with an antibody to the peptide that forms amyloid in AD (Aβ peptide). The bottom section has been stained with an antibody to hyperphosphorylated tau protein, which accumulated inside neurons and cell processes in AD. Amyloid plaques can be seen as military focal deposits in the cortex with Aβ staining. Tau protein accumulation has a laminar pattern, reflecting its accumulation in nerve cell bodies and processes. Notice that some foci of tau labeling correspond to the same areas as the Aβ plaques in the top section; these foci are clusters of plaque-associated nerve cell processes that contain hyperphosphorylated tau (plaque-associated dystrophic neurites).
31.11 Neuritic changes in plaques.
(a) Labeling for Aβ peptide shows range of plaque morphologies (contrast with a similar area stained for hyperphosphorylated tau protein). (b) Immunostaining of hyperphosphorylated tau protein. This shows accumulation of tau in neuronal somata and abnormal nerve cell processes; these are particularly prominent within neuritic plaques, seen as condensations of dense labeling. (c) Immunostaining of hyperphosphorylated tau protein in plaque-associated neurites. The plaque Aβ amyloid is not demonstrated with this immunostain. (d) In some plaques, immunostaining for ubiquitin shows bulbous dilated nerve cell processes (plaque-associated neurites). The amyloid is not labeled.
Neurofibrillary tangles
Neurofibrillary tangles are neuronal inclusions composed largely of filamentous aggregates of hyperphosphorylated tau proteins that are variably ubiquitylated and glycated. In sections stained with hematoxylin and eosin, intracellular NFTs are faintly basophilic and extracellular NFTs appear eosinophilic (Fig. 31.16). In sections stained by silver impregnation, or when immunostained, several morphologic forms of NFT can be identified, the shape of the NFT probably being determined by that of the neuron containing it. A multi-stage model of NFT formation has been proposed (Fig. 31.17). Ultrastructural investigation reveals that NFTs are composed of paired helical filaments (PHFs) with a maximum diameter of 20 nm and a periodic narrowing to 10 nm every 80 nm (Fig. 31.18). A small proportion of filaments is straight, with a diameter of 15 nm. Detailed examination of PHF preparations shows that the filaments have a dense core region with a surrounding fuzzy coat.
31.16 Neurofibrillary tangles.
(a) In H&E sections, NFTs can sometimes just be seen as faintly basophilic structures within the neuronal cytoplasm but this is not a reliable way to detect them. Many are flame-shaped, as here. (b) Silver staining shows a characteristic filamentous tangle structure in a pyramidal neuron with material extending into the apical dendrite. The filamentous material is composed of tau protein.
31.17 Histologic appearances of NFTs.
(a) Band-shaped perikaryal NFT: a single well-defined band runs from the base of the neuron into the apical dendrite. This type of NFT is seen in both large and small pyramidal cells. (b) Flame-shaped perikaryal NFT: a triangular mass of filaments, usually surrounding the nucleus and extending into the apical dendrite, and seen mainly in large pyramidal cells. (c) Small globose perikaryal NFT: a rounded mass of filaments displacing the nucleus to one side of the neuron. This type of NFT is seen in small cortical neurons, especially in Layers 5 and 6, and also in the periamygdaloid cortex. (d) Large globose NFTs: seen in the nucleus basalis of Meynert, periaqueductal gray matter, substantia nigra, locus ceruleus, and raphe nuclei. (e) Ghost NFTs: faintly eosinophilic extracellular structures that persist after the death of the neuron. (f) Ghost NFTs: the extracellular ghost NFTs are moderately well seen on silver impregnation. (g) Ghost NFTs may become immunoreactive for Aβ peptide as a result of its deposition around them. (h) Ghost NFTs may seem to be immunoreactive for glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP), due to ingrowth of glial cell processes.
31.18 Ultrastructure of NFT.
NFTs are composed of paired helical filaments with a periodicity of 80 nm.
NFTs are readily detected by antisera directed against phosphorylated tau protein (Fig. 31.19). Many NFTs are immunoreactive for ubiquitin or P62 (Fig. 31.20). Neurofibrillary tangles can be seen in elderly brains in low density and restricted distribution as well as in a variety of other conditions. Hence, they are not specific to AD (Table 31.5). In AD, the density of NFTs is closely related to the severity of dementia.
Table 31.5
Disorders associated with neurofibrillary tangles
Progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP)
Down syndrome
Dementia pugilistica
Postencephalitic parkinsonism
Parkinsonism dementia complex of Guam
Subacute sclerosing panencephalitis
Niemann–Pick disease type C
Familial British dementia
Myotonic dystrophy
Kufs’ disease
Neuronal brain iron accumulation type-1
Gerstmann–Straüssler–Scheinker syndrome
Cockayne syndrome
31.19 NFT and NT tau immunostaining.
Immunostaining with antisera to phosphorylated tau protein is used as a routine method for detecting NFTs and NTs. Staining will detect established NFTs, as well as pretangles – dispersed aggregates of tau that are probably precursors of NFTs. Many extracellular (‘ghost’) NFTs are not immunoreactive for tau. (a) Granular cytoplasmic pretangle staining in a pyramidal neuron in the hippocampus. There is a low density of background NTs. (b) Dense labeling, characteristic of tangle stage, in a pyramidal neuron. Note higher density of NTs in the background. (c) NFTs of flame-shaped and globular morphology, in temporal neocortex. There is a high density of background NTs. (d) Tangles are densely stained structures in the cell bodies. There is abundant labeling of NTs in the surrounding neuropil.
31.20 NFT P62 immunostaining.
Some NFTs are immunoreactive for ubiquitin, or the ubiquitin-binding protein P62, shown here. It is of note that small globose NFTs are generally ubiquitylated and can therefore be almost indistinguishable from cortical Lewy bodies on ubiquitin or P62 immunohistochemistry.
Neuritic abnormalities in AD. There are two main forms:
Plaque-related dystrophic neurites, which are abnormally distended nerve cell processes running through Aβ plaque deposits. Some of the neurites contain increased amounts of lysosome-related dense bodies, but no PHFs, and immunostain for chromogranin A and ubiquitin, but not tau protein. Other neurites contain PHFs ultrastructurally and are immunoreactive both for tau protein and variably for ubiquitin (Fig. 31.11).
Neuropil threads (NTs), which are fine, distorted, and twisted nerve cell processes that are immunoreactive for tau protein (Fig. 31.21) and variably for ubiquitin. Ultrastructural examination shows nerve cell processes that contain a mixture of PHFs and straight filaments (Fig. 31.18).
Perisomatic granules. Immunostaining for ubiquitin reveals densely-labeled round bodies adjacent to pyramidal neurons representing distended, retracted synaptic boutons. These are termed perisomatic granules (Fig. 31.21).
Tangle-associated neuritic clusters in AD. Tau immunostaining may show shows filamentous aggregates in the pyramidal cell region of the hippocampus. Although these superficially resemble plaque neurites, there is no associated focal accumulation of Aβ. These clusters represent ingrowth of tau-containing cell processes into a region previously occupied by a NFT (Fig. 31.22).
31.22 Tangle-associated neuritic clusters.
Tau immunostaining of the hippocampal pyramidal layer shows two tangle-associated neuritic clusters (arrowheads). A few adjacent pyramidal neurons contain tangles.
Neuronal and synaptic loss in AD. A 30–40% loss of neocortical neurons can be demonstrated in advanced AD, particularly in young-onset patients. The neuronal loss is associated with astrocytic gliosis and, in some cases, cortical microvacuolation, the latter often termed status spongiosus (Fig. 31.23). This pattern of vacuolation is coarser than that typically seen in prion disease and is largely confined to the outer cortical layers. In AD, synaptic loss of 30–50% can be demonstrated by quantitation of synapse-related proteins in affected cortical regions. The most widely used marker is synaptophysin, a glycoprotein associated with synaptic vesicles. The degree of synaptic loss correlates well with clinical scores of the severity of dementia.
31.23 Status spongiosus in AD.
Severe neuronal loss from the cortex in AD, with associated astrocytic gliosis, results in irregular coarse vacuolation termed status spongiosus.
Subcortical involvement in AD. Many subcortical regions are involved by plaques, NFTs, or NTs in AD (Table 31.6). Some regions, such as the dorsal raphe nucleus, are affected at an early stage of disease. Involvement of the nucleus basalis of Meynert is especially important, as this is the cholinergic projection nucleus to the cerebral cortex. Cell loss from this nucleus results in a severe cholinergic deficit in the cerebral cortex in AD.
Pathologic staging of AD
Plaque stages correlate poorly with the severity of dementia (Fig. 31.24) and are:
Stage A: low density of neuritic plaques in the neocortex, especially in the frontal, temporal, and occipital lobes.
Stage B: neuritic plaques present in neocortical association areas and moderate hippocampal involvement.
Stage C: neuritic plaques present in primary sensory and motor areas.
NFT stages correlated well with the severity of dementia (Fig. 31.25). The Braak staging of neurofibrillary degeneration is incorporated in the 2012 National Institute on Aging–Alzheimer’s Association (NIA-AA) guidelines for the neuropathologic assessment of Alzheimer’s disease neuropathologic criteria for diagnosis of AD (p. 625). The BrainNet Europe Consortium has validated a scheme incorporating immunohistochemistry for hyperphosphorylated tau instead of silver staining for staging of neurofibrillary changes in AD (Fig. 31.26).
AD pathology in the cognitively normal elderly
The histologic changes that affect AD patients may be found in a restricted distribution or low density in cognitively normal elderly individuals. Plaques occur in the cortex with increased frequency in aging. In normal aging, the plaques are mainly diffuse. There may be small numbers of neuritic plaques, most associated with ubiquitin- and chromogranin-immunoreactive neurites, that do not contain tau protein. NFTs may be seen in small numbers in the hippocampus and entorhinal cortex in the cognitively normal elderly. This corresponds to Braak stages I–III (Fig. 31.25).
Pathologic diagnostic criteria for AD
Several different criteria have been proposed for the pathologic diagnosis for AD:
The Consortium to Establish a Registry for Alzheimer’s Disease (CERAD) guidelines for the diagnosis of AD have been widely used and are based on semi-quantitative assessment of neuritic plaque density by comparison with standard reference illustrations (Tables 31.7–31.9, Figs 31.24, 31.25). This has been shown to have good reproducibility between different laboratories. The patient’s age and the clinical history of dementia are taken into account in determining the diagnostic category for each case. The CERAD scheme specifies silver staining or fluorescent dye staining, which has prompted workers to evaluate equivalent immunohistochemical staining methods for evaluation of cases.
Table 31.7
CERAD protocol for diagnosis of Alzheimer’s disease
Macroscopic appearance
The following features are noted:
brain weight
regional neocortical atrophy and ventricular enlargement (rated semiquantitatively as none, mild, moderate, or severe)
atrophy of the hippocampus and entorhinal cortex (present or absent)
pallor of the substantia nigra and locus ceruleus (present or absent)
atherosclerosis, significant obstruction or aneurysms of cerebral blood vessels (present or absent)
lacunar infarcts, regional infarcts, hemorrhages (number, size, frequency, distribution, and laterality recorded)
Histologic sampling and staining
A minimum of six anatomic regions is designated for histologic examination (Fig. 31.26):
middle frontal gyrus
superior and middle temporal gyri
anterior cingulate gyrus
inferior parietal lobule
hippocampus and entorhinal cortex
midbrain including the substantia nigra
Paraffin-embedded sections are cut at a thickness of 6–8 μm and stained with:
Hematoxylin and eosin (H&E)
A silver stain, such as the modified Bielschowsky impregnation, for the detection of neuritic plaques and neurofibrillary tangles
Thioflavin-S stained sections viewed under UV light can be used to assess plaques, tangles, and vascular amyloid
A Congo red stain can be used for evaluating vascular amyloid
Diagnostic classification
The CERAD classification is performed in three steps:
A semiquantitative assessment is made of the density of neuritic plaques (i.e. that include thickened, silver-impregnated neurites) in the sections of the neocortex. The density is scored by comparison with reference photomicrographs and diagrams as none, sparse, moderate, or frequent (Fig. 31.27). The density of tangles is also estimated but this does not contribute to the diagnostic classification in the CERAD protocol
An age-related plaque score is obtained by relating the maximum plaque density in sections of frontal, temporal, or parietal cortex, to the age of the patient at death (in the ranges <50, 50–75, or >75 years) (Table 31.8)
The age-related plaque score is then integrated with the clinical presence or absence of dementia to allow cases to be categorized as normal with respect to AD, probable AD, or definite AD (Table 31.9)
Table 31.8
Table 31.9
Normal (with respect to Alzheimer’s disease or other dementing processes) if:
Either
No histologic evidence of Alzheimer’s disease (0 score), and no clinical history of dementia, and absence of other neuropathologic lesions likely to cause dementia
Or
An A age-related plaque score and no clinical history of dementia
CERAD NP definite Alzheimer’s disease
C age-related plaque score, and clinical history of dementia, and presence or absence of other neuropathologic lesions likely to cause dementia
CERAD NP probable Alzheimer’s disease
B age-related plaque score, and clinical history of dementia, and presence or absence of other neuropathologic lesions likely to cause dementia
CERAD NP possible Alzheimer’s disease if:
Either
A age-related plaque score, and clinical history of dementia, and presence or absence of other neuropathologic lesions likely to cause dementia
Or
B or C age-related plaque score and absence of clinical manifestations of dementia
The Thal plaque phase is a scheme that stages the regional involvement of accumulation of Aβ in the brain into five phases. Aβ detected exclusively in neocortex (phase 1), additionally in allocortex (phase 2), extending to diencephalon and striatum (phase 3), involving brainstem (phase 4), and present in cerebellum (phase 5).
The NIA-AA criteria were developed in recognition that AD has to be defined as a clinico-pathologic entity and that within that clinical diagnostic group there may be pathologic variation. It is recommended that finding pathologic changes of AD in the brain at autopsy are reported as ’AD neuropathologic changes’.
Aβ plaques are staged according to the Thal Phase scheme (A).
NFT stage is determined according to the Braak criteria (B).
Neuritic plaques are scored according to the CERAD scheme (C) (Fig. 31.27, Table 31.10).
Table 31.10
ABC scoring scheme for AD neuropathologic change
Modified from National Institute on Aging-Alzheimer’s Association guidelines for the neuropathologic assessment of Alzheimer’s disease, 2012.
Combining these three scores (‘ABC scoring’) allows the pathologist to allocate a probability that AD-associated abnormalities accounted for the patient’s dementia in life. AD lesions seen in the post-mortem brain from cognitively normal elderly people are considered pathologic rather than a part of a normal aging process. The likelihood that clinical dementia has been caused by AD lesions in the brain is stratified on the basis of the post-mortem neuropathologic findings, as follows (Table 31.11):
Table 31.11
NIA-AA ABC scoring for Alzheimer neuropathologic change
(Modified from National Institute on Aging-Alzheimer’s Association guidelines for the neuropathologic assessment of Alzheimer’s disease. Alzheimer’s Dement 2012 8(1):1–13)
High probability that dementia was due to AD lesions, if the brain has both neuritic plaques and neurofibrillary tangles in the neocortex (CERAD frequent neuritic plaque score 3, Thal plaques score 3 and Braak and Braak stage V/VI score 3).
Intermediate probability that dementia was due to AD lesions, if the brain has a moderate density of neocortical neuritic plaques, and neurofibrillary tangles in the limbic regions (CERAD moderate, and Braak and Braak stage III/IV).
Low probability that dementia was due to AD lesions, if the brain has neuritic plaques and neurofibrillary tangles in a more limited distribution and/or severity (CERAD infrequent, and Braak and Braak stage I/II).
In applying earlier NIA–Reagan criteria, it became apparent that many laboratories had moved away from use of silver-stained preparations in evaluating AD pathology and that alternate approaches were desirable. The BrainNet Europe group published staging criteria based on evaluation of tau-labeled histologic sections from four brain regions (Figs 31.27–31.30).
31.28 Cortical sampling for immunohistochemical staging of neurofibrillary changes (BrainNet Europe).
Section 1: visual cortex including the calcarine fissure to include the primary visual cortex with band of Gennari (involved in stage VI) and parastriate/peristriate region (Brodmann area 18/19, the six-layered cortex (involved in stage V). Section 2: middle and superior temporal gyrus (involved in stage IV). Section 3: anterior hippocampus and/or amygdala at the level of uncus (involved in stages I–III). Section 4: posterior hippocampus at level of lateral geniculate body (involved in stages II and III).
31.29 Semiquantitative assessment of immunohistochemical labeling of neurofibrillary changes, with antibody to hyperphosphorylated tau protein.
0, No labeling (not illustrated); +, labeling barely detectable (a); ++, labeling readily detectable (b); +++, dense labeling that can be seen by macroscopic inspection of the slide (c).
DIFFICULTIES IN DIAGNOSING AD
Specific tauopathies such as PSP (see Chapter 28) and CBD (see Chapter 28, and later in this chapter) may present as a dementia syndrome or a syndrome of parkinsonism and dementia. A search for the characteristic abnormalities should be made of subcortical structures known to be affected in these disorders. Cortical regions should be assessed for swollen neurons characteristic of CBD, and both cortex and white matter should be examined for tau-immunopositive glial inclusions.
Tangle-only dementia (see below) is an uncommon but increasingly recognized disorder.
Some patients have an abundance of plaques but very few NFTs.
A careful search for cortical Lewy bodies should be made in cortical and subcortical regions, with a view to making a diagnosis of dementia with Lewy bodies (DLB), which accounts for many cases previously regarded as ‘plaque-only’ AD.
If no cortical Lewy bodies are seen and the plaques are all diffuse, they may be incidental and other types of dementia (such as a frontotemporal dementia, or argyrophilic grain disease – see below) should be considered, and the relevant abnormalities sought (e.g. microvacuolation in Layer II of the anterior temporal or frontal neocortex; neuronal inclusion bodies, tau-immunopositive structures in the hippocampus).
Limbic AD, characterized by clinical dementia and large numbers of NFTs restricted to the amygdala and hippocampus but with large numbers of neocortical plaques.
Two pathologic subtypes of AD have been suggested: typical AD (~75% cases) and hippocampal sparing or limbic-predominant AD (~25% of cases).
Asymmetric AD. The changes of AD may rarely be asymmetric so that one hemisphere is preferentially affected.
Posterior AD. Severe disease preferentially affecting the occipital and visual-association areas with pathologic features of AD has been reported.
Frontal AD. AD pathology may be most marked frontally and associated with the clinical features of frontotemporal dementia.
Swollen neurons in AD. In a few cases swollen cortical neurons are a feature of disease that would otherwise be pathologically typical of AD. Care should be taken to ensure that the case does not meet criteria for CBD (see Chapter 28, and below) and that grain pathology is not present (p. 639).
AD with other degenerative diseases. AD pathology can occur in association with other degenerative diseases such as Parkinson’s disease, Huntington’s disease, Pick’s disease or prion disease.
AD with vascular disease. There may be ischemic or hemorrhagic disease due to the cerebral and cerebellar amyloid angiopathy in AD (see Chapter 10), and AD is often associated with atherosclerotic and/or arteriosclerotic vascular disease of the brain; a diagnosis of mixed AD and vascular dementia is appropriate in some cases.