Visual-aid questions

Published on 14/03/2015 by admin

Filed under Emergency Medicine

Last modified 14/03/2015

Print this page

rate 1 star rate 2 star rate 3 star rate 4 star rate 5 star
Your rating: none, Average: 0 (0 votes)

This article have been viewed 1756 times

Chapter 4 Visual-aid questions

The visual-aid question (VAQ) section is one of the more challenging components of the exam. Candidates who spend time preparing themselves for this style of examination are more likely to be successful.

Format

There are eight questions to be answered in one hour, allowing approximately seven and a half minutes to answer each question. In addition, 10 minutes of reading time is allocated at the beginning of the exam during which no writing is permitted.

For visual aids, expect at least one ECG, one laboratory result (often an arterial blood gas and one other item), one plain radiograph (+/– other radiology) and some clinical photos. At least one question will relate to paediatrics and another will relate to trauma. Because VAQs can cover the whole syllabus, anything can be presented. There has been a drift away from using photographs of equipment or therapies in favour of clinical conditions, but any clinically relevant photograph could be included.

Each question starts with a ‘stem’ that provides background information about the case. All the information provided in the stem is important to the case and should be incorporated in your answer. Every word is there for a reason. Read carefully!

The questions may be individual or divided into two or occasionally three parts. Each part is designated a percentage of the total marks — be aware of this when answering the question. You are more likely to score well if you write three pages on the section worth 70% and one page on the section worth 30% than if you do the opposite. In many cases, the first part of the question will ask you to interpret the available data. Include as much relevant and correct information as you can. Even things that may appear self-evident can score points.

The question types can be expected to vary, and trends change and evolve over time. The questions are prepared by the members of the VAQ Subcommittee of the Fellowship Examination Committee. The examiners are assigned questions to mark and so have no prior knowledge of the questions, which ensures that they are not marking in areas where they are experts. Each question is marked by two examiners who are blinded to each other’s marks until they make contact and agree on the final mark.

Preparation

Like much of the fellowship exam, there is a breathtakingly broad range of topics that could be examined in the VAQs. General preparation by methodically working through the full curriculum is important.

Because the questions are prepared by FACEMs, it is reasonable to expect that images will be sourced from the departments they work in. As images and laboratory results become available, the ‘bank’ of questions will be developed to cover the curriculum. With this in mind and remembering the principle of what is ‘common’ and ‘commonly deadly’, it is possible to anticipate the important questions. Table 4.1 outlines likely VAQ topics that require most attention in your preparation. Many of these have featured in previous examinations and are likely to be used again. Other pathologies you need to be familiar with are presented in the right-hand column.

TABLE 4.1 Common VAQs

Visual aid Likely VAQ topics Other VAQ topics
ECGs

Arterial blood gases Electrolyte profiles Haematology profiles
Microbiology results Biochemistry results Chest X-rays Cervical spine images
Abdominal X-rays Limb X-rays CT head scans CT neck CT thorax
CT abdominal scans MRI V/Q scan   Ultrasound Adult clinical images Paediatric clinical images Equipment Other images  

Sample VAQs can be sourced in a number of ways. A small number can be obtained from the College website or your DEMT, or your colleagues can write some for you, but the best way to prepare for this section of the examination is to write some VAQs yourself. We strongly encourage you to work your way through the topics in Table 4.1 to become familiar with the images and/or laboratory results associated with these conditions. The process of identifying suitable material that lends itself well to VAQs is excellent exam preparation.

Google Images (images.google.com.au) can help you to easily find images pertaining to virtually any condition — including clinical photographs, radiological images and abnormal ECGs. In addition, excellent collections of thousands of emergency medicine-related clinical photographs, covering all subspecialty areas, are available in atlases such as:

Once you have selected your images and/or laboratory results and made up your questions, spend some time practising writing your answers. Remember to think as the examiners would when considering your responses. The examiners have not selected the questions and do not know the cases themselves, so they do not have any ‘hidden agenda’ or other special knowledge. You see what they see, so answer as they would, as a ‘real’ FACEM.

When practising VAQs, it is worthwhile doing them under exam conditions wherever possible. Do at least four in a sitting and include a proportional amount of preparation time (i.e. five minutes’ reading time (without writing) for four VAQs). Ask someone to mark them for you —preferably an examiner or DEMT, but otherwise other FACEMs or your study buddies.

As with other sections of the exam, you can incorporate your day-to-day practice into your preparation for the VAQ section. Each time a nurse, medical student, junior doctor or consultant asks you to interpret an ECG, an X-ray or a pathology result or you see a patient where the diagnosis can be made on initial inspection, you have an opportunity to practise your VAQ answering skills.

On the day

Answering the questions

Seven and a half minutes is a short time to impart as much information as you know for each question. However, the questions are designed to be answered in this time frame by asking you to address specific issues.

Ensure that you answer the question that is asked using the College’s glossary of definitions. The wording is deliberately chosen, and details such as age, gender, the specific location of symptoms and whether conditions are isolated or not are all important considerations for your answer. Pay special attention to whether you are asked about ‘investigations’ or ‘management’ and so on to ensure you answer appropriately: you will not score points by answering about management when investigations have been requested.

Structure your answers in such a way that they are as easy to understand and provide as much information as possible in a readable and interpretable format. Legibility and rational organisation of your answers cannot be overemphasised. Point-form answers using standard abbreviations are preferred as they allow you to say more and are easier for the examiners to read. Inclusion of tables, flow charts and diagrams is also encouraged, as they can present substantial amounts of information efficiently and in a visual format that makes it easy for the examiners to find the relevant information.

Where appropriate, include a very brief synopsis with headings at the beginning of your answer to remind you of the key elements and to minimise omissions of important information. It is also a good idea to write on every second line, so that you can easily insert any information you recall later.

Use the experience you have gained from sitting practice VAQs. It is not uncommon to have tackled one or more similar VAQs during your preparation. Be aware, however, of subtle differences in the way the questions are asked. The most commonly cited reasons for candidates failing VAQs are failure to answer the question asked and/or providing ‘general’ answers to a specific question (e.g. discussing general trauma management when told the injury is an isolated one). Answer the question that is asked, not what you would like it to be!

Sample VAQs

To help with your preparation, some worked sample VAQs have been provided. Draw on these as a framework to develop your own practice VAQs, using the topics in Table 4.1 as a guide. In addition, a range of VAQ props are presented as ‘problems’ for you to ponder with sample questions. We suggest that you use these to develop further questions using standard terminology and then write full answers using the templates suggested in Table 3.2 (see pages 25–27). Suggested answers to some of these questions are provided towards the end of the chapter. A broad range of material is included. Some items are presented to stimulate you to cover topics that may otherwise be glossed over (e.g. therapies and equipment that are now less likely to be assessed as VAQs, but are most easily studied using this format and may be examined in other sections of the exam).

VAQ 1

Sample answer

The image shows an open fracture/dislocation of the right ankle.

VAQ 2

VAQ 3

  Value Normal range
pH 6.80 7.32–7.43
pCO2 36 mmHg 37–50 mmHg
pO2 47 mmHg 36–44 mmHg
Bicarbonate 6 mmol/L 22–28 mmol/L
Base excess –28 mmol/L –3 to 3 mmol/L
Sodium 136 mmol/L 134–146 mmol/L
Potassium 6.7 mmol/L 3.4–5.0 mmol/L
Chloride 90 mmol/L 98–108 mmol/L
Urea 13.8 mmol/L 3.0–8.0 mmol/L
Creatinine 210 μmol/L < 105 μmol/L
Glucose 54.0 mmol/L 3.0–5.4 mmol/L

A 78-year-old woman is brought to ED with a history of increasing confusion over a period of four days. Venous blood gas and U&E results are shown to you by the resident assessing her.

Describe and interpret her listed investigations. (100%)

VAQ 4

Sample answer

An introductory differential diagnosis places the history, examination and investigations into context.

Differential diagnosis

VAQ 8

O2via nasal cannulae 2 L/min Value Reference range
pH 7.13 7.35–7.45
CO2 7 mmHg 36–45 mmHg
O2 146 mmHg 8–110 mmHg
Bicarbonate < 3 mmol/L 21–28 mmol/L
Glucose 15.7 mmol/L 3.0–5.4 mmol/L
Lactate 4.3 mmol/L < 1.3 mmol/L
Sodium 142 mmol/L 134–146 mmol/L
Potassium 5.2 mmol/L 3.4–5.0 mmol/L
Chloride 103 mmol/L 98–108 mmol/L
Urea 2.4 mmol/L 3.0–8.0 mmol/L
Creatinine 107 μmol/L < 120 μmol/L

A 39-year-old Indonesian sailor is brought to ED by the ship’s first mate with a history of vomiting, visual disturbance and increasing confusion over a period of three days. Some of his investigations, including arterial blood gases, are shown above.

(a) Describe and interpret the investigations shown. (50%)

Buy Membership for Emergency Medicine Category to continue reading. Learn more here