25 Simulation of the clinical experience
Reasons for simulation
• ‘Real patients’ may not always be available for clinical teaching. With changes in healthcare delivery patients’ stay in hospital is now shorter and during their stay they are occupied with investigation and treatment procedures. Patients may be less willing to have repeated exposure to students.
• With simulation every student can receive a guaranteed and standard clinical experience. Unlike with real patients a simulated experience can be made available to students at the most appropriate time to fit in with their learning programme.
• Repetitive practice is recognised as a key element in the acquisition of clinical skills. Learners can practise with the simulator until they have achieved the necessary mastery of the skill.
• Students are now introduced to clinical experiences earlier in many curricula and preparation on simulated patients and simulators can prepare them for their work with real patients.
• Trainees can be exposed to uncommon situations or rare clinical events that they may not encounter in their routine clinical experience.
• The management of crisis events can be practised and rehearsed so that students and trainees are better prepared should such events occur in real life. Airline pilots are trained in this way and simulators enable the pilots to deal with extreme situations such as engine failures.
• Students can learn a procedure in a risk-free environment. Learners can make mistakes and appreciate their consequences without causing harm to patients. Indeed in some areas it is now a requirement that a doctor demonstrates mastery of a procedure on a simulator before being approved to perform it on a patient. Uncoupling injury from learning sends a message to the public that patients are not ‘a commodity’ for training.
• Doctors need to be able to work as a member of a team. Simulation can address not only the acquisition of individual technical skills but also be used to train the learner to work in a coordinated and effective manner as a member of a team.
• The assessment of a learner’s mastery of a clinical skill is important. Simulated patients and simulators can be used for this purpose in examinations, including high stakes examinations, to assess the learner’s mastery of a skill as described in Section 5.
• Simulation can be used to provide students with a motivating and engaging learning experience. This can be designed to challenge the students, encourage their reflection and provide feedback about their performance. The experience can be customised to meet the needs of the individual learner.
Approaches to simulation
There are three approaches to simulating the real patient:
1. Simulated patients. These are individuals trained to play the role of a patient.
2. Simulators or manikins. These are devices or models that represent the functioning of the body or part of the body and with which the student can interact.
3. Virtual patients. The patient is represented in a computer simulation.
Choice of simulation
• The expected learning outcomes. Simulated patients are the obvious choice if communication skills are the expected learning outcome. Computer-based programmes designed for the purpose also have a role to play in communication skills training. If skills in auscultation are the required learning outcome, a manikin such as the Harvey cardiac simulator is appropriate. Virtual patients can contribute to decision-making, problem-solving and patient-management skills.
• The level of fidelity required. Simulators vary in how similar they are to the real situation they are designed to simulate. A high fidelity simulator may be unnecessarily complex and expensive, and a simple piece of plastic simulating a wound on the skin may be adequate to teach suturing skills. A higher fidelity simulator may be required in a high stakes examination but may not always be necessary in a training situation. However, students tend to be more engaged with a high fidelity simulation that more closely resembles a patient.
• The availability of simulators. This may be a limiting factor. If students do not have immediate access to a clinical skills centre with a full range of simulators, it may be possible to arrange access to a nearby centre. If a bank of simulated patients is not available, a simulated patient can be trained to meet the needs of a programme but this can be time consuming. Virtual patients that can be shared online across institutions and modified to suit a local context are now available.