Trichloroacetic Acid (TCA) Peels

Published on 15/03/2015 by admin

Filed under Dermatology

Last modified 15/03/2015

Print this page

This article have been viewed 16050 times

7 Trichloroacetic Acid (TCA) Peels

Janie M. Leonhardt, Kathleen M. Rossy, Naomi Lawrence

Introduction

Chemical peels have been documented in American medical literature since Eller and Wolff described their use for treatment of blemishes and pitted scars of the face in 1941. Since that time, physicians have expanded the indications for chemical peels and advanced the understanding of the physiologic effect of these agents. Chemical peels are now commonly used to remove damaged skin and to promote regeneration and improvement in quality and overall texture of the skin. Chemical peels are classified according to their depth of penetration. Superficial peels are those reaching, at greatest depth, the superficial papillary dermis. Medium-depth peels are those reaching the papillary to reticular dermis, and deep peels extending to the mid-reticular dermis. Trichloroacetic acid (TCA) may be used for tissue penetration of superficial and medium-depths, depending on the concentration (Table 7.1). For superficial peels, TCA should be between 10% and 25% concentration. For medium-depth peels, most experienced physicians will use a concentration of 35% combined with another agent, and no greater than 40% since concentrations of 50% are known to impart a much greater risk of scarring, pigment dyschromia and undesired textural change. See Box 7.1.

Table 7.1 Chemical peel agents

Peel type	Agent
Superficial	TCA 10–25% Jessner’s solution Glycolic acid
Medium	TCA 35–50% Solid CO₂ + TCA 35% Glycolic acid 70% + TCA 35% Jessner’s solution + TCA 35%
Deep	Phenol peel

Box 7.1

Key features

• It has been shown that rubbing alcohol, chlorhexidine gluconate and acetone are equally efficacious in the prepeel skin preparation

• The end-point of a superficial peel with TCA is speckled white frost

Selection of Peel Type

Choosing the correct concentration for the desired indication in any one patient requires consideration of the following factors: what is desired by the patient, photoaging classification by the physician, Fitzpatrick sun-reactive skin type classification, sebaceous quality of the skin, presence of inflammation (seborrhea, retinoid dermatitis, etc.), and skin translucency. (The more translucent the skin and more inflammation present, the more likely the patient will convert from a superficial to a medium-depth peel.) Indications for superficial peels include treatment of melasma, comedonal acne, and improvement of overall skin reflectiveness, texture, and tone. The use of superficial peels for actinic damage is controversial and some studies suggest that the improvement of actinic damage using superficial peels is no greater than that achieved by using topical glycolic products or topical retinoids alone. Indications for a medium-depth peel include reversal of actinic damage, including removal of actinic keratoses and other epidermal lesions, reduction of rhytides, removal of dyschromia, and improvement of atrophic scarring (Figs 7.1 and 7.2).

Figure 7.1 (A), Patient with generalized dyschromia and actinic damage prior to a medium-depth peel. (B), Patient 2 weeks following a medium-depth peel (Jessner’s solution with 35% trichloroacetic acid (TCA) combination). Note significant improvement of dyschromia and fine lines

Figure 7.2 (A), Histology of the skin prior to a medium-depth peel. Histology of the skin 6 months (B) and 12 months (C) following one medium-depth peel (Jessner’s solution with 35% TCA combination)

• Superficial peels

For superficial peels, patients who belong to Glogau classification for photoaging types I and II are most appropriate (Box 7.2). Severe photodamage with resultant hyperkeratosis and parakeratosis creates a barrier to peel penetration and will minimize the effect of any peeling agent. This can make using only a superficial peeling agent almost totally ineffective. It is therefore recommended that a retinoid be used to pretreat the area and increase the penetration of the peel. With regards to sun-reactive skin types, Fitzpatrick types IV, V, and VI are most prone to developing postinflammatory hyperpigmentation (Table 7.2). Pretreatment with tretinoin and hydroquinone may minimize this effect and can be particularly helpful in type IV, where the hyperpigmentation may be the most noticeable compared to their normal skin tone. Topical ascorbic acid has also been used as a priming agent and has been found to be beneficial in decreasing pigmentation. Soliman et al (2007) reported a significant improvement in melasma patients who were pretreated with topical 5% ascorbic acid prior to a superficial peel with 20% TCA. With adequate patient education, patients with darker complexions can safely undergo superficial peels without risk of permanent color change as hyperpigmentation fades over time and with treatment. Oily, thickened, sebaceous skin may lead to uneven and less effective superficial peeling. Peel response may be improved with the use of pretreatment tretinoin on a daily basis combined with alpha-hydroxy acids (10–20%) used as a daily cream, lotion or gel. In addition, a more vigorous skin preparation may be used to enhance peel absorption. In contrast, there are patients, usually women, who have paper-thin skin with a translucent quality. These patients are at an increased risk for conversion to a medium-depth peel with superficial peeling agents and should have their skin preparation and skin pretreatment performed cautiously. Other patients who deserve caution are those with seborrhea and other types of dermatitis (retinoid, etc.) Inflammation in the skin is known to enhance uptake of the peel solution and result in a deeper than expected peel.

Box 7.2

Glogau’s classification of photoaging

Group I: Mild (usually aged 28–35 years)

• No keratoses

• Little wrinkling

• No scarring

• Little or no make-up

Group II: Moderate (usually aged 35–50 years)

• Early actinic keratoses – slight yellow skin discoloration

• Early wrinkling-parallel smile lines

• Mild scarring

• Small amount of make-up

Group III: Advanced (usually aged 50–65 years)

• Actinic keratoses – obvious yellow skin discoloration with telangiectasias

• Wrinkling present at rest

• Moderate acne scarring

• Wears make-up always

Group IV: Severe (usually aged 60–75 years)

• Actinic keratoses and skin cancers have occurred

• Wrinkling: much cutis laxa of actinic, gravitational, and dynamic origin

• Severe acne scarring

• Wears make-up that does not cover, but cakes on

Based on Glogau (1994)

Table 7.2 Fitzpatrick’s classification of sun-reactive skin types

Skin type	Color	Reaction to first summer exposure
I	White	Always burn, never tan
II	White	Usually burn, tan with difficulty
III	White	Sometimes mild burn, tan average
IV	Moderate brown	Rarely burn, tan with ease
V	Dark brown*	Very rarely burn, tan very easily
VI	Black	No burn, tan very easily