Chapter 36 Meningiomas
• Meningiomas are believed to derive from the arachnoid cap cells around arachnoid granulations near venous sinuses, cisterns, ventricles, and brain. They can be found anywhere there is known pia, arachnoid, or dura. These tumors exhibit a wide variety of behaviors from benign to extremely aggressive. The etiology of meningiomas is unclear but some are associated with genetic aberrations such as partial loss of chromosome 22, prior trauma, and radiation therapy.
• The latest World Health Organization (WHO) grading system of meningiomas evaluates these neoplasms from grades I to III. Grade I meningiomas have nine subtypes ranging from fibroblastic to psammomatous. Despite the different histological patterns there is no prognostic significance among the subtypes of grade I meningioma. Grade II represents an atypical meningioma and implies the presence of mitosis, or three or more of such features as increased cellularity, brain invasion, or necrosis. Grade III anaplastic malignant meningiomas are characterized by highly active mitosis, and their tumor cells resemble carcinoma or sarcoma. Metastases are rare in meningioma but can occur in the lungs, liver, bone, and heart.
• The treatment of meningiomas depends on a variety of factors such as their growth rate, radiological characteristics, location, and patient clinical status and age. The advent of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) has brought the age of more incidentally diagnosed lesions. The natural history of meningiomas varies, as do the growth rates. Some incidentally discovered meningiomas remain stable and can be observed, especially in elderly patients with few symptoms or signs. Meningiomas are symptomatic in a wide range of patient ages and locations and thus warrant excision. Total surgical excision of meningiomas is the treatment of choice.
• A wide spectrum of surgical approaches can be employed to radically excise a meningioma. Preoperative embolization can decrease intraoperative blood loss in selected patients. Postoperative radiation therapy, radiosurgery, and hormonal therapy is required for incompletely resected lesions or those with malignant characteristics.
• Simpson classification of meningioma provides a general estimate of recurrence after resection. The resection ranges from grade I resection, which is complete removal, to grade IV subtotal resection, and grade V, which is decompression of the tumor. The recurrence rates are as low as 9% for grade I resections and as high as 40% for grade IV resections.
In 1922, Harvey Cushing presented a series of 85 meningeal tumors in his Cavendish lecture and coined the term meningioma to describe these lesions.1 Years later with Louise Eisenhardt, he created a definitive monograph on these tumors.2 He believed that all meningeal tumors arose from the arachnoidal cap cells that are particularly abundant in the arachnoid granulations.
Meningiomas are the most common brain tumor and have a wide variety of clinical behaviors. Although most of them behave rather nicely, there are some that are extremely aggressive. Little is known about the reasons for this difference in natural history. The etiology of meningiomas remains unknown, but previous radiation therapy and monosomy or partial loss of chromosome 22 are important factors. Radiation therapy, at a high or low dosage, can cause meningiomas even after several years of treatment.3
Epidemiology
Meningiomas constitute 15% to 20% of all primary intracranial tumors in surgical series, but their incidence in routine screening is 1 in 100 population. Their incidence increases with advancing age.4 They predominantly affect women with an overall male-female ratio of 1:2.5. This difference is increased for intraspinal meningiomas with a ratio of 1:10 in comparison with an intracranial ratio of 2:3. Meningeal tumors are rare in children but tend to be more aggressive when they occur in children. They represent 0.4% to 4.1% of all childhood brain tumors and constitute 1.5% to 1.8% of all meningiomas.5,6 Pediatric meningiomas tend to be more frequent in males with a male-female ratio of 1.2 to 1.9:1 and have a higher incidence of ventricular location.7,8
In one study, symptomatic meningiomas were encountered in 2.0 per 100,000 of the population and asymptomatic ones in 5.7 per 100,000, with an overall incidence of 7.7 per 100,000.9
Imaging
Computed Tomography
Meningiomas on nonenhanced CT usually appear as well-circumscribed extra-axial lesions, hyperdense (70-75%), isodense (25%), or hypointense (1-5%) to adjacent parenchyma.8 Calcifications ranging from microscopic psammoma bodies to dense sclerosis are found in 25% of patients. Necrosis, cysts, and hemorrhage are seen occasionally (8-23%).8,10 With contrast agent, they usually enhance brightly.
Magnetic Resonance Imaging
T1-weighted imaging shows meningiomas as isointense or moderately hypointense to gray matter lesions. Calcifications and highly fibrous areas are hypointense. FLAIR (fluid-attenuated inversion recovery) is helpful to demonstrate edema, seen as a hyperintense signal in the adjacent parenchyma. T2-weighted imaging may present a wide range of possible signal intensities. Usually isointense or mildly hyperintense, it can show hypointensity if the meningioma is calcified or highly fibrous. Massive surrounding edema is seen as a hyperintense signal. Arterial feeders to tumor are seen as arborizing flow voids (hypointense). Pial blood vessels present as surface flow voids between tumor and parenchyma.11 T2-weighted gradient echo (GRE) may “bloom” as parenchymal low signal, suggesting calcifications or intratumoral microhemorrhages.
T1 contrast enhancement shows meningiomas as heterogeneous clearly defined hyperintensive images. The “dural tail” may enhance in 35% to 80%, but is not specific.11,12 Magnetic resonance (MR) angiography and venography are noninvasive options to demonstrate tumor blood supply, vascularization, drainage veins, and sinus compromise.
Functional MRI is based on increased brain hemodynamics in response to cortical neuronal activity due to certain stimulus performed during imaging. It can be helpful in surgical planning for localization of motor, sensory, and language regions. Diffusion may differentiate benign from atypical or malignant meningiomas.13,14 Perfusion reveals differentials in relative cerebral blood volume, allows us to distinguish meningiomas from dural metastases,15 and according to some authors also discerns typical from atypical histological grades.8,16 Spectroscopy shows high choline peak, low or absent N-acetylaspartate (NAA) and creatinine levels, and variable amounts of lactate. Some of them also present high alanine and glutamate/glutamine levels on MR spectroscopy.17
Positron Emission Tomography
The role of positron emission tomography (PET) in patients with meningiomas is still not clear. The benign variants of these tumors usually show isometabolism with [18F]-fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG) markers while atypical or anaplastic meningeal tumors may exhibit hypermetabolism.18,19 FDG uptake in meningioma could be a predictive factor in tumor recurrence.20 In one study FDG PET had 80% sensitivity but only 57% specificity for detecting meningiomas.21
Single-Photon Emission Computed Tomography/Scintigraphy
Meningiomas have many somatostatin receptors (SSr) and this is the base of the scintigraphy in which SSr-positive tumors can be imaged in vivo through single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT). Octreotide is a somatostatin analog with high binding affinity for SSr subtype 2 and a longer plasma half-life than native somatostatin. Therefore, octreotide is a better SSr imaging agent than somatostatin.22 Octreotide SPECT had 83% sensitivity and 27% specificity for identifying meningiomas.21
Pathology
Hormone Receptors
Meningioma growth may be related to hormonal status due to the presence of estrogen and progesterone receptors. The tumor may become clinically evident during pregnancy or in the luteal phase of the menstrual cycle.23 The expression of progesterone receptors alone in a meningioma could be related to a favorable behavior. Absence of both progesterone and estrogen receptors or the presence of estrogen receptors alone correlates with aggressive clinical behavior, progression, and recurrence after complete surgical resection.24 Despite the presence of these receptors, drug therapies targeting hormonal status have not been particularly successful.
Classification
Histological subtypes are classified according to the most recent WHO grading system published in 200725 (Box 36.1). In the 2000 WHO classification of meningiomas, brain invasion was associated with aggressive behavior and increased probability of recurrence, but was not included as a diagnostic criterion for grade II or grade III tumor.3 Perry and associates demonstrated that brain invasion indicated a greater likelihood of recurrence and felt that it should be considered one of the diagnostic features of grade II meningioma.26 Following these findings, brain invasion by a meningioma is now an independent criterion for WHO grade II. Subtype classification does not appear to influence prognosis unless atypia or malignancy is evident.
BOX 36.1 World Health Organization (WHO) Grading of Meningiomas, 2007
Grade II
Clear cell type is distinguished by lobulated or sheet-like proliferations of polygonal cells with clear, abundant glycogen cytoplasm (periodic acid–Schiff positive [PAS+]). This type is associated with a higher incidence of recurrence, frequently affects young patients, and commonly arises in spinal or cerebellopontine locations.27
Chordoid type is marked by the presence of cords of eosinophilic, epithelial-like, and vacuolated cells in a prominent myxoid background, similar to the appearance of chordomas. It is associated with chronic inflammation cell pattern, dysgammaglobulinemia, and microcytic anemia (features observed in Castelman’s disease).28 This variant also presents a high rate of recurrence after subtotal resection.29
Grade III
Rhabdoid variant is characterized by rhabdoid-like cells with prominent eosinophilic cytoplasm, prominent nucleolus, and eccentric nuclei. This histological presentation has been associated with increased risk of recurrence and distant metastases.
Decision Making
In order to integrate these variables some treatment algorithms have been developed. Dr. Takeshi Kawase and his group (Adachi and associates30) in 2006 presented a set of rules for treating cranial base meningiomas. They give a score to each tumor based on predetermined risk characteristics:
A higher score number (risk factor) implies a lower chance of complete resection.
Dr. Joung Lee31 and his group at the Cleveland Clinic designed the “CLASS” algorithm for the treatment of all meningiomas. This algorithm compares negative features (comorbidity, location, and age) against benefits (size and symptoms) and assigns a score:
Conservative Treatment
Around two thirds of asymptomatic meningiomas do not continue to grow and may be observed at appropriate time intervals. Absolute growth rates of meningiomas vary between 0.03 and 2.62 cm3 per year. Several studies following the behavior of asymptomatic meningiomas showed minimal growth during the follow-up period. In a retrospective study of tumor growth rate in 37 patients, 9 of the 37 (24.3%) showed tumor growth during a mean follow-up period of 4.2 years. Annual growth rates were calculated as the difference in tumor volume between the initial and latest imaging, divided by the time interval (years) between these determinations, with tumor growth defined as an annual increase in tumor volume more 1 cm3 per year. In this study they associate the age of patients and the volume of the tumor at its initial diagnosis with growth rate increased. They concluded that young patients and those with large tumors should be carefully observed.32 Nakamura and colleagues33 studied 41 patients with asymptomatic meningiomas, reporting a majority (66%) of growth rates less than 1 cm3 per year. They also correlated growth rate with patient age but did not consider initial tumor size as a predictive factor for tumor growth. Yano and Kuratsu in their study of surgical indications for asymptomatic meningiomas reported 37% of tumor growth during a period of observation of 3.9 years and only 6.4% becoming symptomatic.34 Some authors recommend the surgical resection of meningiomas when the tumor growth rate is greater than 1 cm3 per year.32,33 Radiological features such as partial or complete calcification is related to slow growth rate or absence of it, so these tumors may be kept only under observation. Meningiomas that remain asymptomatic but show displacement and compression of delicate structures as spinal cord, optic nerve, chiasm, and brainstem, or with considerable surrounding edema, should be considered for early treatment. Observation alone, with periodic neurological and MRI evaluation follow-up, first at 3 months, second at 6 months, and then every year, is reasonable for asymptomatic or minimal symptomatic elderly patients with fewer than 10 to 15 years of remaining life expectancy.
Surgical Treatment
General Surgical Planning
Preoperative Embolization
The main goal of this procedure is to decrease intraoperative blood loss in meningiomas with high vascular supply. The superselective catheterization makes this procedure safer and allows for controlling the aggressiveness of embolization. The proximal occlusion of the tumor-feeding arteries only reduces the blood supply temporarily and collateral flow quickly develops. The time between embolization and surgery is controversial. The possibility of necrosis induced by vascular occlusion and therefore the softening of tumoral tissue should be compared to the increase of collateral supply development on time. The optimal interval could be between 3 and 9 days. Complications such as painful trismus, facial pain, scalp necrosis, ischemic stroke, and intratumoral hemorrhage could occur but are infrequent.
General Recurrence Rate
In 1957 Simpson35 classified meningioma resection as follows: grade I, complete removal, including resection of dura and bone; grade II, complete tumor removal with coagulation of dural attachment; grade III, complete tumor removal without resection or coagulation of dural attachments; grade IV, subtotal removal; and grade V, decompression. This classification remains useful for evaluating recurrences. In Simpson’s series, grade I through grade IV tumors had recurrence rates of 9%, 19%, 29%, and 40%, respectively, at a follow-up period of 10 years.
Considerations by Location
Convexity Meningiomas
Surgical Technique
Approach
Depending on the location and size of the lesion a linear or horseshoe incision is done with preservation of scalp vascularity. The scalp incision should extend at least 2 cm away from the craniotomy; this should allow extending the dura resection around 2 cm beyond the meningioma border. The pericranium is dissected from the skull and prepared for later grafting. Bur holes are placed around the tumor, and the dura is separated from the overlying bone with a blunt dissector. The bone flap is cut with a high-speed craniotome. Bleeding from bone edges is controlled with bone wax. The infiltrated dura or identified tumor-feeding vessels are coagulated.
Operative Results
In a series of convexity meningiomas Black and co-workers36 reported no surgical fatality and no significant difference in morbidity between age groups younger and older than 65 years. The overall morbidity rate was 5.5%. The 5- and 10-year survival rate was 90% with overall recurrence rate of 4.3%. The 5-year recurrence rate for WHO grade I tumors was zero, for grade II 27.2%, and for grade III was 50%. In their series 15 patients (9%) underwent radiation therapy.
Parasagittal Meningiomas
Type I: Attachment to outer surface of the sinus wall
Type II: Fragment inside the lateral recess
Type III: Invasion of the ipsilateral wall
Type IV: Invasion of the lateral wall and roof
Types V and VI: Complete sinus occlusion, with or without one wall free, respectively37
To achieve a Simpson grade I or II radical resection, the infiltrated SSS should be removed with the tumor. They represent about 16.8% to 25.6% of all intracranial meningiomas.38
Pathology
The histological pattern in a reported series of 106 was 79.6% for WHO grade I tumors, 14.8% for grade II, and 3.7% for grade III meningiomas.39
Treatment
Observation is acceptable in asymptomatic elderly patients or with tumor less than 3 cm in diameter. The SSS total or partial invasion can be treated by radical resection of the sinus with or without venous reconstruction. Resecting the SSS is associated with an increased risk of intraoperative and postoperative hemorrhage, sinus occlusion, corticovenous thrombosis, and venous infarction leading to brain edema. A less aggressive surgical approach, with satisfactory long-term effect and fewer complications, is to resect the tumor up to the sinus wall and leave the sinus intact.36 Residual tumor can be followed up and treated with radiosurgery at recurrence. Radiosurgery as first-line treatment can offer good results for tumors smaller than 3 cm.
Surgical Technique
Operative Results
In Black and co-workers’36 series the anterior third of the SSS was involved in 12.8% of tumors, the middle third in 69.2%, and the posterior third in 17.9%. In 63.2% of patients there was total tumor resection, Simpson grades I and II. In 14 patients (36.8%) residual tumor was found on postoperative imaging, and 13.2% of those had tumor progression. Recurrence-free survival rate was 94.7% at 5 years.
Falx Meningiomas
These meningiomas arise from the falx cerebri and tend to grow and compress the medial surface of the cerebral hemispheres. They can be classified according to involvement of the falx in longitudeal dimension. Like parasagittal meningiomas, they can be divided into anterior, middle, or posterior types. The classification proposed by Yasargil40 separated them into outer falx meningiomas, which arise from the body of the falx, and inner falx meningiomas that arise adjacent to the inferior sagittal sinus (ISS). Falcine meningiomas represent 8.5% of all intracranial meningiomas.41
Evaluation
About 60% of falx meningiomas present the dural tail sign.41 MRVA or angiographies are useful to determine the displacement or involvement of the anterior cerebral artery (ACA). The venous phase shows the SSS of ISS invasion and the localization of venous drainage.
Surgical Technique
Operative Results
In the series of 68 patients presented by Chung and colleagues,41 85.2% had total resection with no evident recurrence and 92.6% achieved a good outcome (no neurological deficit or complications). SRS was performed as a postoperative adjunctive treatment in six patients.
Olfactory Groove Meningiomas
Surgical Technique
Positioning
An external lumbar cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) drainage is placed to prevent or reduce brain retraction. For a frontotemporal approach the patient is placed in the supine position. The patient’s trunk and head are elevated 20 degrees.The head is turned to the contralateral shoulder, 30 degrees for more anterior lesions and 20 degrees for posterior tumors. The head is flexed, taking the chin to the ipsilateral clavicle and then slightly hyperextended so that the maxillary eminence reaches the highest point in the surgical field. For the bifrontal approach the patient is also placed in a supine position but with the head in a neutral position and minimally extended inferiorly.
Operative Results
In Obeid and Al-Mefty’s42 series of 13 benign OGMs gross total resection was achieved in 93.3% of patients. Vision remained stable in six patients and improved in eight with no recurrence in a median follow-up period of 3.7 years. They reviewed the recurrence rate for OGMs reported in the literature and found that it ranged from 5% to 41%, and concluded that radical tumor resection, including the dural attachment and any involved bone during the initial surgery, is the best way to reduce the chances of recurrence.42
Tuberculum Sellae Meningiomas
Tuberculum sellae meningiomas (TSMs) arise from the dura of the tuberculum sellae, diaphragma sellae, chiasmatic sulcus, and limbus sphenoidale. Usually bilateral, they grow from the midline over one side. They can invade the suprasellar region as other meningiomas with different dural origins. TSM can be distinguished from OGM by the displacement of the optic nerves and chiasm. TSMs elevate the chiasm and optic nerves superolaterally, but OGMs displace the chiasm downward and posteriorly as they grow. TSMs represent 5% to 10% of all intracranial meningiomas.43
Clinical Presentation
The most frequent presentation of a TSM is optic atrophy with bitemporal hemianopia. The asymmetrical visual loss usually begins in an insidious way and progresses slowly. Other occasional symptoms include headache, mental status deterioration, seizures, anosmia, hyperprolactinemia due to pituitary stalk posterior displacement and compression, and hydrocephalus in cases of third ventricle compression.
Expanded Endonasal Approach
Provide access to the anterior skull base extending from the crista galli to the foramen magnum;44 all 12 cranial nerves and the carotid and vertebrobasilar arteries can be seen through the nose. This approach should be considered only for small TSMs measuring less than 4 cm owing to the limited lateral explosion. Tumors arising lateral to the optic nerve or beyond the midline of the superior orbit are best approached via craniotomy if the objective of surgery is total removal.44 Neuronavigation is commonly used.