Overview of Bacterial Identification Methods and Strategies

Published on 08/02/2015 by admin

Filed under Basic Science

Last modified 22/04/2025

Print this page

rate 1 star rate 2 star rate 3 star rate 4 star rate 5 star
Your rating: none, Average: 0 (0 votes)

This article have been viewed 6774 times

Overview of Bacterial Identification Methods and Strategies

Rationale for Approaching Organism Identification

It is challenging to determine how most effectively to present and teach diagnostic microbiology in a way that is sufficiently comprehensive and yet not excessively cluttered with rare and seldom-needed facts about bacterial species uncommonly encountered. Approximately 530 different bacterial species or taxa are reported by clinical microbiology laboratories across the United States (Figure 13-1). Yet 95% of the bacterial identifications reported are distributed across only 27 of these taxa. This is an indication of how infrequently the other 500 or more taxa are identified and reported. Therefore, although the chapters in Part III, Bacteriology, are intended to be comprehensive in terms of the variety of bacterial species presented, it is helpful to keep in perspective which taxa are most likely to be encountered in the clinical environment. The relative frequencies with which the common bacterial species and organism groups are reported in clinical laboratories are presented in Figure 13-2.

Historically, most chapters in microbiology texts have been organized by genus name; however, they failed to provide information and processes needed to understand what is involved in analyzing information from the clinical specimen to the identification of the correct genus. Many texts (including this one) provide flow charts containing algorithms or identification schemes for organism workup. Although these are helpful, one must be aware of the limitations of flow charts. In some cases they may be too general to be helpful; that is, they may lack sufficient detail to be useful for discriminating among key microbial groups and species. In other cases, they may be too esoteric to be of practical use in routine clinical practice (e.g., identification schemes based on cellular analysis of fatty acid analysis). In addition, many other criteria that must be incorporated into the identification process are too complex to be included in most flow charts. Thus, flow charts are only one of many tools used in the field of diagnostic microbiology.

Also, as discussed later in this chapter, organism taxonomy and profiles continuously change. Detailed flow charts are at risk of quickly becoming outdated. Furthermore, as is evident throughout the chapters in Part III, diagnostic microbiology is full of exceptions to rules, and flow charts are not constructed in a manner that readily captures many of the important exceptions.

To meet the challenges of bacterial identification processes beyond what can be portrayed in flow charts, the chapters in Part III have been arranged to guide the student through the entire workup of a microorganism, beginning with initial culture of the specimen. In most instances, the first information a microbiologist uses in the identification process is the macroscopic description of the colony, or colony morphology. This includes the type of hemolysis (if any), pigment (if present), size, texture (opaque, translucent, or transparent), adherence to agar, pitting of agar, and many other characteristics (see Chapter 7). After careful observation of the colony, the Gram stain is used to separate the organism into a variety of broad categories based on Gram stain reaction and the cellular morphology of gram-positive or gram-negative bacteria (e.g., gram-positive cocci, gram-negative rods; see Chapter 6). For gram-positive organisms, the catalase test should follow the Gram stain, and testing on gram-negative organisms should begin with the oxidase test. These simple tests, plus growth on MacConkey agar, if the isolate is a gram-negative rod or coccobacillus, help the microbiologist assign the organism to one of the primary categories (organized here as subsections). Application of the various identification methods and systems outlined in this chapter generate the data and criteria discussed in each chapter for the definitive identification of clinically relevant bacteria. Most of the procedures described in the following chapters can be found at the end of this chapter. In this chapter, each procedure includes a photograph of positive and negative reactions. Chapter 6 includes photographs of some commonly used bacteriologic stains. In addition, Table 13-1 lists several commonly used commercial identification systems for a variety of the microorganisms discussed in the following pages.

TABLE 13-1

Examples of Commercial Identification Systems for Various Organisms

Organism Group System Type Manufacturer Incubation Time
Enterobacteriaceae Manual:
 API 20E bioMérieux* 24-48 hr
 API Rapid 20E bioMérieux 4 hr
 Crystal Enteric/Nonfermenter Becton Dickinson Diagnostic Systems 18 hr
 RapID ONE Remel 4 hr
Automated:
 GNI bioMérieux 4-13 hr
 GNI+ bioMérieux 2-12 hr
 NEG ID Type 2 Dade MicroScan§ 15-42 hr
 Rapid NEG ID Type 3 Dade MicroScan 2.5 hr
 Sensititre AP80 Trek Diagnostic Systems 5-18 hr
Enterococcus spp. and Streptococcus spp. Manual:
 API 20 Strep bioMérieux 4-24 hr
 RapID STR Remel 4 hr
 Crystal Gram-Positive ID Becton Dickinson Diagnostic Systems 18 hr
Automated:
 GPI bioMérieux 2-15 hr
 Pos ID2 Dade MicroScan 18-48 hr
 Sensititre AP90 Trek Diagnostic Systems 24 hr
Haemophilus spp. Manual:
 API NH bioMérieux 2 hr
 RapID NH Remel 4 hr
 NHI bioMérieux 4 hr
 Crystal Neisseria/Haemophilus Becton Dickinson Diagnostic Systems 4 hr
Automated:
 HNID Dade MicroScan 4 hr
Neisseria spp. and Moraxella catarrhalis Manual:
 API NH bioMérieux 2 hr
 RapID NH Remel 4 hr
 NHI bioMérieux 4 hr
 Crystal Neisseria/Haemophilus Becton Dickinson Diagnostic Systems 4 hr
Automated:
 HNID Dade MicroScan 4 hr
Nonenteric gram-negative rods Manual:
 API 20NE bioMérieux 24-48 hr
 Crystal Enteric/Nonfermenter Becton Dickinson Diagnostic Systems 18-20 hr
 RapID NF Plus Remel 4 hr
Automated:
 GNI bioMérieux 2-18 hr
 NEG ID Type 2 Dade MicroScan 15-42 hr
 Sensititre AP80 Trek Diagnostic Systems 5-18 hr
Staphylococcus spp. Manual:
 API STAPH bioMérieux 24 hr
 Crystal Gram-Positive Becton Dickinson Diagnostic Systems 18-24 hr
Automated:
 GPI bioMérieux 2-15 hr
 Pos ID2 Date MicroScan 24-48 hr
Coryneform rods Manual:
 API Coryne bioMérieux 24 hr
 RapID CB Plus Remel 4 hr
 Crystal Gram-Positive Becton Dickinson Diagnostic Systems 18-24 hr
Automated:
 GPI bioMérieux 2-15 hr

image

*Durham, N.C.: www.bioMerieux-Vitek.com

Sparks, Md.: www.bectondickinson.com

Lenexa, Kan.: www.remelinc.com

§West Sacramento, Calif.: www.dadebehring.com

Westlake, Ohio: www.trekds.com

Because diagnostic microbiology is centered around the identification of organisms based on common phenotypic traits shared with known members of the same genus or family, microbiologists “play the odds” every day by finding the best biochemical “fit” and assigning the most probable identification. For example, the gram-negative rod known as CDC group EF-4a may be considered with either MacConkey-positive or MacConkey-negative organisms, because it grows on MacConkey agar 50% of the time. Therefore, although CDC group EF-4a has been arbitrarily assigned to the section on oxidase-positive, MacConkey-positive, gram-negative bacilli and coccobacilli in this text, it is also included in the discussion of oxidase-positive, MacConkey-negative, gram-negative bacilli and coccobacilli. This example clearly demonstrates the limitations of solely depending on flow charts for the identification process.

The identification process often can be arduous and a drain on resources. Laboratorians must make every effort to identify only those organisms most likely to be involved in the infection process. To that end, the chapters in Part III have also been designed to provide guidance for determining whether a clinical isolate is relevant and requires full identification. Furthermore, the clinical diagnosis and the source of the specimen can help determine which group of organisms to consider. For example, if a patient has endocarditis or the specimen source is blood and a small, gram-negative rod is observed on Gram stain, the microbiologist should consider a group of gram-negative bacilli known as the HACEK (Aggrega-tibacter [formerly the aphrophilus group of Haemophilus and Actinobacillus], Cardiobacterium hominis, Eikenella corrodens, and Kingella spp.), which are not commonly encountered in clinical specimens. Similarly, if a patient has suffered an animal bite, the microbiologist should think of Pasteurella multocida if the isolate is gram negative and Staphylococcus hyicus and Staphylococcus intermedius if the organism is gram positive. Finally, in consideration of an isolate’s clinical relevance, each chapter also provides information on whether antimicrobial susceptibility testing is indicated and, if needed, the way it should be performed.

Future Trends of Organism Identification

Several dynamics are involved in clinical microbiology and infectious diseases that continue to challenge bacterial identification practices. For instance, new species associated with human infections will continue to be discovered, and well-known species may change their characteristics, affecting the criteria used to identify them. For these reasons, identification schemes and strategies for both conventional methods and commercial systems must be continually reviewed and updated. Also, although most identification schemes are based on the phenotypic characteristics of bacteria, the use of molecular and advanced chemical methods (e.g., matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry) to detect, identify, and characterize bacteria continues to expand and play a greater role in diagnostic microbiology. In addition, phenotypic, molecular, and advanced chemical methods increasingly will become incorporated into simpler automated systems.

Procedure 13-3   Bacitracin Susceptibility

Procedure 13-7   CAMP Test

Procedure 13-8   Catalase Test

Procedure 13-10   Citrate Utilization

Procedure 13-11   Coagulase Test

Procedure 13-12   Decarboxylase Tests (Moeller’s Method)

Method

Procedure 13-13   DNA Hydrolysis (DNase Test Agar)

Procedure 13-15   Fermentation Media

Principle

Carbohydrate fermentation is the process microorganisms use to produce energy. Most microorganisms convert glucose to pyruvate during glycolysis; however, some organisms use alternate pathways. A fermentation medium consists of a basal medium containing a single carbohydrate (glucose, lactose, or sucrose) for fermentation. However, the medium may contain various color indicators, such as Andrade’s indicator, bromocresol, or others. In addition to a color indicator to detect the production of acid from fermentation, a Durham tube is placed in each tube to capture gas produced by metabolism.

Basal media: Pancreatic digest of casein (10 g), beef extract (3 g), NaCl (5 g), carbohydrate (10 g), specific indicator (Andrade’s indicator [10 mL, pH 7.4] or bromocresol purple [0.02 g, pH 6.8]).

Expected Results

Procedure 13-16   Flagella Stain (Wet Mount Technique)

Method

1. Grow the organism to be stained at room temperature on blood agar for 16 to 24 hours.

2. Add a small drop of water to a microscope slide.

3. Dip a sterile inoculating loop into sterile water.

4. Touch the loopful of water to the colony margin briefly (this allows motile cells to swim into the droplet of water).

5. Touch the loopful of motile cells to the drop of water on the slide. Note: Agitating the loop in the droplet of water on the slide causes the flagella to shear off the cell.

6. Cover the faintly turbid drop of water on the slide with a cover slip. A proper wet mount has barely enough liquid to fill the space under a cover slip. Small air spaces around the edge are preferable.

7. Examine the slide immediately under 40× to 50× for motile cells. If motile cells are not seen, do not proceed with the stain.

8. If motile cells are seen, leave the slide at room temperature for 5 to 10 minutes. This allows the bacterial cells time to adhere either to the glass slide or to the cover slip.

9. Gently apply 2 drops of RYU flagella stain (Remel, Lenexa, Kansas) to the edge of the cover slip. The stain will flow by capillary action and mix with the cell suspension. Small air pockets around the edge of the wet mount are useful in aiding the capillary action.

10. After 5 to 10 minutes at room temperature, examine the cells for flagella.

11. Cells with flagella may be observed at 100× (oil) in the zone of optimum stain concentration, about halfway from the edge of the cover slip to the center of the mount.

12. Focusing the microscope on the cells attached to the cover slip rather than on the cells attached to the slide facilitates visualization of the flagella. The precipitate from the stain is primarily on the slide rather than the cover slip.

Procedure 13-17   Gelatin Hydrolysis

Procedure 13-20   Indole Production

Principle

The test is used to determine an organism’s ability to hydrolyze tryptophan to form the compound indole. Tryptophan is present in casein and animal protein. Bacteria with tryptophanase are capable of hydrolyzing tryptophan to pyruvate, ammonia, and indole. Kovac’s reagent (dimethylamine-benzaldehyde and hydrochloride), when added to the broth culture, reacts with the indole, producing a red color. An alternative method uses Ehrlich’s reagent. Ehrlich’s reagent has the same chemicals as the Kovac preparation, but it also contains absolute ethyl alcohol, making it flammable. Ehrlich’s reagent is more sensitive for detecting small amounts of indole. (The spot indole test is described in Procedure 13-39.)

Media: Casein peptone (10 g), NaCl (5 g), tryptophan (10 g), per 1000 mL.

Procedure 13-22   Litmus Milk Medium

Expected Results

Appearance of Indicator (Litmus Dye)

Color pH Change to … Record
Pink, mauve (Figure 13-24, A) Acid Acid (A)
Blue (Figure 13-24, B) Alkaline Alkaline (K)
Purple (identical to uninoculated control) (Figure 13-24, C) No change No change
White (Figure 13-24, D) Independent of pH change; result of reduction of indicator Decolorized

Appearance of Milk

Consistency of Milk Occurs When pH Is … Record
Coagulation or clot (Figure 13-24, E) Acid or alkaline Clot
Dissolution of clot with clear, grayish, watery fluid and a shrunken, insoluble pink clot (Figure 13-24, F) Acid Digestion
Dissolution of clot with grayish, watery fluid and a clear, shrunken, insoluble blue clot Alkaline Peptonization

Procedure 13-23   Lysine Iron Agar (LIA)

Principle

Lysine iron agar contains lysine, peptones, a small amount of glucose, ferric ammonium citrate, and sodium thiosulfate. The medium has an aerobic slant and an anaerobic butt. When glucose is fermented, the butt of the medium becomes acidic (yellow). If the organism produces lysine decarboxylase, cadaverine is formed. Cadaverine neutralizes the organic acids formed by glucose fermentation, and the butt of the medium reverts to the alkaline state (purple). If the decarboxylase is not produced, the butt remains acidic (yellow). If oxidative deamination of lysine occurs, a compound is formed that, in the presence of ferric ammonium citrate and a coenzyme, flavin mononucleotide, forms a burgundy color on the slant. If deamination does not occur, the LIA slant remains purple. Bromocresol purple, the pH indicator, is yellow at or below pH 5.2 and purple at or above pH 6.8.

Media: Enzymatic digest of gelatin (5 g), yeast extract (3 g), dextrose (1 g), L-lysine (10 g), ferric ammonium citrate (0.5 g), sodium thiosulfate (0.04 g), bromocresol purple (0.02 g), agar (13.5 g), per 1000 mL, pH 6.7.

Procedure 13-24   Methyl Red/Voges-Proskauer (Mrvp) Tests

Principle

This test is used to determine the ability of an organism to produce and maintain stable acid end products from glucose fermentation, to overcome the buffering capacity of the system, and to determine the ability of some organisms to produce neutral end products (e.g., 2,3-butanediol or acetoin) from glucose fermentation. The methyl red detects mixed acid fermentation that lowers the pH of the broth. The MR indicator is added after incubation. Methyl red is red at pH 4.4 and yellow at pH 6.2. A clear red is a positive result; yellow is a negative result; and various shades of orange are negative or inconclusive. The VP detects the organism’s ability to convert the acid products to acetoin and 2,3-butanediol. Organisms capable of using the VP pathway produce a smaller amount of acid during glucose fermentation and therefore do not produce a color change when the methyl red indicator is added. A secondary reagent is added, alpha-naphthol, followed by potassium hydroxide (KOH); a positive test result is indicated by a red color complex.

Media: Peptic digest of animal tissue (3.5 g), pancreatic digest of casein (3.5 g), dextrose (5 g), KPO4 (5 g), per 1000 mL, pH 6.9.

Procedure 13-28   4-Methylumbelliferyl-β-D-Glucuronide (MUG) Test

Procedure 13-29   Nitrate Reduction

Principle

Anaerobic metabolism requires an electron acceptor other than atmospheric oxygen (O2). Many gram-negative bacteria use nitrate as the final electron acceptor. The organisms produce nitrate reductase, which converts the nitrate (NO3) to nitrite (NO2). The reduction of nitrate to nitrite is determined by adding sulfanilic acid and alpha-naphthylamine. The sulfanilic acid and nitrite react to form a diazonium salt. The diazonium salt then couples with the alpha-naphthylamine to produce a red, water-soluble azo dye. If no color change occurs, the organism did not reduce nitrate or reduced it further to NH3, NO, or N2O2. Zinc is added at this point; if nitrate remains, the zinc will reduce the compound to nitrite and the reaction will turn positive, indicating a negative test result for nitrate reduction by the organism. If no color change occurs after the addition of zinc, this indicates that the organism reduced nitrate to one of the other nitrogen compounds previously described. A Durham tube is placed in the broth for two reasons: (1) to detect deterioration of the broth before inoculation, as evidenced by gas formation in the tube; and (2) to identify denitrification by organisms that produce gas by alternate pathways; if gas is formed in the tube before the addition of the color indicator, the test result is negative for nitrate reduction by this method.

Media: Pancreatic digest of gelatin (20 g), KNO3 (2 g), per 1000 mL.

Method

1. Inoculate nitrate broth (Figure 13-31, D) with 1 to 2 drops from a young broth culture of the test organism.

2. Incubate for 48 hours at 35°-37°C in ambient air (some organisms may require longer incubation for adequate growth). Test these cultures 24 hours after obvious growth is detected or after a maximum of 7 days.

3. After a suitable incubation period, test the nitrate broth culture for the presence of gas, reduction of nitrate, and reduction of nitrite according to the following steps:

Expected Results

The nitrate reduction test is read for the presence or absence of three metabolic products: gas, nitrate (NO3), and nitrite (NO2). The expected results can be summarized as follows:

Reaction Gas Color after Addition of Solutions A and B Color after Addition of Zinc Interpretation
NO3 → NO2 (Figure 13-31, A) None Red NO3+, no gas
NO3 → NO2, gas partial nongaseous end products None Red NO3+, no
NO3 → NO2, gaseous end products (Figure 13-31, B) Yes Red NO3+, gas+
NO3 → gaseous end product (Figure 13-31, C) Yes None None NO3+, NO2+, gas+ C)
NO3 → nongaseous end products None None None NO3+, NO2+, no gas
NO3 → no reaction None None Red Negative

image

Procedure 13-30   Nitrite Reduction

Procedure 13-32   Optochin (P disk) Susceptibility Test

Procedure 13-33   Oxidase Test (Kovac’s Method)

Procedure 13-34   Oxidation/Fermentation (of) Medium (CDC Method)

Principle

This test is used to determine whether an organism uses carbohydrate substrates to produce acid byproducts. Nonfermentative bacteria are routinely tested for their ability to produce acid from six carbohydrates (glucose, xylose, mannitol, lactose, sucrose, and maltose). In addition to the six tubes containing carbohydrates, a control tube containing the OF base without carbohydrate is also inoculated. Triple sugar iron agar (TSI) (see Procedure 13-40) is also used to determine whether an organism can ferment glucose. OF glucose is used to determine whether an organism ferments (Figure 13-36, A) or oxidizes (Figure 13-36, B) glucose. If no reaction occurs in either the TSI or OF glucose, the organism is considered a non-glucose utilizer (Figure 13-36, C). Hugh and Leifson’s formula uses a low peptone-to-carbohydrate ratio and a limiting amount of carbohydrate. The reduced peptone limits the formation of alkaline amines that may mask acid production resulting from oxidative metabolism. Two tubes are required for interpretation of the OF test. Both are inoculated, and one tube is overlaid with mineral oil, producing an anaerobic environment. Production of acid in the overlaid tube results in a color change and is an indication of fermentation. Acid production in the open tube and color change is the result of oxidation. Media: Pancreatic digest of casein (2 g), glycerol (10.0 mL), phenol red (King method) (0.03 g), agar (3 g), per 1000 mL, pH 7.3.

Expected Results

Positive: Acid production (A) is indicated by the color indicator changing to yellow in the carbohydrate-containing deep.

Weak-positive (Aw): Weak acid formation can be detected by comparing the tube containing the medium with carbohydrate with the inoculated tube containing medium with no carbohydrate. Most bacteria that can grow in the OF base produce an alkaline reaction in the control tube. If the color of the medium in a tube containing carbohydrate remains about the same as it was before the medium was inoculated and if the inoculated medium in the control tube becomes a deeper red (i.e., becomes alkaline), the culture being tested is considered weakly positive, assuming the amount of growth is about the same in both tubes.

Negative: Red or alkaline (K) color in the deep with carbohydrate equal to the color of the inoculated control tube.

No change (NC) or neutral (N): There is growth in the media, but neither the carbohydrate-containing medium nor the control base turns alkaline (red).

Note: If the organism does not grow at all in the OF medium, mark the reaction as no growth (NG).

Procedure 13-40   Triple Sugar Iron Agar (TSI)

Principle

The composition of TSI is 10 parts lactose:10 parts sucrose:1 part glucose and peptone. Phenol red and ferrous sulfate serve as indicators of acidification and H2S formation, respectively. A glucose-fermenting organism turns the entire medium acidic (yellow) in 8 to 12 hours. The butt remains acidic after the recommended 18- to 24-hour incubation period because of the presence of organic acids resulting from the fermentation of glucose under anaerobic conditions in the butt of the tube. The slant, however, reverts to the alkaline (red) state because of oxidation of the fermentation products under aerobic conditions on the slant. This change is a result of the formation of CO2 and H2O and the oxidation of peptones in the medium to alkaline amines. When, in addition to glucose, lactose and/or sucrose are fermented, the large amount of fermentation products formed on the slant neutralizes the alkaline amines and renders the slant acidic (yellow), provided the reaction is read in 18 to 24 hours. Reactions in TSI should not be read beyond 24 hours of incubation, because aerobic oxidation of the fermentation products from lactose and/or sucrose proceeds, and the slant eventually reverts to the alkaline state. The formation of CO2 and hydrogen gas (H2) is indicated by the presence of bubbles or cracks in the agar or by separation of the agar from the sides or bottom of the tube. The production of H2S (sodium thiosulfate reduced to H2S) requires an acidic environment, and reaction with the ferric ammonium citrate produces a blackening of the agar butt in the tube.

Media: Enzymatic digest of casein (5 g), enzymatic digest of animal tissue (5 g), yeast-enriched peptone (10 g), dextrose (1 g), lactose (10 g) sucrose (10 g), ferric ammonium citrate (0.2 g), NaCl (5 g), sodium thiosulfate (0.3 g), phenol red (0.025 g), agar (13.5 g), per 1000 mL, pH 7.3.

Procedure 13-41   Urease Test (Christensen’s Method)

Procedure 13-42   X and V Factor Test