CHAPTER 17 The Postpartum
POSTPARTUM CARE OF THE MOTHER
On Crete, right after a baby is born, it is given chamomile tea. The mother’s breasts and nipples are washed with chamomile tea before she nurses. When visitors come to the hospital to see the new baby, the first question they asked is “has she/he drunk the chamomile yet?” The tea is considered the perfect thing for both mother and child after the excitement of labor. Once the baby had had its first chamomile, it is a huge relief to everyone because it is a sign that they are healthy and now part of the clan. In the hospital near the village I live in part of the year, there is a special room for brewing chamomile for the new mothers and babies.1
REDEFINING POSTPARTUM IN A WOMAN-CENTERED WAY
Societal expectations also revolve around this arbitrarily allotted 6-week period. Many employers expect women to be back to work after 6 weeks; obstetricians’ and midwives care packages end at 6 weeks; and even husbands, other relatives, and friends expect mom to be able to cope on her own by then. Yet most women, when given the opportunity to express their feelings about their postpartum experience say that they needed more help, support, care, guidance, and understanding than they received, and for much longer than 6 weeks after birth (Box 17-1). Most mothers say that they don’t really begin to feel like their old selves for at least 6 to 8 months after birth, and many never feel quite like their old selves again. Most admit that they had feelings of profound joy as well as stress, anxiety, and confusion during those early days, weeks, and months of becoming a mother.
Postpartum women experience a significant rate of physical health problems; however, little attention has been given to research in this area beyond recent research into postpartum depression.1,2 Substantial postpartum morbidity is known to exist and this is not routinely assessed as the postnatal assessment.3 In a study of 11,701 postpartum women, nearly half had health problems within 3 months after the birth that continued for more than 6 weeks, and that they had never experienced before. The symptoms of ill health that they confronted sometimes lasted for months or years afterward, and many of them never told their doctors about their problems.2 In general, the cursory nature of postnatal care does not facilitate the intimacy required for women to express the nature of their physical complaints, and thus most obstetricians have not recognized the extent to which postpartum women experience health complaints. Interestingly, recent studies have questioned the effectiveness of postpartum medical visits in meeting the postpartum health needs of mothers, and have concluded that “the present six week postnatal examination does not appear to meet the health needs of women after childbirth: its content and timing should be reviewed.”3
Postpartum visits should focus on the challenges women face during this time, and should provide women with the opportunity to express their concerns and expectations, both physically and emotionally. In Reactions to Motherhood: The Role of Post-Natal Care, midwife Jean A. Ball states:
The main focus of postnatal care has traditionally been that of ensuring the physical recovery of the mother from the effects of pregnancy and labor and establishing infant feeding patterns.… The emotional and psychological needs of mothers have not received much attention until recently and there has been an assumption that these needs will automatically be met if the first two aspects of care are satisfied. The organization of postnatal care has accordingly been based upon this premise.4
According to a study by Buchart et al., “Listening to women is an essential element in the provision of flexible and responsive postnatal care that meets the felt needs of women and their families.”5 By developing an open dialogue with women during pregnancy, care providers can help women to realistically prepare for the postpartum prior to birth, and overcome difficulties that might be inhibiting their recovery as well as their experience of motherhood. This chapter highlights the need for extensive family and social support for the mother after birth in the prevention of this potentially devastating problem. It must be recognized, however, that the need for such support is not limited to the prevention of PPD, but for the promotion of the overall wellness of the new mother, and by extension, her child and family. Indeed, many postpartum difficulties can be averted with adequate postpartum support of the mother, both from her immediate personal community (family, friends, coworkers, etc.) and from her health care providers.
THE USE OF HERBS FOR POSTPARTUM CARE
The use of medicinal herbs has been an intrinsic part of postpartum care in cultures throughout the world. Herbal teas and other preparations are given for a variety of reasons, including preventing infection, treating colic, and nourishing the mother and child. Herbs have been used both internally and topically to reduce bleeding, ease pain from cramping, increase breast milk production, heal and soothe the perineal area, and relax the mother. 6 7 8 9 10 References to traditional herb use after birth abound in historical and sociological references, although the ethnobotany is often not specific. For example, women in Thailand have been known to drink a mixture of tamarind, salt, and water to “strengthen the womb,” whereas women of the Seri Indian tribe of Mexico drank “seep willow tea” to “stop bleeding after birth.”11 The Jicarillo women chewed the root of wild geranium to assist in “expelling uterine blood.”11 Herb use was common in Colombia and Jamaica, as it was in Southeast Asia.12 In Burma, a paste of tumeric is rubbed onto the body to prevent blood stasis and encourage good circulation while expelling the afterbirth blood.12 In Micronesia, women are given baths of tumeric paste after birth.1 In both Ayurvedic and traditional Chinese medicine, herbs are a routine aspect of postpartum care, and have been for thousands of years.
There is little evidence on the number of women in the United States using herbs for postpartum complaints; however, it is likely consistent with the volume of herb use during pregnancy, or slightly higher, as the use of herbal teas for increasing lactation is very popular, and women and care providers are often less hesitant to use herbs outside of pregnancy. Numerous articles appearing in nursing, medical, and midwifery journals describe the use of herbs for postpartum care. 6 7 8 9 10 Chapters 12 and 18 discuss the safety of herb use during lactation. The remainder of this chapter presents information on treatments for common postpartum problems.
COMMON POSTPARTUM COMPLAINTS
After birth women experience a number of common physiologic changes that can lead to discomfort (e.g., sweating, engorged breasts, after birth pains), problems resulting from pregnancy or birth (e.g., hemorrhoids), and discomforts associated with breastfeeding (e.g., engorgement, sore nipples). Hemorrhoids are discussed in Chapter 5, and problems associated with lactation in Chapter 18.
After Pains
After pains are associated with the normal process of uterine involution—the return of the uterus to its pre-pregnant size. Involution involves the clamping down of the uterine myometrium, a process that is accompanied by menstrual cramp–like pain that varies from mild to very severe. Many women turn to nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory medications (NSAIDs) such as ibuprofen to relieve the discomfort, whereas others, preferring not to use pharmaceuticals while breastfeeding, turn to herbs. Herbs such as cramp bark (Viburnum opulus), black haw (Viburnum prunifolium), and motherwort (Leonurus cardiaca) are excellent choices as they are both antispasmodic and uterotonic.13,14 This is important as uterine laxity might actually exacerbate the contractions as the uterus tries to involute. The herbs facilitate the physiologic process while providing relief of cramping and possibly, with the viburnums, mild analgesia. Simple teas such as catnip (Nepeta cataria) and chamomile (Matricaria recutita) have empirically been shown to be effective as teas, when combined with the preceding tinctures, providing and apparently synergistic effect when used together.15 for mild cramping with tinctures of cramp bark, black haw, and/or motherwort added for severe discomfort.
A popular treatment among independent midwives for the relief of after pains, and for supporting recovery of the pelvic organs and “qi” of the body after childbirth is the use of the traditional Chinese medicine practice of moxibustion (Box 17-2). This technique, previously discussed for turning a breech baby when applied to acupuncture points on the small toe, is applied to the lower back and abdominal area over the uterus to warm the mother, reduced pain, and support involution. It is repeated once or twice daily, for 30 minutes, for the first week after birth, usually starting on day 2 or 3 postpartum.
BOX 17-2 Moxibustion for Essential Postpartum Care
To Give a Moxibustion Treatment
POSTPARTUM DEPRESSION
Postpartum depression is a crippling mood disorder, historically neglected in health care, leaving mothers to suffer in fear, confusion, and silence. Undiagnosed it can adversely affect the mother–infant relationship and lead to long-term emotional problems for the child. I have described it as ‘a thief that steals motherhood.’16
Postpartum depression (PPD) is a potentially devastating mood disorder thought to affect approximately 15% but as many as 28% of new mothers, with an estimated 400,000 women suffering from this condition annually. Twenty-five percent of these women are likely to develop PPD in the first 3 months postpartum and 25% of these women are at increased risk of developing severe, chronic depression. PPD generally has a slow and insidious onset, beginning at 2 to 3 weeks postpartum; however, it can occur anytime in the first year postpartum, and may last up to a year or longer. Symptoms of PPD include irritability, depression, guilt, hopelessness, chronic exhaustion, despair, feelings of inadequacy, insomnia, agitation, loss of normal interests, joylessness, difficulty relaxing or concentrating, memory loss, confusion, inability to function, emotional numbness, inability to cope, irrational concern with baby’s well-being, and thoughts of hurting oneself or baby (Box 17-3). Women with postpartum depression may become obsessed by the terrifying feeling that their depression and anxiety are interminable. They may feel extremely detached from their family, including husband, baby, and other children. They may be plagued by fear of hurting the baby, causing them panic and anxiety, leading them to distance themselves from the baby, and exacerbating feelings of inadequacy as a mother; thus, it has been described as “a thief that steals motherhood.”16,17
Despite multiple visits to care providers in the postpartum period, postpartum depression often goes unrecognized by the obstetrician or midwife, with symptoms of depression commonly dismissed as “just the baby blues” leaving women in need of treatment and care with none, and prolonging the terrible desperation they feel without an explanation.16, 18 19 20 Undiagnosed PPD can adversely affect the mother–infant relationship and lead to long-term emotional consequences for both.16 For most women, a diagnosis of postpartum depression comes as a welcome relief—putting their experience into the context of an explainable illness for which there is treatment. It can provide a framework that helps them, as well as their family, begin to make sense of what is happening. It is essential that care providers learn to recognize the many symptoms and manifestations of PPD to ensure that it is recognized and that women receive adequate support and treatment.21
ETIOLOGY AND RISK FACTORS FOR PPD
Despite its prevalence, the etiology of PPD remains unknown.22 Smokers are at increased risk for PPD.23 In a survey of 574 women in Ontario, of whom 9.9% were diagnosed with PPD, there was a higher rate of PPD among women with a prior history of depression, among women whose pregnancy was unplanned, among those who described the course of pregnancy as “difficult,” and among women who described their general health as “not good.”24 Women with a history of premenstrual dysphonic disorder (PMDD) may also be at increased risk.25 Breastfeeding mothers may be significantly less likely to develop postpartum depression than non-breastfeeding mothers, and breastfeeding may have unknown protective biological factors against PPD.23,26,27 A recent revision of the predictive factors for PPD lists prenatal depression, child care stress, life stress, lack of social/marital support, prenatal anxiety, low marital satisfaction/poor relationship, history of depression, a difficult infant temperament, maternity blues, low self-esteem, low socioeconomic status, single motherhood, and unplanned/unwanted pregnancy as the most important risk factors for PPD. 28 29 30 31 32 33
Many hormones have been investigated for their possible causative roles, and PPD is commonly attributed to the rapid change in hormones in the postpartum period; however, the role of hormones in PPD remains inconclusive.22,34 PPD has also been attributed to thyroid insufficiency (hypothyroidism), which is commonly found in the 2 to 5 months after birth. Recent research suggests that the abrupt physiologic drop in insulin levels that occurs during the postpartum period after the slow rise throughout pregnancy may induce mood disorders by affecting serotonin secretion in the brain. Low blood sugar can also have a dramatic effect on mood; therefore, postpartum women must ensure adequate caloric intake through a well-balanced diet to minimize the risk of depression resulting from hypoglycemia. It has been suggested that a carbohydrate-rich diet in the postpartum period may be a preventative or adjunctive treatment of postpartum mood disorders.22 Inadequate intake of essential fatty acids, protein, B vitamins, zinc, and iron also have been associated with PPD. Women who have experienced significant blood loss at birth may be predisposed to depression caused by anemia and its accompanying increased fatigue, tendency to infection. Fatigue also appears to be highly correlated with PPD, especially persistent fatigue occurring by day 14 postpartum.35
Lack of social and emotional support during pregnancy, the labor and birth, and in the postpartum period have all been associated with an increased risk of developing PPD. One PPD study found that poor support with newborn care showed a positive correlation with PPD, whereas affiliation with a secular group was a positive preventative factor.36 A study looking at the impact of a supportive partner in the treatment of PPD found a significant decrease in depressive symptoms in the group where the partner provided the mother with significant support, whereas another discovered that women with postpartum depression “reported less practical and emotional support from their partners and saw themselves as having less social support overall.”37 Clearly, adequate social support is an important variable in preventing postpartum depression. Even a therapist can lead to significant improvement in PPD. In one study, interpersonal psychotherapy was demonstrated to reduce depressive symptoms, improve adjustment, and was shown to be an alternative to drug therapy, especially for breastfeeding mothers.38 It is important for women who are experiencing extreme or prolonged symptoms to seek help.
A study conducted in Switzerland found that among the most significant risk factors for postpartum depression are social or professional difficulties, deleterious life events, early mother–child separation, and negative birth experience.39 Birth experience may have a dramatic impact on a woman’s self-perception as she enters motherhood, yet is generally overlooked. Assisted delivery (cesarean, forceps, and vacuum extraction) may be associated with higher rates of postnatal depression, as are bottle-feeding, dissatisfaction with prenatal care, having unwanted people present at the birth, and lacking confidence to care for the baby themselves after they leave the hospital.40,41 A study by Edwards et al. indicated that there is an increase in rates of postpartum depression among women who have had cesarean sections, a finding that women themselves report.42,43 Although this finding has been debated, clinical experience suggests that disappointment in the birth experience effect a new mother’s self-confidence. Considering that 25% to 40% of American women now deliver by cesarean section, this certainly illuminates the need to both reduce cesarean rates and provide counseling and support for those women who have birthed operatively. Furthermore, one study indicates that women who were cared for by midwives had lower rates of depression in the postnatal period, whereas another study revealed a significantly lower rate of depression among the women who had given birth at home compared with hospital vaginal delivery.44 Women reported that a sense of control and being informed about choices in their health care greatly improved their psychological state.
Few women experience all of the symptoms of PPD; some may exhibit only a few, some many. It is the duration, severity, and complexity of the symptoms that distinguishes postpartum depression from the common and normally occurring “baby blues,” which occurs in 50% to 70% of new mothers. Baby blues is thought to be a result of normal postnatal hormonal and other physiologic adjustments, and is self-limiting, usually beginning at about day 3 or 4 postpartum and lasting only up to about 14 days.45 Symptoms include crying, irritability, fatigue, anxiety, and emotional lability.16