Antimicrobial Drugs
• Discuss the general goal of antimicrobial drug actions
• Describe the five basic categories of mechanisms used by antimicrobial drugs
• Explain the various spectra of activity for antimicrobial drugs
• Name and describe factors that need to be considered in selecting an antimicrobial drug
• Explain the therapeutic index and discuss possible side effects associated with antimicrobial therapy
• Discuss the development of drug resistance by microorganisms
• Explain the mechanisms leading to drug resistance, including the development of multiple resistances
• Describe how drug resistance can be controlled
• Name and describe the actions of antibacterial, antiviral, antiprotozoan, and antihelminthic agents
Mechanisms of Antimicrobial Action
The general goal of any antimicrobial agent is to disrupt the metabolism or structure of an organism to such a point that it can no longer survive or reproduce. The organisms can thus be affected in two different ways: by microbicidal action or by microbiostatic action. Microbicidal action simply kills the microorganism whereas microbiostatic action reversibly inhibits growth. If the antimicrobial agent is microbiostatic, once it is removed the microorganism will usually recover and grow again normally. Factors that can influence the effectiveness of either type of antimicrobial action include the concentration of the agent as well as the type and nature of the target organisms. An agent that may be microbicidal at a certain concentration may only be microbiostatic at lower levels and one that is lethal to one type of organism may only inhibit another (see Dose Effects in Chapter 21, Pharmacology). The effectiveness of microbiostatic agents may also be dependent on external factors such as the host’s own immune system. Because this agent does not directly destroy the target pathogen, the infection must ultimately be eliminated by the host’s own defensive mechanisms.
1. Cell wall synthesis inhibition
2. Protein synthesis inhibition
Inhibition of Cell Wall Synthesis
As discussed in Chapter 3 (Cell Structure and Function) and Chapter 6 (Bacteria and Archaea), most bacterial cells contain a rigid cell wall composed of peptidoglycan, which protects the cell from rupturing in hypotonic environments. Young, growing cells must constantly synthesize new peptidoglycan and transport it to the wall (Figure 22.1). Agents such as penicillins and cephalosporins chemically react with the enzymes responsible for completing the peptidoglycan layer, thus preventing the assembly process. This disruption may occur at numerous different sites in the layer and at different points in the process, but in all cases it causes weaknesses at growth points in the layer, which in turn renders the cell vulnerable to lysis. In a hypotonic environment, water then enters the cell and eventually causes it to burst.
Inhibition of Protein Synthesis
Most of the agents that inhibit protein synthesis involve disrupting the process of translation (see Chapter 3, Cell Structure and Function) at the ribosome–mRNA complex (Figure 22.2). The ribosomes of eukaryotic cells are structurally different from those of prokaryotic cells, and because of this human cells are usually not affected by the inhibitory action of these agents because they selectively act against bacteria. The specific chemical reactions that disrupt the translation of the mRNA vary and include the following:
Inhibition of Nucleic Acid Synthesis
The metabolic process involved in the synthesis of DNA and RNA is a long and complex series of enzyme-catalyzed reactions (see Chapter 3, Cell Structure and Function). The complexity of the process lends itself to disruption at many points along the way and inhibition at any point can block subsequent events in the pathway. As with the other mechanisms the specific target within the process is often dependent on the specific antimicrobial agent being used, but the end result is the same no matter where the point of attack is—disruption of the synthesis of nucleic acids. The interference with nucleic acid synthesis by an antimicrobial drug can be due to:
Characteristics of Antimicrobial Agents
• Whether it is microbicidal rather than microbiostatic
• How readily and easily the agent may be delivered to the site of infection
• Whether it is readily soluble in body fluids and will maintain its potency long enough to be effective
• How long the agent remains active in the body
• The degree of antimicrobial resistance to the agent
• Whether it complements or aids in host body defenses
• Does it have a long shelf life?
• Is it affordable/available to all patients who might need it?
Spectrum of Action
Most antimicrobial drugs do not inhibit the growth of all pathogens. Antimicrobial drugs have a spectrum of activity, which is the range of pathogen types against which a given drug is effective (Table 22.1). On the basis of the spectrum of activity, drugs can be classified as antimicrobials with a broad spectrum of activity and those that have a narrow spectrum of activity.
TABLE 22.1
Spectrum of Activity of Some Antimicrobial Drugs
Drug | Activity against: |
Penicillin G | Gram-positive bacteria |
Streptomycin | Gram-negative bacteria, mycobacteria |
Tetracycline | Gram-negative bacteria, gram-positive bacteria, chlamydias, rickettsias |
Isoniazid | Mycobacteria |
Acyclovir | Viruses |
Ketoconazole | Fungi |
Mefloquine (malaria) | Protozoans |
Niclosamide (tapeworms) | Helminths |
Biltricide (flukes) | Helminths |
• Drugs with a broad spectrum of activity are effective against a large variety of microorganisms. An example would be the sulfonamides, which are effective against both gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria, actinomycetes, chlamydias, and some protozoans. These drugs exert their effects on all cell components of the microbes. An advantage of using broad-spectrum antibiotics is the high possibility of efficacy against an unidentified pathogen. The disadvantage of using such a drug is the likelihood of also destroying the normal flora (see Chapter 9, Infection and Disease). Destruction of the normal flora can lead to disease if one organism of the normal flora is replaced by a pathogen. This then leads to what is referred to as a superinfection.
• Drugs with a narrow spectrum of activity, such as isoniazid and penicillin G, are effective only against a relatively small number of microbes, and generally avoid destruction of the normal flora. They target a specific component that is present only in certain bacteria.
• Drugs with a medium spectrum of activity are effective against some gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria, but not all of them.
Selective Toxicity
An ideal antimicrobial drug will kill harmful microorganisms without significant damage to the host. This principle is referred to as selective toxicity. The differences in structure and/or metabolism between the microbe and the host make selective toxicity possible. With greater differences between the pathogen and the host it is easier to develop an effective antimicrobial drug. Regarding toxicity, it is preferable to have a wide range between the toxic dosage level, which can cause damage to the host, and the therapeutic dosage level, which will eliminate the infectious pathogen over a prescribed period of time (see Chapter 21, Pharmacology).
Delivery to the Site of Infection
To be effective, drugs need to be easily and effectively delivered to the site of infection. Therefore, an important criterion for the effectiveness (efficacy) of a drug is its ability to cross biological barriers (see Chapter 21, Pharmacology). Potential barriers may be physiological, such as the lining of the body compartments and the blood–brain barrier, or those induced by inflammation and disease. Abscess walls, exudates, and necrotic material are classic examples of host reactions to pathogens and can impede the transport of drugs to the invading microorganisms.
Time of Activity
It is desirable for an antimicrobial drug to be active over a long period of time for an optimal effect. As covered in Chapter 21 (Pharmacology), the duration of action time is a major consideration when evaluating the overall effect of a drug on an infection/pathogen. If the destruction of a population of pathogens requires a sustained concentration of agent over a specified period of time, any shortening of this time may significantly decrease the effectiveness of the treatment. By subjecting the organisms to the agent for a time that proves to be nonlethal to many of them, the risk of producing a resistant population is increased.
Not Subject to Antimicrobial Resistance
The ideal antimicrobial drug is an agent that is not subject to the development of antimicrobial resistance. If the nature of the agent and its mechanism is such that populations of pathogens are less likely to develop resistance to the agent, its effectiveness and scope of use would be dramatically increased. Because of microbial genetic mutations as well as the acquisition of resistance genes from other cells, viruses, and the environment; it is difficult to develop an antibiotic against which microbes will not eventually develop some resistance (see Resistance to Antimicrobial Drugs).
Complements/Aids in Host’s Own Defenses
The natural defenses of a host, including barriers at portals of entry, protective cells and environments within the host, and an acquired immune system (both active and passive), do an excellent job in fighting off infections in the healthy host (see Chapter 20, The Immune System). When these layers of defense are compromised, antimicrobial drugs need to be administered in order to aid the immune system. Any time a foreign substance is introduced into a host there is a risk of upsetting this complex balance of defenses and actually inhibiting the body’s natural response to pathogens. For example, if an antibiotic harms an organ or system it may adversely affect the natural defenses of the host, causing such things as excessive damage to the kidneys.
Nonallergenic
Certain antimicrobial agents are capable of inducing a hypersensitivity reaction (Chapter 20, The Immune System) in certain individuals. Patients with allergies to specific agents such as penicillin must be careful to inform medical personnel about their allergy, or the shock that may result from receiving penicillin could be fatal.
Determination of Antibiotic Effectiveness: Efficacy
• The disk diffusion or Kirby-Bauer method
• The dilution or minimal inhibitory concentration (MIC) method
Disk Diffusion or Kirby-Bauer Method
In the disk diffusion or Kirby-Bauer method a culture of the pathogen is uniformly spread over the entire surface of an agar plate, using the spread plate method, or in a modified streak pattern, using a sterile swab to literally paint the surface of the plate. Paper filter disks impregnated with specific concentrations of selected antibiotics are then evenly spaced on the agar surface. The inoculated plate with disks is then incubated. As they are incubated the antibiotic in each disk begins to diffuse into the agar. If the antibiotic affects the growth of the organism that has been spread on the surface this will be evident as a clear area of no growth surrounding the disk (Figure 22.3). This area is called a zone of inhibition because it delineates the area where the diffused antibiotic inhibited growth of the organism. Because larger molecules diffuse into the agar at a slower rate than smaller molecules, the size of the zone of inhibition is not necessarily a measure of effectiveness. Standard zone diameters have been established for each concentration of antibiotic, as well as approximate number of cells plated on the specific medium being used. The diameter of each individual zone can then be measured and evaluated in order to determine whether the organism is sensitive or resistant to the antibiotic.
Dilution/Minimal Inhibitory Concentration Method
In the dilution/minimal inhibitory concentration method a given quantity of the pathogen culture is added to a series of tubes containing decreasing concentrations of a specific antibiotic. The tubes are then incubated and examined for growth. Turbidity (cloudiness) indicates bacterial growth; lack of turbidity signifies that bacterial growth is either inhibited or the organisms have been killed by the antimicrobial agent (Figure 22.4). The goal is to identify the tube with the lowest concentration of drug that inhibits visible growth. This concentration is referred to as the minimal inhibitory concentration (MIC) for a specific agent acting on a selected microorganism. In the past this test was performed in individual test tubes. However, kits are now available wherein the test is performed in shallow wells on standard testing plates. This test is widely used in hospitals and clinics today; however, there are also shortcomings with this method. As with the Kirby-Bauer method, the basic test procedure will not indicate whether an antibiotic is microbicidal or microbiostatic. A second test using this method can be added to determine whether the organisms are being inhibited or killed. In this test a sample from the tube with the lowest concentration showing no growth is subcultured in order to see whether there are any organisms still surviving in the tube. This lowest concentration containing no living organisms is called the minimal bactericidal concentration (MBC).
Side Effects
All drugs are potential poisons (see Chapter 21, Pharmacology) and the administration of therapeutic drugs can possibly lead to side effects that can be potentially serious. Drugs can adversely affect the liver (hepatotoxic), kidneys (nephrotoxic), gastrointestinal tract, cardiovascular system, red bone marrow (hemotoxic), nervous system (neurotoxic), respiratory system, integument, bones, and teeth. The administration of drugs involves a previous assessment of the risks and benefits. This type of assessment is referred to as the therapeutic index (see Chapter 21).