Chapter 39 Craniopharyngiomas and Suprasellar Tumors
• Craniopharyngiomas with different points of origin of tumor growth have substantially different topographical relationships with surrounding structures determining their surgical resectability and the outcome of treatment; originally infradiaphragmatic tumors are the most amenable for safe radical removal, which is the best treatment of craniopharyngiomas.
• The majority of craniopharyngiomas growing inside and outside the cavity of the third ventricle have started to grow as intrapial tumors, thus acquiring direct and intimate contact with hypothalamic structures.
• If the floor of the third ventricle cannot be seen directly on preoperative magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans, the topographical relationship of the tumor with hypothalamic structures may be predicted according to its relation with the chiasm and the presence or absence of hydrocephalus.
• The nature and intensity of the tumor adherence to surrounding structures vary in different cases within each topographical group. Decisions about the optimal extent of tumor removal may thus be made only at surgery.
• The natural history of craniopharyngiomas is unpredictable, the growth potential of the tumor or its residual tumor may differ significantly, and therefore radiotherapy should be indicated in case of tumor progression.
The region above the sella contains anatomical structures of the hypothalamus-pituitary system (hypothalamic structures and infundibulum with its pars compacta named also the pituitary stalk), the structures of the visual pathways (optic chiasm and adjacent portions of the optic nerves and the optic tracts), and important blood vessels. The tumors affecting the suprasellar region may belong to (a) tumors of dysembryogenetic origin (craniopharyngioma, epidermoid cyst, dermoid cyst, hamartoma, germ cell tumors, Rathke’s cleft cyst), (b) tumors originating from the tissues of suprasellar structures (gliomas of the visual pathways and hypothalamus, pituicytoma, granular cell tumor of the neurohypophysis, meningioma), (c) tumors extending into the suprasellar space secondarily, most often from the cavity of the sella (pituitary adenoma, Rathke’s cleft cyst, and other cysts), and (d) systemic tumors affecting the central nervous system (CNS metastasis, lymphoma, leukemia).1–3
The structures of optic pathways and the hypothalamus-pituitary system may be involved also by suprasellar meningiomas or large and giant pituitary adenomas. The latter may severely displace the floor of the third ventricle upward and may also lead to atrophy of the pia and invade the hypothalamus.4 Suprasellar meningiomas originating from the lower leaf of the diaphragm can mimic nonfunctioning pituitary adenomas.5 Extremely rare is a meningioma originating from the pituitary stalk having no connection to surrounding dura.6
Craniopharyngiomas
The intention to remove the craniopharyngioma totally whenever technically possible emerged in the past in conjunction with therapeutic and diagnostic improvements: steroid hormone replacement, microsurgery, magnetic resonance imaging.7–16 Another attitude to management of craniopharyngiomas, namely, intentional incomplete removal and radiotherapy, has been advocated in order to lower the surgical morbidity rate.17–23 However, radiotherapy cannot prevent recurrences in many instances24 and causes adverse effects.16 A compromise solution has been elaborated: radical removal was recommended only for the patients harboring the tumors not involving the hypothalamus.25 Nevertheless, the definition of “involvement of the hypothalamus” is not clear. Radiological signs of retrochiasmatic growth of the tumor in the direction of the hypothalamus and the impossibility of identifying the latter26 as a distinct form of the tumor do not indicate whether the hypothalamus is compressed or invaded.27
The management of craniopharyngiomas presented in this chapter is based on the results of our morphological studies,28 the results of the correlation of morphological data with neuroradiological and operative findings,27 and our clinical experience.
Incidence
Craniopharyngiomas account for 1% to 4.6% of all intracranial tumors and 13% of suprasellar tumors. Their incidence represents 0.5 to 2.5 new cases per 1 million population per year, being more frequent in Nigerian (18% of all CNS tumors) and Japanese children, with an annual incidence of 5.25 cases per 1 million per year. Papillary craniopharyngiomas occur virtually exclusively in adults, at a mean age of 40 to 55 years. A bimodal age distribution of adamantinomatous craniopharyngiomas is observed with peaks in children aged 5 to 15 years and in adults aged 40 to 55 years.29 In children, craniopharyngiomas account for 2.5% to 13% (average 7.5%) of all tumors and 56% of the sellar-chiasmatic tumors.30
Tumor Development
According to the widely accepted embryogenetic theory of Erdheim, craniopharyngiomas take their origin from the remnants of the craniopharyngeal duct or Rathke’s pouch. Epithelial cell rests have been reported to occur in the “nests” most frequently along the anterior part of the infundibulum near its origin from the brain and the anterosuperior surface of the adenohypophysis.29,31 When the cells of the vanishing hypophyseal duct are brought into immediate contact with the infundibular area before the primitive pia mater has developed, they will be intimately adherent to the neuroepithelium and subsequently developed pia mater will incorporate them into the subpial space.32 Alternatively, when the cell rests do not come into immediate contact with the neuroepithelium they will remain extrapial (Fig. 39.1). On the basis of histological findings, Grekhov33 distinguished four groups of craniopharyngiomas according the point of their original growth: infrasellar, intrasellar (intrasellar and suprasellar), pituitary stalk, and infundibular craniopharyngiomas. Intimate contact of the cells of tumor origin with neural elements probably accounts for the manner in which many of these tumors appear to blend with the tuber cinereum, so as to form an intrinsic portion of that structure, or even to replace it.34 These developmental concepts represent the clue to understanding the topographical variations of craniopharyngiomas.
The metaplastic theory postulates that the nests of squamous epithelium are derived from mature cells of adenohypophysis which undergo metaplasia.35 However, these nests were not found in persons in their first decade, and rarely in those in the second; according to Kernohan36 these observations failed to support the origin of craniopharyngiomas from such cells. The theory explains the craniopharyngioma spectrum, attributing the adamantinomatous type (typical for childhood) to embryonic remnants, and the papillary type (common in adult age) to metaplasia.14
Pathology and Surgical Anatomy
Microscopic Anatomy
The brain parenchyma that surrounds both variants of craniopharyngioma is typically gliotic and often shows a profuse number of Rosenthal fibers.29,34 Tumor tissue, gliosis, and brain parenchyma may form one layer of tissue with a common vascular network. Finger-like protrusions of the tumor into the surrounding gliosis or even into the adjacent brain parenchyma are characteristic of adamantinomatous craniopharyngiomas.37 On histological sections, these outgrowths appear as isolated islands of epithelium in the zone of intense gliosis.34,36
Surgical Anatomy
Craniopharyngiomas may start to grow below the sellar diaphragm (infradiaphragmatic tumors) or above it (supradiaphragmatic tumors). The point of origin of growth of the tumor influences its future relationship with surrounding structures.28 To a lesser degree the topography of the tumor depends on premorbid anatomy, first of all on the length of the optic nerves and hence the position of the chiasm.
Infradiaphragmatic Craniopharyngiomas
Enlargement of the infradiaphragmatic (i.e., intrasellar) craniopharyngiomas causes upward displacement of the sellar diaphragm and the arachnoid. Such an intrasellar and suprasellar craniopharyngioma grows below the chiasm and gradually compresses and displaces it upward as well as the floor of the third ventricle similar to pituitary adenomas (Fig. 39.2).
Supradiaphragmatic Craniopharyngiomas
The point of original growth of primarily supradiaphragmatic tumors may be in the pituitary stalk or inside the infundibulum (i.e., in the most basal part of the floor of the third ventricle). Tumors starting to grow from the pituitary stalk are located in the subarachnoid space and grow below the chiasm and the floor of the third ventricle (suprasellar extraventricular craniopharyngiomas, SECs). A part of such a tumor almost always extends anteriorly in front of the chiasm between the optic nerves, where it can be reached (see Fig. 39.2). Rare retrochiasmatic location of an entire SEC may be the consequence of premorbid anatomy of short optic nerves and pre-fixed chiasm.
The intraventricular and extraventricular location of the craniopharyngiomas, according to a widespread idea, is a consequence of the disruption of a stretched and thinned-out floor of the third ventricle. This mechanism, which may also be occasionally observed in giant pituitary adenomas,4 is rather rare. More commonly, it is caused by the mechanism described previously. Our morphological27,28 and clinical observations showed that the structures of the third ventricular floor undergo atrophy of different degrees. The most affected structure is the tuber: its central part (postinfundibular eminence) is usually absent, and its remnants, the lateral eminences, are located on the lateral or lateral-basal surface of the tumor. The infundibulum (median eminence) is destroyed less frequently, whereas compressed mammillary bodies covering the posterior pole of the tumor can be found in all IEVCs.27
Some tumors classified in the literature as intraventricular craniopharyngiomas have been described as protruding into the interpeduncular cisterns.38 We classified such tumors as IEVCs, reserving the term intraventricular for rare craniopharyngiomas lying entirely within the ventricular cavity covered from below by the floor of the third ventricle.39–41 Such a tumor is attached to a partially atrophied floor of the third ventricle while it may only touch its lateral walls (Figs. 39.2 and 39.3). This observation28 has also been confirmed by others.42 We have seen only one such tumor in our clinical series.
Clinical Presentation
The most common signs and symptoms include endocrine deficiencies (over 90%) more frequently in children, and visual disturbances (up to 96%) more frequently in adults. Among hypothalamic disorders in children obesity is prevalent, and mental disorders occur in both age groups.43 Increased intracranial pressure is the most frequent presenting symptom in children.
Patients with craniopharyngioma generally present late, and visual symptoms are often preceded by a long history of systemic symptoms.44 Children rarely become aware of visual problems and often present after almost complete visual damage has taken place.45
Involvement of the optic pathway manifests itself by the defects of the visual fields and lowering of the visual acuity. Many different varieties of the visual field defects are found, among them bitemporal hemianopia, homonymous hemianopia, concentric contractions of fields, and central or paracentral scotomas.43 The commonest field defect is asymmetrical bitemporal hemianopia, as a result of the compression of the chiasm, whereas homonymous visual field defects are caused by the tumors located behind the chiasm. The structures of the optic pathway may be compressed not only by the tumor but also by the arteries of the anterior part of the circle of Willis. The tumors growing below the chiasm push the optic structures upward against the anterior cerebral arteries (A1) and the anterior communicating artery (AComA). A strangulation groove may be found on the upper surface of the chiasm or on the terminal portion of the optic nerves. Retrochiasmatic tumors push the chiasm forward and downward below the A1-AComA complex. Strangulation grooves may be found on the most anterior parts of the optic tracts (Figs. 39.4 and 39.5). In the most severe case of our series we observed practically complete amputation of the optic tract from the chiasm.46 Decompression of the optic pathway in such a case cannot be expected to improve the visual functions. Visual impairment may also be caused by compression of the lower chiasmatic arteries, branches of the internal carotid arteries (ICAs) between the upper surface of the tumor and the stretched chiasm. The decussating fibers in the central chiasm receive their arterial supply solely from this inferior group of vessels.47,48 Visual defects caused by ischemia may rapidly resolve after surgical decompression.
Endocrinopathies represented the most common manifestation at diagnosis (68%) in pediatric series of Di Rocco and associates.16 However, they are rarely the reason for referral. Growth deceleration and diabetes insipidus are often overlooked;49 gonadotropic deficiency cannot be observed in small children. Delayed puberty in appropriate age was observed in all children with craniopharyngiomas.49 Adults complain of decreased sexual drive and almost 90% of men complain of impotence, and most women complain of amenorrhea. Growth hormone deficiency in a large group of mostly adult patients was found in 82%.50 The frequency of presurgery diabetes insipidus varies from 8% to 35%.16,49,51,52 Compression of the pituitary stalk by a suprasellar mass causes hyperprolactinemia, which can be detected in more than 40% of patients with craniopharyngiomas.53 Obesity is present in up to 25% of the patients.51 Its evolution before and after surgery is related to the severity of the involvement of the hypothalamus.54,55 Growth hormone insufficiency can also lead to increased body fat.56
Signs of increased intracranial pressure from obstructive hydrocephalus, headache and vomiting, are more frequent in pediatric patients.51 This may be explained by the more common occurrence of the IEVCs causing hydrocephalus in children (73%) more frequently than in adults (49%). Extraventricular tumors, even large or giant, usually do not cause complete obstruction of the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF), as can be assumed according to the absence of enlargement of the lateral ventricles.
Cognitive impairment and personality changes occur more often in adults. In a series with the patients over 40 years of age, more than half suffered from impairment of memory.43 Memory disturbances are attributed to a lesion of the mammillary bodies or of their connections with the hippocampal system, the fornix, and the mammillary-thalamic tract.57,58
Radiographic Diagnosis
Infradiaphragmatic craniopharyngiomas (intrasellar, infrasellar, and suprasellar) enlarge the sella similar to pituitary adenomas. Supradiaphragmatic tumors displace the diaphragm and the pituitary downward and the sella is shallow with depressed tuberculum, acquiring a J or a pear shape on plain radiography. Calcifications are present in about 85% of childhood and 40% of adult craniopharyngiomas, and are more readily detected by computed tomography (CT). Calcium deposits are present in most adamantinomatous tumors. Eggshell-like calcification of the wall of a cystic tumor may occasionally delineate the entire lesion (Fig. 39.6). Cyst fluid is usually of low density; however, cystic portions may appear dense or solid if they contain a sufficient quantity of suspended calcium salts (Fig. 39.7). Solid tumor tissue and the cyst walls show contrast enhancement.
FIGURE 39.6 Eggshell-like calcification of the capsule of intrasellar ane suprasellar craniopharyngioma.
The heterogeneous nature of the craniopharyngiomas is best displayed by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Solid parts of the tumor are most often isointense on T1-weighted images and show contrast enhancement. Hyperintense ring enhancement of the cyst wall is common. The high signal of the cyst fluid seen on T1 images in some tumors is related to high protein content or blood breakdown products. MRI provides information on the topography essential for planning the surgical approach. A different relation to the sella and its diaphragm may be seen on coronal scans (Fig. 39.8). In a tumor of a large or a giant size, the chiasm and the structures of the floor of the third ventricle often cannot be identified. The position of the chiasm may be detected indirectly as the AComA is always located in its immediate vicinity, most often at its upper posterior surface (see Fig. 39.4). Furthermore, the relation of the tumor with the chiasm and presence or absence of hydrocephalus may indicate the relation of the tumor to the floor and the cavity of the third ventricle with a high degree of probability.27
Modalities and Options for Treatment
The argument for radical surgery is the recurrence rate, which is considerably lower after complete tumor removal compared to subtotal or partial tumor resection, reaching 0% to 43% and 40% to 100%, respectively, and a worse outcome of secondary surgery.9,10,12–16,59–63 The authors advocating conservative surgery and subsequent radiotherapy stress lower incidence of endocrine deficit, hypothalamic insufficiency, major disability, and even higher rate of local tumor control after more conservative management.17–22 There is almost general agreement on decreasing the number of recurrences and progression of residual tumors after radiotherapy. The recurrence rate in children after incomplete removal reaching 44% to 100% lowered to 16% to 37.5% after radiotherapy.60,64,65 The recurrence-free survival rate representing 38% after partial surgery increased to 77% after radiotherapy.66 Even a 100% progression-free survival rate after radiotherapy without previous surgery has been reported.17 Some other studies, however, found no relation between recurrence and adjuvant radiotherapy—neither globally nor in patients with incomplete resection.24
There is no agreement concerning the timing of radiation. Lin and colleagues63 could prevent the recurrence in all cases with radiotherapy applied initially; if radiotherapy was applied at relapse the tumor subsequently recurred in 22%. Some authors therefore recommend routine administration of postoperative radiation.18,22,67 On the other hand, residual tumor may remain stable for a very long period of time; therefore, others prefer the wait-and-see policy and do not recommend radiotherapy in stable residual tumor.16
Irradiation may be applied in fractions as conventional radiation therapy or by means of more advanced techniques: three-dimensional conformal radiation treatment, intensity modulated radiation therapy, or stereotactic radiotherapy. The tolerance of the optic chiasm is 54 Gy in 30 fractions.17 Gamma Knife stereotactic radiosurgery delivers to a tumor margin a dose from 9.5 to 35 Gy.68–70 Close tumor relationship to visual pathways, however, is a limiting factor. For targeted single high-dose irradiation the dose to the optic chiasm should not exceed 8 Gy.69
Shrinking of a cystic craniopharyngioma may be achieved by means of instillation of the solution of beta particle–emitting radioactive isotopes of yttrium-90, gold-198, or phosphorus-32. Long-term results after yttrium-90 colloid irradiation led to reduction of the initial cyst volume of 79%; in 47 patients in the reduction was more than 80%.71
All modalities of radiotherapy may cause damage to the pituitary, the hypothalamus, and the visual structures, and it may cause moyamoya syndrome, cavernous malformation, and secondary malignant astrocytoma.16,72–75 Most often affected is the function of the anterior pituitary.18 Deterioration of vision after instillation of beta wave emitters, attributed to irradiation and as the result of tumor progression, reached 22.5% to 52%.76,77 New neuro-ophthalmological deficits after yttrium-90 colloid irradiation occurred in 5.8%.71 The latter was comparable to 6.1% of visual deterioration after radiosurgery.68 Damage to the carotid was reported after yttrium-90 treatment.71 In our autopsy series of craniopharyngiomas, the occlusion of the supraclinoid ICA was noted in a 15-year-old boy 6 years after intracystic instillation of 5 mCi of yttrium-90 and 2 years after additional external radiotherapy.
Chemotherapy with bleomycin has been used in cystic craniopharyngiomas. It causes thickening of the tumor capsule, and the cyst contracts, pulling away from brain structures, which facilitates cyst removal.78 However, bleomycin is highly toxic for neural structures if it is allowed to leak from the cyst. In a review of 16 articles79 at least one severe toxic effect, including visual or hearing impairment, personality changes, seizures, somnolence, or even death, occurred in 19% of patients. A combination of intracystic bleomycin and phosphorus-32 used in nine patients led to an even higher rate of complications.80
Other surgical techniques are sometimes used in patients with primary or recurrent craniopharyngiomas. Ventriculoperitoneal shunt or even external ventricular drainage (EVD) may be inserted in cases with severe intracranial hypertension. We have had severe acute intracranial hypertension necessitating EVD in one patient. Some patients have had shunts implanted before referring to us for a tumor removal. Our policy is to restore the patency of the CSF pathways by removal of the tumor. Stereotactic technique is sometimes used for evacuation of a cyst or for instillation of radioisotopes or bleomycin into the tumor cyst.21,70,81 A repeatedly enlarging large cystic tumor may be treated by the implantation of an Ommaya reservoir, enabling simple evacuation of the cystic contents.
Cyst evacuation, different forms of irradiation, and chemotherapy are recommended mostly as an adjuvant treatment. We believe the best management of craniopharyngiomas is radical tumor removal whenever safely possible. A lower quality of life was observed after radical removal of craniopharyngiomas “involving the hypothalamus.”25,26 However, in cases with “hypothalamus no longer identifiable” on MRI scans the tumor may just compress the floor of the third ventricle and not invade it.27,28 It may be a good decision to remove the tumor radically in cases of extraventricular craniopharyngiomas and consider it contraindicated when the tumor is intraventricular.82 Nevertheless, the nature and intensity of the adherence of the tumor to diencephalic structures may differ within any of the topographical groups. Imaging studies do not show directly whether the tumor is simply compressing the hypothalamus or invading it, without a plane of cleavage. Therefore, the final decision about the extent of safe tumor removal cannot be made before the operation.
Surgery
Surgical strategy and tactics are based on the answers to two questions: Where to begin, and when to stop tumor removal? The answer to the first question is related to the choice of the optimal surgical approach. It should respect the topographical relationship of the tumor with the surrounding structures and at the same time it must provide sufficient tumor exposure. The answer to the second question is related to the fact that accessibility of a craniopharyngioma does not mean its resectability. Hypothalamic structures should be avoided during surgical approach and tumor resection (Fig. 39.9). There are two factors limiting preoperative assumption of the tumor–third ventricular floor relationship on rare occasions. First, it may be impossible to find out whether a retrochiasmatic supradiaphragmatic tumor not reaching the foramina of Monro and not causing hydrocephalus lies below the floor of the third ventricle or is embedded inside the infundibulum and the tuber cinereum. Distinction in such an MRI finding is possible only if the structures of the floor of the third ventricle are directly delineated. Second, besides the majority of tumors with expressed topographical features characteristic for one of the described groups, there are transitional types of craniopharyngiomas displaying the features of two topographical groups.
Intrasellar and Intrasellar and Suprasellar Craniopharyngiomas
For intrasellar craniopharyngiomas the only appropriate approach is the transsphenoidal route, which exposes the entire tumor and allows identification of the remnants of the pituitary gland located anterior to the tumor or posterior to it.83 The transsphenoidal approach is suitable also for the intrasellar and suprasellar craniopharyngiomas, with the exception of giant tumors and the tumors of a dumbbell or multinodular shape, which are rather rare in intrasellar and suprasellar craniopharyngiomas (Fig. 39.10). These tumors can be resected through the extended transsphenoidal approach, which allows removing even supradiaphragmatic craniopharyngiomas.84,85 In our series of 43 infradiaphragmatic tumors, 4 were intrasellar and 39 extended above the sellar diaphragm. Some of them were large or even giant tumors.
To expose the tumor via the transsphenoidal route we use the unilateral paraseptal, usually sublabial, approach performed under the operative microscope from the first incision. In order to get sufficient exposure of intrasellar contents a large opening of the sphenoid sinus and the sellar floor is mandatory.83 The anterior wall of the sphenoid sinus and the sellar floor is resected under neuronavigation guidance. In a majority of our cases in which a compressed pituitary gland was found (one third of the intrasellar and suprasellar tumors), it could be detected at the sellar floor immediately after dural incision. The gland, which was identified at the floor of the enlarged sella, was split in the midline and displaced to the side so the tumor capsule could be identified (Fig. 39.11). The capsule always adheres to surrounding dura covering the sellar cavity; nevertheless, the tumor does not invade the cavernous sinus as the pituitary adenomas do. The capsule is separated from the dura by pulling it into the sellar cavity and detaching it by blunt microdissection, although sometimes sharp dissection is necessary. If the capsule is thin and fragile, care must be taken not to lose its continuity as later on it may not be identified and may be unintentionally left in place. On the other hand, if there is a thick firmly adhering capsule, it may not be possible to dissect it free and a part of it may have to be left in place.
Suprasellar Extraventricular Craniopharyngiomas
Superior displacement of the chiasm and partial prechiasmatic extension of a great majority of the SECs allow tumor removal through the (1) prechiasmatic space between the optic nerves, anterior angle of the chiasm, and the sellar tubercle; (2) opticocarotid triangle between the lateral margin of the optic nerve and chiasm, supraclinoid carotid artery, and the A1 segment of the anterior cerebral artery; and (3) laterally to the carotid. All these extracerebral routes to the tumor are accessible by the unilateral subfrontal approach, which is our most commonly used craniotomy in craniopharyngiomas (Fig. 39.12). Removal of an extraventricular tumor through the lamina terminalis would jeopardize hypothalamic structures of the floor of the third ventricle covering the upper surface of the tumor. Therefore, with rare SECs growing exclusively behind the optic chiasm we approach below and behind the chiasm through pterional craniotomy (Figs. 39.13 and 39.14). Skull base approaches enabling an approach to the tumor more from below, such as the orbitozygomatic or transpetrosal approach, may be of great help in these cases.86 In a giant multicystic tumor a bifrontal craniotomy was necessary (Fig. 39.15).
The tumor may adhere to large blood vessels. Intraoperative damage to the internal carotid artery has been reported. Removal of a calcified portion of the tumor from the wall of the carotid in children may be especially dangerous.8,87 We found such extensive calcifications more commonly in the IEVCs. The SECs could be dissected safely from the adventitia even if they completely envelop the large arteries at the base of the brain. Extreme care must be taken to look for the minute perforating vessels, the branches of the supraclinoid carotid, and the posterior communicating arteries supplying the visual pathways and the hypothalamus. It is important to dissect these tiny vessels from the capsule of the tumor because they often bifurcate, with one branch supplying the tumor and the other continuing to its original destination. The vessel may be occluded only after confirming that it does not supply adjacent neural structures. The branches of the A1 and the AComA come in such close contact only with the tumors growing in front of the chiasm. If the perforators adhere firmly and cannot be safely detached from the tumor surface, a part of the capsule is left attached to the vessels.