Genital Ulcers (Case 49)
Patricia D. Brown MD
Case: A 26-year-old man presents to an urgent-care center with a complaint of painful lesions on the penis that appeared 3 days earlier. The patient states that before the appearance of these lesions he had a sensation of “burning and tingling” near the end of his penis; he then noticed several “red bumps and little blisters” that opened and became painful. He has been sexually active with several female partners over the past year (vaginal sex and receptive oral sex), and he admits that he has been inconsistent with the use of condoms. He has no knowledge of any sexually transmitted disease (STD) diagnosis in his previous or current sexual partners. On further questioning, he recalls that he may have experienced several similar episodes of burning and tingling in the same region in the past but never noticed any similar lesions. He is otherwise healthy and denies any prior history of STDs. He believes that he was tested for HIV infection 3 years ago during a visit to his primary-care physician for a routine physical examination. His physical examination is remarkable only for the genital exam, which reveals a cluster of five small, shallow ulcers, each on an erythematous base; there is shotty nontender inguinal adenopathy. The patient is very concerned about the possibility of an STD and also requests testing for HIV.
Differential Diagnosis
Herpes simplex virus (HSV) infection |
Chancroid |
Syphilis |
Speaking Intelligently
The differential diagnosis of genital ulcers includes both infectious and noninfectious etiologies. Ulcers may occur as part of a systemic disease. Among the infectious etiologies, STDs are most common, although infections that are not transmitted sexually can rarely cause genital ulcers. The differential diagnosis can be generated based on the history and clinical characteristics of the lesion and then narrowed on the basis of selected diagnostic testing. It is important to emphasize that a patient diagnosed with an STD is at increased risk for other STDs, including HIV, and to offer screening for these diseases.
PATIENT CARE
Clinical Thinking
• Perform a thorough general physical examination, including inspection of the oral mucosa, skin, and anus, and evaluate for adenopathy. Carefully describe the location and appearance of the ulcer(s).
History
• A prior history of recurrent genital ulcers is suggestive of HSV infection.
• Note any associated systemic symptoms such as fever, arthralgias, oral lesions, or skin lesions.
• Obtain a travel history as well as information regarding symptoms in sexual partners.
Physical Examination
• Carefully examine the oral mucosa, the skin, and all lymph node groups.
• Note if there is a single ulcer or multiple ulcers.
Tests for Consideration
Although a preliminary diagnosis can be made based on history and physical examination, it is important to utilize diagnostic testing to confirm the etiology of genital ulcers.
$6 |
|
• Culture or antigen-detection testing should be done to rule out HSV. |
$17 |
• In some settings, such as STD clinics, dark field examination for Treponema pallidum is available. |
$16 |
$17 |
|
Clinical Entities | Medical Knowledge |
Herpes Simplex Virus |
|
Pφ |
HSV is a dsDNA virus; there are two different HSV subtypes, HSV-1 and HSV-2. Although HSV-1 has typically been associated with herpes labialis (cold sores) and HSV-2 with genital ulcers, an increasing proportion of cases of genital HSV have been documented to be due to HSV-1. HSV viral replication occurs first in epidermal and dermal cells at mucosal surfaces or abraded skin. Virus then enters nerve endings and is transported intra-axonally to nerve cell bodies, most commonly in the sacral root ganglia. Viral replication occurs in the ganglia and surrounding tissues, followed by centrifugal spread back to mucosal surfaces via the peripheral sensory nerves. After the primary infection has resolved, HSV DNA can be found in a small proportion of ganglion cells. When reactivation occurs, peripheral sensory nerves transport virus back to the mucosal surface, and recurrent genital lesions appear. Many individuals with evidence of HSV-2 infection, based on positive serology, may never have clinically recognizable genital ulcer disease, yet these individuals may still intermittently shed virus and transmit the infection to their partners. It is important to emphasize to patients that viral shedding (and therefore transmission to partners) occurs even in the absence of visible lesions. |
TP |
Patients with symptomatic primary genital infection present with multiple bilateral genital lesions characteristically in various stages of evolution from vesicles to pustules to shallow ulcerations; lesions have an erythematous base. The cervix and the urethra may be involved, and patients may complain of dysuria and vaginal discharge. Tender inguinal lymphadenopathy is common, and patients may have significant systemic symptoms including fever, headache, myalgias, and generalized malaise. Recurrent disease is much milder, with fewer lesions that are usually unilateral without systemic symptoms. Recurrence occurs in 90% of those with symptomatic primary infection. |
Dx |
A presumptive diagnosis of genital HSV can be made based on history and physical examination; however, the clinician should attempt to confirm the diagnosis with a viral culture or antigen detection test. It is currently believed that up to 50% of primary genital HSV infections are due to HSV-1; in HSV-1 genital infection, recurrences and subclinical viral shedding are much less common than with HSV-2 infections. This information is important when counseling patients regarding risk of recurrent disease and transmission. The type-specific serologic tests (those that reliably distinguish between HSV-1 and HSV-2) may be useful in some clinical settings, including patients who have recurrent ulcers with a negative culture or those with a past clinical diagnosis of genital HSV that was never virologically confirmed. |
Tx |
Antiviral medication can reduce the symptoms of both primary and recurrent infections and reduce the frequency of recurrence when given as chronic suppressive therapy; chronic therapy can also reduce the risk of transmission to sexual partners. Primary infections may be treated with acyclovir, valacyclovir (a formulation of acyclovir with improved bioavailability), or famciclovir; 7–10 days of therapy are recommended. Episodic therapy for recurrent episodes can be utilized; a 5-day course is recommended. It is important that therapy be started within a day of the appearance of lesions, or during the period of prodromal symptoms before the appearance of lesions. Patients who have frequent recurrences (six or more per year) can be offered daily suppressive therapy, which is effective at reducing the frequency of recurrences. It is important that patients understand that antiviral therapy is not curative in any of these circumstances. Physicians should counsel patients with a diagnosis of genital HSV regarding the natural history of the disease, emphasizing the potential for asymptomatic viral shedding in the absence of lesions, which may result in transmission to sexual partners. Both women and men require education regarding the risk of neonatal HSV infection. See Cecil Essentials 107. |
Pφ |
T. pallidum, a spirochete, is the causative organism of syphilis and can penetrate intact mucosal surfaces or gain entry into the tissues through abraded skin. The organism disseminates via the lymphatics and the bloodstream; virtually every organ can be affected. Disease is classified into the following stages: incubating syphilis, primary, secondary, latent, and tertiary. An ulcer at the site of inoculation (chancre) is the major manifestation of primary disease. On histopathology, chancres demonstrate infiltration by plasma cells with proliferation of endothelial cells and fibroblasts of small blood vessels, leading to the classic histopathologic finding of obliterative endarteritis. |
TP |
Chancres are usually single ulcers, but several lesions may occur; the lesion is typically painless and therefore may not be noticed by the patient. Chancres are round lesions with raised regular borders that have firm induration on palpation. The ulcer base does not have an exudate. Nontender inguinal adenopathy is frequently found. Genital lesions may also occur in secondary syphilis, where the generalized rash appears as raised, moist papular lesions. |
Dx |
A definitive diagnosis of syphilis may be established by dark field examination or direct fluorescent antibody testing of exudate from the ulcer base. This testing is not available in many settings; therefore, serologic testing can allow a presumptive diagnosis in a patient with a compatible clinical presentation. A two-step serologic testing strategy is as follows: Nontreponemal (nonspecific) tests are the Venereal Disease Research Laboratory (VDRL) and rapid plasma reagin (RPR) tests; these tests are reported qualitatively as a titer. If this test is positive, it is confirmed with a treponemal (specific) test such as the fluorescent treponemal antibody absorbed (FTA-ABS) or the T. pallidum particle agglutination (TP-PA) test. |
Tx |
A single intramuscular (IM) dose of benzathine penicillin (2.4 million units) is the recommended treatment for primary and secondary syphilis. Doxycycline, tetracycline, and azithromycin are potential alternative therapies for individuals with penicillin allergy. Follow-up consists of following the titer of the nontreponemal serologic test; a fourfold drop in the titer (i.e., a drop of two dilutions) is considered clinically significant and indicates an appropriate therapeutic response. Ideally, the nontreponemal test should become negative; treponemal antibody tests will generally remain positive indefinitely. Individuals exposed to a partner with a diagnosis of primary or secondary syphilis within 3 months preceding the diagnosis may have incubating syphilis and should be treated even if serologic testing is negative. See Cecil Essentials 107. |
Chancroid |
|
Pφ |
Worldwide, chancroid is thought to be one of the most common causes of genital ulcer disease; however, this infection is much more common in the developing countries of Asia, Africa, and Latin America than in the United States. In the United States the disease has generally occurred in outbreaks in urban areas, often in association with the trading of sex for drugs, particularly crack cocaine. The causative organism, H. ducreyi, gains entry through breaks in the epithelial surface during sexual contact with an individual with active infection. The ability of the organism to evade phagocytosis is thought to be important in pathogenesis. On histopathology, the ulcers have been shown to contain numerous CD4-positive T lymphocytes. |
TP |
Typical lesions begin as a tender erythematous papule, which then becomes pustular; the pustule then ruptures to form an ulcerative lesion. There may be single or multiple lesions, and the lesions are painful. The ulcer base is described as granulomatous, frequently with a purulent exudate; the ulcer border is ragged but not indurated. Approximately half of the patients will have tender, enlarged inguinal lymph nodes, frequently unilateral, which may suppurate and drain (buboes). |
Dx |
H. ducreyi is a fastidious organism that requires specialized media for growth and is therefore difficult to isolate in culture. DNA amplification techniques have been developed to aid in diagnosis but are not yet widely available. The CDC recommend that a clinical diagnosis of chancroid is appropriate in patients who have all of the following: (1) single or multiple painful genital ulcers; (2) no evidence of infection with T. pallidum by either dark field examination of exudate from the ulcer or serologic tests for syphilis performed at least 7 days after the appearance of the ulcer; (3) a typical clinical presentation and appearance of the ulcer; and (4) a negative test for the presence of HSV from the ulcer exudate. |
The following regimens are recommended for the treatment of chancroid: azithromycin (1 g orally) or ceftriaxone (250 mg IM) as a single dose, oral ciprofloxacin (500 mg twice daily) for 3 days, or oral erythromycin (500 mg three times daily) for 7 days. Patients should be re-examined within a week for evidence of improvement; failure to respond to therapy within 1 week of treatment should raise the suspicion of an incorrect diagnosis, and consultation with an expert is advised. See Cecil Essentials 108. |
Practice-Based Learning and Improvement: Evidence-Based Medicine
Title
Once-daily valacyclovir to reduce the risk of transmission of genital herpes
Authors
Corey L, Wald A, Patel R, et al.
Institution
University of Washington, Seattle
Reference
N Engl J Med 2004;350:11–20
Problem
Patients with genital HSV infection may shed virus even in the absence of active lesions and therefore transmit the infection to sexual partners.
Intervention
A total of 1484 immunocompetent heterosexual couples discordant for HSV-2 infection (one partner with symptomatic infection and the other seronegative for HSV-2 infection) were enrolled in the study. The individuals with HSV-2 infection were randomized to receive 500 mg of valacyclovir daily or placebo. The uninfected partners were monitored monthly for clinical signs and symptoms of genital HSV infection. All study participants were counseled regarding safer sex and offered condoms at each visit.
Outcome/effect
Clinically symptomatic HSV-2 infection occurred in significantly fewer patients whose partners received valacyclovir than with those whose partners received placebo (hazard ratio 0.25; 95% confidence interval 0.08 to 0.75; P = 0.008).
Historical significance/comments
This study demonstrated a significant reduction in the transmission of HSV-2 among discordant couples with the use of daily valacyclovir. Because HSV-2 infection is lifelong, the therapy would have to be continuous to sustain the benefit of transmission reduction. Valacyclovir is safe, albeit expensive; the potential benefit of acyclovir has not been studied for this indication.
Interpersonal and Communication Skills
The Five “Ps” for Sexual History
Taking a complete and accurate sexual history is an important skill for clinicians. It is imperative that clinicians feel comfortable speaking with patients in a way that is respectful and nonjudgmental so as to obtain correct information and to be effective in the delivery of information regarding risk reduction and prevention. The Sexually Transmitted Disease Treatment Guidelines from the CDC recommend an approach utilizing the “Five Ps”: partners, prevention of pregnancy, protection from STDs, practices, and past history of STDs. Regarding partners, clinicians should ask patients, “Have you had sex with men, with women, or both?” They should ask patients to recall the number of sexual partners they have had in the past 2 months and the past 12 months, and also to provide an estimate of a lifetime number of partners. Clinicians should also question patients regarding what they (or their partner) are doing to prevent pregnancy and what they are doing to protect themselves from STDs and HIV infection. To understand for what types of infections the patient may be at risk, the clinician needs to ask about specific sexual practices including vaginal, anal, and oral sex. Patients are often more comfortable discussing their sexual history than inexperienced physicians in training are about asking the appropriate questions. This improves with practice and experience.
Professionalism
Maintain Confidentiality in Notifying Contacts of Patients with Transmissible Infections
When caring for a patient with an STD, it is important that the clinician ensure that patient confidentiality is maintained, while being aware of the laws regarding STD reporting and the importance of partner notification. Of the infections discussed in this chapter, syphilis, chancroid, and HIV infection are reportable in every state of the United States. Patients need to be aware that their infection must be reported and to receive assurance that these reports are kept confidential. Clinicians must encourage patients to inform sexual partners of their STD diagnosis and should make provisions for having their partners evaluated and treated. In most jurisdictions, the local health department can provide assistance to patients in contact tracing and partner notification, including assistance with anonymous notification. It is important that clinicians who manage patients with STDs address the infection from both the standpoint of the individual patient and the health of the public.
The Cost-Effectiveness of HIV Screening
In caring for patients with genital ulcer disease, it is important to address the issue of screening for HIV infection. Since September 2006, the CDC has recommended that HIV testing be offered to all individuals 13 to 64 years of age in all care settings including emergency departments, hospitals, and primary-care offices. In 2009 the American College of Physicians endorsed routine HIV screening for all patients 13 years of age and older. It is estimated that as many as 25% of HIV-infected adults in the United States are unaware of their HIV status. In addition to the risk to their own health, these individuals are an important source of transmission to others; it has been demonstrated that individuals who are aware of their HIV-positive status are more likely to modify their sexual practices to reduce the risk of transmission to partners. Several studies have suggested that at least a one-time screening of the entire U.S. population in this age range would be cost-effective.