Retinal Degenerations: Retinal Dystrophies

Published on 08/03/2015 by admin

Filed under Opthalmology

Last modified 22/04/2025

Print this page

rate 1 star rate 2 star rate 3 star rate 4 star rate 5 star
Your rating: none, Average: 0 (0 votes)

This article have been viewed 3644 times

16 Retinal Degenerations

Retinal Dystrophies

Normal vision depends on the proper functioning of the macula which, when disturbed by disease, affects central vision and often causes the patient to present for the first time. Central distortion of vision (metamorphopsia) or minification of the image are pathognomonic for macular disease. Other symptoms apart from loss of acuity include photophobia, glare and dazzle (which can be severe), poor colour perception, night-blindness and a central or paracentral scotoma. Macular disease in infants frequently presents as congenital nystagmus.

Classifying macular disease by the anatomical layer that is primarily affected—choriocapillaris, Bruch’s membrane, retinal pigment epithelium (RPE), photoreceptors or neuroretina—is a commonly used and helpful way to conceptualize and diagnose retinal problems. Stereoscopic examination of the fundus with an indirect biomicroscopy lens through a dilated pupil is essential to assess the location of a lesion within the retina and its relationship to the superficial retinal vessels. However, although examination can infer the initial site of the lesion in many retinal diseases the primary defect cannot be precisely localized to a single cell layer as defects in one retinal layer produce changes in adjacent structures. For example, retinitis pigmentosa is associated with photoreceptor degeneration and also RPE and choriocapillaris atrophy with later neuroretinal degeneration and vascular attenuation. Our understanding of the pathogenesis of various retinal diseases has improved in recent years with advances in molecular genetics and cell biology and some diseases that were thought to affect, for example, primarily the photoreceptors have now been shown to have their defect in the RPE. Fundus photography, fundus fluorescein angiography (FFA), indocyanine green (ICG) angiography, optical coherence tomography (OCT) and autofluorescence (AF) imaging are valuable investigations for diagnosis and documentation. Many macular lesions are small and produce scotomas that are difficult to demonstrate; an Amsler grid can help in these cases. Electrodiagnostic tests and psychophysical testing are time consuming but very useful for diagnosing, documenting and assessing the prognosis of inherited retinal disease (see Ch. 1).

Occasionally deciding whether visual loss is caused by macular or optic nerve disease can be difficult as both reduce acuity and colour vision and can cause central scotomas. Retinal lesions tend to produce a ‘positive’ scotoma in which patients are aware of dark obscuration or something in front of their vision in contrast to the ‘negative’ scotoma of neurological disease (for example, patients do not notice a hemianopic field defect as ‘dark’). An afferent pupillary defect indicates optic nerve disease unless the macular lesion is extensive. Another useful and easily performed test is the photostress test in which recovery of visual acuity following dazzle with a bright light is delayed with macular lesions whereas vision recovers normally with optic nerve disease. Retinal lesions produce a blue-yellow pattern of colour deficit in contrast to the red-green pattern of optic nerve disease (see Ch. 19). These clinical tests are subjective, however, and less reliable than pattern electroretinography (PERG) which in most cases can distinguish macular from optic nerve disease (see Ch. 1).

Most retinal dystrophies and degenerations are untreatable and any treatment measures are largely supportive in the form of low visual aids. Perhaps the most important aspect of management is to establish a correct diagnosis as this aids prognosis; genetic and occupational counselling are very important. It is unusual for macular diseases to progress to total blindness and patients are often reassured to know this; most will have a central scotoma with good peripheral vision and are able to lead independent lives.

AGE-RELATED MACULAR DEGENERATION

This is the commonest cause of legal blindness in the developed world. It predominantly affects the elderly Caucasian population and is much less common in other races. The hallmarks of age-related macular degeneration are drusen, RPE atrophy and choroidal neovascularization.

Major studies have devised various systems for describing the fundus changes. Age-related maculopathy (ARM) and age-related macular degeneration (AMD) distinguish early disease from end-stage disease. ARM describes drusen and/or RPE abnormalities. AMD is subdivided into dry (geographical RPE atrophy without neovascularization) or neovascular (RPE detachment, haemorrhages and/or scarring due to choroidal neovascularization (CNV) forms. The Age Related Eye Disease Study (AREDS) subdivides ARM into four categories and allows rapid classification. Drusen type is divided into small (<63 mm), intermediate (63 to 124 mm) and large (greater than 124 mm). Atrophy of the RPE is either centred or noncentered (not involving the fovea).

CNV occurs as ‘classical’ or ‘occult’ forms. In classical CNV, fluorescein angiography shows a well demarcated neovascular membrane with hyperfluorescence that progressively leaks dye from early on to obscure the lesion’s boundaries over time. Occult CNV is associated with late leakage from an undetermined source at the level of the RPE. It can also appear as a fibrovascular pigment epithelial detachment which is seen on fluorescein angiography as early (less than 2 minutes) stippled hyperfluorescence representing irregular RPE elevation. The Treatment of Age Related Macular Degeneration with Photodynamic Laser Study (TAP) subdivided CNV into predominantly classical (more than 50 per cent of CNV lesions with a classical component), minimally classical (less than 50 per cent classical) and purely occult (no classical CNV).

PATHOGENESIS OF AMD

AMD appears to result from defects in the RPE cell–Bruch’s membrane–choriocapillaris complex and is thought to be a collection of heterogeneous disorders associated with multiple genetic and environmental factors. Much current research centres on defects in the RPE cell and Bruch’s membrane (see Ch. 13). In normal ageing progressive thickening of Bruch’s membrane occurs with accumulation of lipids, noncollagenous proteins and other extracellular material such as advanced glycation endproducts, collagen and elastin changes and increased calcification. By the fourth decade all eyes show accumulation of membranous debris within both collagenous layers. With time, a second series of changes is seen with deposition of diffuse material both between the RPE and its basement membrane (basal linear deposit) and between the basement membrane and the inner collagenous layer (basal laminar deposit). The latter can become extensive with a complex morphology and may be confused with diffuse or soft drusen, drusen being focal accumulations between the RPE basement membrane and the inner collagenous layer of Bruch’s membrane. Lipofuscin accumulates with age in the RPE cell from metabolism of photoreceptor outer segments from oxidative damage or RPE overloading by failed photoreceptors. The specific mechanisms underlying these changes are not fully understood, but it is thought that the resultant increase in thickness and reduction in molecular transport through Bruch’s membrane and the RPE cell may contribute to photoreceptor cell death and AMD. In addition, anatomical changes and delayed filling on fluorescein angiography are seen in the choroidal circulation.

AMD can be dominantly inherited and many classical features of AMD (drusen, pigment epithelial detachment (PED), CNV, atrophy) are also seen in inherited disorders such as Sorsby’s fundus dystrophy, North Carolina macular dystrophy, and Doyne’s dominant drusen, suggesting common underlying cellular mechanisms between these dystrophies and AMD.

These are important for the potential clue that they give to the underlying cellular process involved. In Stargardt’s macular dystrophy, mutation of the ABCA4 gene causes lipofuscin to accumulate in RPE; a similar process might occur in AMD leading to RPE dysfunction and eventual death. In Sorsby’s fundus dystrophy, mutation of the TIMP3 gene (tissue inhibitor of metalloproteinase 3 inhibits matrix degradation) is associated with thickening of Bruch’s membrane. In AMD, TIMP3 concentration is also increased and associated with thickening of Bruch’s membrane. Increased lipid deposition is also found in Bruch’s membrane and epidemiological risk factors for cardiac disease (although not serum cholesterol) are also associated with AMD.

DRUSEN AND ATROPHIC MACULAR CHANGES

Drusen lie in Bruch’s membrane and stain progressively during fluorescein angiography. They are assessed more easily by fluorescein angiography than by fundoscopy as angiography shows RPE atrophy more clearly. Different drusen staining patterns emerge during angiography. Conventionally, drusen that stain readily are taken to be ‘hydrophilic’, whereas those that do not are ‘hydrophobic’. Hydrophilic drusen are more proteinaceous and are associated with an increased risk of choroidal neovascularization; hydrophobic drusen have increased lipid and are more associated with PED. Other factors, such as drusen size and extracellular matrix characteristics probably influence staining too. However, it is the extent of RPE atrophy seen as window defects (see Ch. 13) on angiography or as blackness on autofluorescence imaging—rather than drusen—that better reflects visual loss.

RETINAL PIGMENT EPITHELIAL DETACHMENT

As part of the degenerative process, fluid may collect between the RPE and Bruch’s membrane to induce a PED in the posterior pole. This is seen clinically as a well demarcated, localized elevation in the macular area that can be distinguished from central serous retinopathy by its rather more solid and better defined appearance. PEDs vary from 0.5 to 2 or 3 disc diameters in size. Fluorescein angiography confirms the diagnosis by showing a steadily increasing diffuse and even pattern of leakage. Marked, well defined pooling is seen in the later stages. Uneven intensity or focal hyperfluorescence indicates associated subretinal neovascularization. PEDs are thought to be caused by hydrophobic drusen material being deposited in Bruch’s membrane. This restricts fluid outflow into choroid by RPE cell ‘pumping’, so that fluid accumulates and cleaves the RPE off Bruch’s membrane.

In younger patients, the visual prognosis is relatively good and no treatment is indicated; the detachment may persist for many years without vision being affected significantly. In elderly patients controlled trials have not shown any benefit from argon laser photocoagulation and the effect of in photodynamic therapy has not yet been studied. The condition is thus best left untreated in all patients. Visual acuity may suddenly be lost if the detached RPE tears, resulting in the pathological event known as a pigment epithelial tear or ‘rip-off’ syndrome. Tears may flap back under themselves and sometimes cause simultaneous haemorrhage. In some patients, especially those of Oriental or African Caribbean descent, the differential diagnosis of idiopathic polypoidal choriovasculopathy (IPCV) should also be considered.

image

Fig. 16.10 Colour photograph showing the well circumscribed elevation of the macula, which has a more prominent and thicker appearance than that seen with central serous retinopathy (see Fig. 16.38). In elderly patients other signs of macular degeneration such as drusen, pigmentation and atrophy are frequently seen. Any surrounding lipid exudate or haemorrhage strongly suggests choroidal neovascularization within the lesion.

CHOROIDAL NEOVASCULAR MEMBRANES

Disciform degeneration of the macula is an old name derived from the elevated mass of fibrosis and exudate that is seen replacing the macula in the terminal stages of the disease. The earliest pathological changes are rupture of Bruch’s membrane with penetration of a neovascular membrane derived from the choriocapillaris. This invades drusen material and the subretinal pigment epithelial and subretinal spaces. The process occurs in the posterior pole of the eye, either under the macula, in the paramacular area, or occasionally adjacent to the optic disc. Similar lesions in the equatorial or peripheral retina can occasionally occur in diseases such as pars planitis or retinitis pigmentosa. In common with neovascular tissue elsewhere, these vessels bleed and leak, producing subretinal exudate and fibrosis with consequent disruption of the macular anatomy and destruction of central vision.

While CNV is usually associated with AMD it is also the end-result of a group of diverse conditions that appear to have in common the ability to affect the posterior pole and damage Bruch’s membrane. The stimulus for the neovascular process is thought to be the release of neovascular factors such as vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) from the RPE, induced by metabolic changes and hypoxia from thickening of Bruch’s membrane with age. This is modulated by a complex interaction of other stimulatory factors and inhibitory factors such as pigment epithelium-derived factor (PEDF) in a way analogous to that seen with retinal neovascularization.

OTHER CAUSES OF CHOROIDAL NEOVASCULAR MEMBRANES

Neovascularization through Bruch’s membrane occurs in a wide range of fundus disorders that have in common the ability to disrupt or damage the RPE or Bruch’s membrane in the macular area.

ANGIOID STREAKS

TREATMENT OF AGE-RELATED CHOROIDAL NEOVASCULARIZATION

The only clinically proven treatment for choroidal neovascularization is the destruction of extrafoveal CNVs by argon laser photo ablation and of classical subfoveal membranes by photodynamic treatment. At present, however, a number of clinical trials are being conducted to assess other modalities such as anti-VEGF aptamers, PEDF gene constructs and anti-angiogenic steroids and in future combinations of laser and pharmacological treatment are likely to be used.

Thermal burns produced by argon laser will destroy choroidal neovascularization and limit, to some extent, further retinal destruction and visual loss. Lesions can be treated up to the edge of the foveal avascular zone but care must be taken with juxtafoveal lesions as damage from the burn can spread outside the treated area. A problem with lesions adjacent to the fovea is that the macular yellow luteal pigment absorbs energy which may then thermally injure the overlying neuroretina and enlarge the scotoma. If light is restricted to the green bands of the argon spectrum the laser energy is taken up by blood and the RPE, sparing the neuroretina; long-wavelength krypton or diode laser energy is also taken up by RPE and choroidal pigment but not by the luteal pigment and so can be useful in this situation. Subfoveal CNV cannot be treated by thermal laser without destroying central vision. Although successful treatment improves the short-term visual prognosis this is not sustained in the long term and studies show that after 3–4 years vision has fallen in 50–60 per cent of patients from further macular degeneration.

With photodynamic therapy a photosensitizing dye (verteporfin) is given intravenously and is taken up by the vascular endothelium. The lesion is then exposed to 689-nm light; the dye is excited and releases singlet oxygen which damages the endothelium and thromboses the membrane. Although multiple treatments are required clinical studies have shown that this treatment can slow visual loss in eyes with predominantly classical subfoveal CNV. The parameters of PDT treatment are still being evaluated. Classic membranes appear to have the best response but some improvement can be seen with lesions that have less than 50% classic changes or even with small recent occult lesions. PDT is also being used for treatment of other neovascular lesions such as those associated with angioid streaks or myopic CNV.

CENTRAL SEROUS RETINOPATHY

This condition is seen most commonly in patients between the ages of 20 and 40 years with a male:female ratio of 8:1. Corticosteroid treatment and stress are well recognized risk factors. A serous retinal detachment develops at the macula in association with a focal leak through the RPE; fluid passes from the choriocapillaris to the subretinal space where it accumulates. The site of leakage is usually above the horizontal meridian and outside the avascular central zone.

Patients present with micropsia and slightly blurred or distorted vision, typically improved by a +1D lens. The photostress test is positive. The condition usually has a self-limiting course of several months; recovery can be accelerated by laser photocoagulation of the leak although the final visual result is unchanged and the risk of developing choroidal neovascularization may be increased. Visual recovery is usually good but some, especially older patients, do less well. Some patients develop recurrent or chronic disease.

INHERITED RETINAL DYSTROPHIES

CLASSIFICATION OF INHERITED RETINAL DISEASE

Clinically inherited retinal dystrophies are classified by natural history (stationary or progressive), mode of inheritance (autosomal dominant, autosomal recessive, X-linked recessive, mitochondrial or, less commonly, multiallelic inheritance) and putative site of dysfunction within the retina. The latter may be inferred from the results of psychophysical and electrophysiological testing (see Ch. 1) and the various methods of fundus imaging such as fluorescein angiography, autofluorescence imaging and optical coherence tomography. This approach has limitations and a more robust classification which more accurately reflects disease pathogenesis awaits the identification of the many genetic mutations associated with retinal disease. More than 90 genes and 140 loci associated with inherited retinal degeneration have now been identified with many more yet to be discovered. At present, routine molecular diagnostic testing is available for only a few disorders but the numbers will increase as advances are made in the technology of molecular genetic analysis.

INHERITED CENTRAL RECEPTOR (MACULAR) DYSTROPHIES

The hereditary macular dystrophies (central receptor dystrophies) comprise a heterogeneous group of disorders characterized by bilateral central visual loss, defects in colour vision and the finding of generally symmetrical macular abnormalities on ophthalmoscopy. The age of onset is variable, but most present in the first two decades of life. A number of different genes and chromosomal loci causing macular dystrophy have now been identified with autosomal dominant (AD), autosomal recessive (AR), X-linked (XL) recessive and mitochondrial inheritance having been reported. Macular abnormalities may also be seen in a variety of inherited multisystem disorders which are outside the scope of this chapter.

AUTOSOMAL RECESSIVE INHERITANCE

Stargardt disease and fundus flavimaculatus (FFM)

Autosomal recessive Stargardt macular dystrophy (STGD) is the most common inherited macular dystrophy with a prevalence of 1 in 10000. Most patients present with central visual loss in their early teens but STGD may also present in adult life when the visual loss is usually milder. The electrophysiological abnormalities detected are variable. An abnormal electro-oculogram (EOG), suggestive of RPE dysfunction is a common finding. The pattern electroretinogram (PERG) and focal ERG are usually abolished or markedly reduced indicating macular dysfunction. The full-field ERG may be normal at diagnosis or over time may show changes consistent with widespread retinal dysfunction. Patients who show an abnormal full-field ERG at diagnosis have a poorer long-term visual prognosis.

The locus for STGD–FFM has been mapped to chromosome 1 p and the causative gene, ABCA4, characterized. Mutations in ABCA4 have also been implicated in other disorders, including retinitis pigmentosa (RP) and cone–rod dystrophy (CORD). It is currently believed that homozygous null mutations cause the most severe phenotype of autosomal recessive RP; combinations of a null mutation with a moderate missense mutation result in autosomal recessive CORD; and combinations of null/mild missense or two moderate missense mutations cause STGD–FFM. ABCA4 encodes a transmembrane rim protein located in the discs of rod and foveal cone outer segments that is involved in ATP-dependent transport of retinoids (intermediates in the vitamin A recycling pathway) from photoreceptor to RPE. Failure of this transport results in deposition of a major lipofuscin fluorophore, A2E (N-retinylidene-N-retinyl-ethanolamine), in the RPE. It is thought that this accumulation may be deleterious to the RPE with consequent secondary photoreceptor degeneration. Growing evidence from in vitro studies and mouse models suggests that the deleterious effects of A2E can be alleviated by a variety of interventions that either antagonize the toxic effects of A2E or inhibit its biosynthesis.

AUTOSOMAL DOMINANT INHERITANCE

Best disease (vitelliform macular dystrophy)

Best disease is dominantly inherited and characterized clinically by the classical feature of a round or oval yellow subretinal macular deposit. Full-field ERG is normal but the EOG shows a very reduced or absent light rise indicating that there is widespread dysfunction of the RPE. The visual prognosis in Best disease is surprisingly good with most patients retaining reading vision into the fifth decade of life or beyond. The disease shows very variable expressivity although the majority of individuals who carry mutations in the VMD2 gene have an abnormal EOG; this is extremely useful in assigning disease status when counselling in Best disease. Family members who carry a mutation in the VMD2 gene and who have minimal macular abnormality or a normal fundus appearance (but abnormal EOG) in early adult life usually retain near-normal long-term visual acuity. The protein product of VMD2, bestrophin, has been localized to the basolateral plasma membrane of the RPE, where it forms a component of a chloride channel. It has been suggested that impaired fluid transport in the RPE secondary to abnormal chloride conductance may lead to accumulation of fluid and/or debris between the RPE and photoreceptors and between the RPE and Bruch’s membrane, leading to detachment and secondary photoreceptor degeneration.

INHERITED RETINAL DYSTROPHIES WITH GENERALIZED RETINAL INVOLVEMENT

STATIONARY RETINAL DYSTROPHIES

Most dystrophies are progressive but others, notably stationary night-blindness and some cone dysfunction syndromes, are stationary. Three forms of stationary night-blindness are recognized: congenital stationary night-blindness (CSNB), fundus albipunctatus and Oguchi disease.

Congenital stationary night-blindness

CSNB is characterized by night-blindness, variable visual loss and a normal fundus examination. It may be inherited as an autosomal dominant (AD), autosomal recessive (AR) or X-linked (XL) disorder. Patients with AD CSNB usually present with symptomatic night-blindness and have normal visual acuity but those with XL and AR CSNB usually present in infancy with nystagmus, strabismus and reduced vision. Visual acuity is usually normal in the AD form. In XL and AR CSNB there is usually reduced central vision, moderate to high myopia, nystagmus, strabismus and, in some cases, paradoxical pupil responses (pupillary dilatation to bright light). Fundus examination is usually normal but some patients have pale or tilted optic discs.

XL CSNB is further subdivided into complete and incomplete forms. Patients with complete CSNB are invariably myopic and have more pronounced night-blindness. Both complete and incomplete CSNB show a negative type of ERG in that the photoreceptor derived a-wave in the maximal response is normal but there is selective reduction in the inner nuclear derived b-wave so that it is smaller than the a-wave. In complete CSNB there is no detectable rod-specific ERG. Cone ERGs show subtle abnormalities now known to reflect ON pathway dysfunction (see Ch. 1). In contrast there is a detectable rod-specific ERG in incomplete CSNB and cone ERGs are much more abnormal than in complete CSNB, reflecting involvement of both ON and OFF pathways.

Mutations in genes encoding three components of the rod phototransduction cascade have been reported in association with the dominant form of CSNB; namely rhodopsin, the α-subunit of rod transducin and the rod cyclic guanosine monophosphate (cGMP) phosphodiesterase β-subunit. Two genes (CACNA1F and NYX) have now been implicated in XL CSNB. Incomplete CSNB is associated with mutation in CACNA1F, which encodes the retina-specific α1F-subunit of the voltage-gated L-type calcium channel expressed in the outer nuclear layer, inner nuclear layer and ganglion cell layer. The loss of functional channels impairs the calcium flux into rod and cone photoreceptors required to sustain tonic neurotransmitter release from presynaptic terminals. This may result in an inability to maintain the normal transmembrane potential of bipolar cells, such that the retina remains in a partially light-stimulated state, unable to respond to changes in light levels. Complete CSNB is associated with mutation in NYX, the gene encoding the leucine-rich proteoglycan, nyctalopin. It has been suggested that nyctalopin plays a role in the development and function of the ON pathway within the retina.

STATIONARY CONE DISORDERS (CONE DYSFUNCTION SYNDROMES)

Achromatopsia

Achromatopsia refers to a genetically heterogeneous group of stationary retinal disorders in which there is an absence of functioning cones in the retina. These disorders are characterized by reduced central vision, poor colour vision, photophobia and a normal fundus examination and may occur in complete (typical) and incomplete (atypical) forms.

Complete achromatopsia (rod monochromatism), a rare disorder with an incidence of approximately one in 30000, is inherited as an autosomal recessive trait and results in impaired vision and complete colour blindness. The usual presentation is with reduced vision (20/120–20/200), nystagmus and marked photophobia in infancy. Vision may be noted to be better in mesopic conditions. Pupil reactions are sluggish or may show pupillary constriction in the dark, the so-called paradoxical response. Hyperopic refractive errors are common and fundus examination is normal. The nystagmus, although marked in infancy, may improve with age as can the photophobia. Peripheral visual fields are normal although a small central scotoma can often be detected. Rod-specific ERGs are normal, but there are no detectable cone-derived responses. Three achromatopsia genes have been identified, CNGA3, CNGB3 and GNAT2, which all encode components of the cone phototransduction cascade.

The presentation and clinical findings of incomplete achromatopsia in infancy are similar but the visual prognosis may be better. Visual acuity is often in the range 20/80–20/120 and there may be some residual colour perception. This form is also inherited as an autosomal recessive trait and mutations in CNGA3 have been identified.

PROGRESSIVE RETINAL DYSTROPHIES

Most inherited retinal dystrophies occur as an isolated abnormality but some dystrophies are associated with other systemic abnormalities (e.g. Usher syndrome and Bardet–Biedl syndrome). These disorders can also be usefully divided according to whether they predominantly affect the choroid, the inner retina or the outer retina. Outer retinal disorders are generally subdivided on the basis of which photoreceptors are involved in the early stage of disease.

ROD–CONE DYSTROPHIES

The rod–cone dystrophies—often referred to as retinitis pigmentosa (RP)— are a clinically and genetically heterogeneous group of disorders in which there is progressive loss of rod and later of cone photoreceptor function leading to severe visual impairment. They may be inherited as an AD, AR or XL trait.

Leber congenital amaurosis

Leber congenital amaurosis (LCA) is a rod–cone dystrophy that presents at birth or the first few months of life with poor vision and nystagmus; the full-field ERG is absent or substantially abnormal. Inheritance is autosomal recessive. Affected infants have roving eye movements or nystagmus, and poor pupillary responses to light. Eye-poking, the ‘oculodigital’ sign, is common. Fundus examination is usually normal but disc pallor, vessel attenuation and peripheral pigmentary retinopathy may occasionally be seen. Affected infants often have high hyperopia.

Molecular genetic testing may be helpful in making a more specific diagnosis. To date six genes have been identified and account for approximately half of all patients with LCA. These genes are expressed preferentially in the retina or the RPE and their putative functions are diverse, including retinal photoreceptor development (CRX), photoreceptor cell structure (CRB1), phototransduction (GUCY2D), protein trafficking (AIPL1, RPGRIP1) and vitamin A metabolism (RPE65). Establishing a molecular diagnosis of LCA may facilitate advice about prognosis and allows improved genetic counselling, the potential for prenatal diagnosis and, in the future, the selection of patients for gene-specific therapies. This is of special interest as gene replacement therapy with subretinal injection of recombinant adeno-associated virus encoding an RPE65 transgene has been assessed in a dog model with promising results. Marked improvements in visual behaviour and ERGs occurred as early as 4 weeks after surgery in affected animals with a gradual progressive improvement in ERG responses over time. Trials of gene therapy in patients with LCA due to mutations in RPE65 are likely in the near future.

Retinitis pigmentosa

Retinitis pigmentosa (RP) is a term used for a genetically diverse group of disorders characterized by night-blindness and visual field loss. ERGs are either undetectable or show the rod system to be more severely affected than the cones with dysfunction at the level of the photoreceptor. The age of onset is very variable. Inheritance can be AR, AD or XL. XL and AR RP tend to have an earlier onset and to be more severe than AD disease. The disease may be confined to the eye or the retinal dystrophy may be part of a systemic disorder. In most cases visual acuity is normal at presentation, although central visual loss may occur later as a result of posterior subcapsular cataract, macular oedema or macular involvement. Early visual field changes are seen as small scotomata in the mid-peripheral retina and are more common in the upper visual field. These field defects gradually coalesce to give the classical peripheral ring scotoma and visual field constriction in advanced disease.

Genetics of RP

RP may be inherited as an AD, AR or XL recessive disorder, but approximately 50 per cent of patients have no family history of RP or evidence of parental consanguinity. It is unlikely that all such patients have AR disease. Some males may have XL disease transmitted via asymptomatic female carriers; other cases may represent new AD mutations or AD disease in a family with reduced penetrance. A significant number of patients with sporadic RP have mild disease, and a proportion of these probably have new AD mutations. It is also important to remember that RP-like changes can be mimicked by posterior segment inflammatory disease, trauma, infection and drugs. Such patients with acquired disease may have uniocular signs and frequently have better visual function and retinal electrophysiology than is found with inherited disease.

Prior to counselling it is important to examine other family members, especially the mothers of severely affected males who may show fundus or electrophysiological abnormalities suggestive of an XL heterozygote. To date, 39 loci have been implicated in nonsyndromic RP for which 30 genes are known. These encode a wide range of proteins including components of the phototransduction cascade, proteins involved in vitamin A metabolism and cell–cell interaction, photoreceptor structural proteins and transcription factors, intracellular transport proteins and splicing factors.

Mutations in 14 genes have now been identified for AD RP with mutations in the rhodopsin gene being the commonest. Clinically rhodopsin gene mutations account for about 25 per cent of patients with AD RP and more than 60 different mutations have been identified; there is considerable variation in the ocular phenotype seen with the different mutations. Mutations in 14 genes have been identified to date in AR RP encoding many components of the rod phototransduction cascade including rhodopsin, subunits of rod cGMP-phosphodiesterase, subunits of rod cGMP-gated cation channels and arrestin. In addition, mutations in four genes coding for components of the visual cycle involved in recycling vitamin A have been identified in AR RP. Mutations in two genes have been identified in XL RP, RPGR and RP2. Most families with XL RP have mutations in RPGR. It has been suggested that the protein RPGR may act as a regulator of a specific type of membrane transport or trafficking that is particularly active in the retina or RPE.

Syndromic RP

RP is associated with systemic disease in a group of rare syndromes in which renal, neurological or hearing problems are often other features. Some of these, such as Refsum disease (comprising RP, peripheral neuropathy, deafness, cardiomyopathy and ichthyosis from deposition of phytanic acid) and abetalipoproteinaemia (RP, acanthocytosis of red blood cells, fat malabsorption, spinocerebellar ataxia and an absence of β (low density) lipoproteins in plasma) are important as the biochemical defect is known and treatment can modify the natural history. Another well known disorder is Usher syndrome (RP and congenital sensorineural deafness). In type 1 Usher syndrome there is profound deafness with no intelligible speech, absent or very abnormal vestibular responses to rotation and calorics with variable ataxia. The ERG is usually absent at the time of diagnosis. In type 2 Usher syndrome the hearing loss is more variable and may be quite mild in some patients. The hearing loss is most apparent at high frequencies; patients develop speech and vestibular responses are normal. The retinal dystrophy is of later onset and is less severe and a small ERG can usually be recorded. A third form of Usher syndrome (type 3) has been described that is similar to type 2 but characterized by progressive sensorineural hearing loss. To date, 12 loci and four genes have been identified in Usher syndrome with more remaining to be discovered.

The mitochondrial cytopathies are an uncommon group of multisystem disorders in which there is biochemical, histopathological or genetic evidence of mitochondrial dysfunction. Clinical abnormalities often begin in childhood and may include lactic acidosis, anaemia, myopathy, neurological abnormalities, endocrine disturbance, renal disease, neurosensory hearing loss and an RP-like dystrophy. A number of syndromes have been recognized including Kearns–Sayre syndrome or chronic progressive external ophthalmoplegia (see Ch. 2).

CONE AND CONE–ROD DYSTROPHIES

The inherited cone and cone–rod dystrophies are a heterogeneous group of disorders characterized by variable photophobia, reduced central vision, abnormal colour vision and abnormal cone ERGs. AR, AD and XL recessive inheritance have all been reported. When an inheritance pattern can be established reliably, it is most commonly AD. The functional deficit is confined to the photopic system in some forms of cone dystrophy but in the majority there is later evidence of rod dysfunction (cone–rod dystrophy; ‘CORD’). The age of onset of visual loss and the rate of progression show wide variability in different families but visual acuity usually deteriorates over time to 20/200 or counting fingers. In pure cone dystrophies or in the early stages of CORD, ERG shows abnormal cone responses with normal rod responses. With later disease generalized abnormalities of rod and cone responses are seen with the cone ERG being more abnormal than the rod ERG. Obligate carriers of XL cone dystrophy may show evidence of cone dysfunction on electrophysiological testing.

Several loci and causative genes have been identified in the progressive cone and cone–rod dystrophies. Currently six genes encoding various proteins, including a transcription factor, phototransduction proteins and a synaptic protein, have been associated with AD disease (CRX, GUCY2D, GUCA1A, RIM1, peripherin/RDS and AIPL1) with more yet to be discovered. Currently, mutations in ABCA4 have been shown to be the commonest cause of AR CORD and mutations in RPGR have been associated with XL CORD.

INHERITED CHORIORETINAL DYSTROPHIES

CHOROIDERAEMIA

Choroideraemia is an XL recessive disorder characterized by progressive atrophy of the RPE and choriocapillaris with subsequent loss of the overlying photoreceptors. Affected males usually present in early childhood with night-blindness and progressive field loss, but central vision is usually preserved until late in the disease. In affected males the earliest fundus signs are fine pigment epithelial atrophy and pigmentation in the equatorial retina; at this stage the clinical appearance may be confused with RP. Later there is marked atrophy of the RPE and choriocapillaris. The choroideraemia gene (CHM) has been mapped to Xq21 with many different mutations in CHM having been identified. The product of this gene, Rab escort protein (REP-1), is involved in the posttranslational lipid modification and subsequent membrane targeting of Rab proteins, small GTPases that play a key role in intracellular trafficking.

GYRATE ATROPHY

Gyrate atrophy of the choroid and retina is a rare autosomal recessive disorder characterized by progressive chorioretinal atrophy, hyperornithinaemia and a deficiency of the pyridoxal phosphate-dependent mitochondrial enzyme ornithine aminotransferase (OAT). The level of OAT activity in obligate carriers of the gene has been shown to be about 50 per cent of normal. Children may present with night-blindness, progressive myopia or field loss, although the diagnosis of gyrate atrophy may be made in early infancy when a raised level of plasma ornithine is found in a child with a family history. Most patients maintain a reasonable level of visual acuity until their forties or fifties, although with a constricted field that corresponds to the degree of choroidal and RPE atrophy. There are small mid-peripheral scotomata in the early stages; progression of disease leads to marked peripheral constriction. The EOG is abnormal in most patients and ERG changes reflect the severity of disease; early in the disease both rod and cone amplitudes are reduced, but later the ERG is usually undetectable. Nonocular features reported include structural abnormalities of the hair, EEG abnormalities and mild intellectual impairment, peripheral neuropathy and mitochondrial abnormalities in a variety of tissues.

The human ornithine-Δ-aminotransferase gene has been cloned. A large number of different mutations of the OAT gene have been identified in patients with gyrate atrophy including some in which the OAT is responsive to pyridoxine. Three different approaches to treatment have been used. A minority of patients are responsive to pyridoxine (B6) supplements. In nonresponders, plasma ornithine levels may be reduced by adhering to an arginine-restricted diet and proline supplementation has been reported to slow the progress of retinal degeneration in some patients.

NEURODEGENERATIVE DISORDERS

In addition to cone and cone–rod dystrophies, bull’s eye maculopathy can also be seen in certain neurodegenerative disorders, especially Batten disease, Hallervorden–Spatz disease and olivopontocerebellar atrophy.

BATTEN DISEASE

Batten disease (neuronal ceroid lipofuscinosis) is an autosomal recessive disorder that occurs in infantile, late infantile and juvenile forms. In the infantile and late infantile forms, neurological deterioration and seizures precede the visual deterioration, which is due to a progressive retinal dystrophy. The ERG is extinguished at an early stage and there is marked optic atrophy, arteriolar attenuation and a mild pigmentary retinopathy. Juvenile Batten disease may present first to the ophthalmologist as the visual deterioration may precede the neurological signs. Visual loss usually starts between 5 and 8 years of age and is later followed by intellectual regression, seizures and neurological deterioration. Death usually occurs by the late teens. The causative gene (CLN3) has been identified. Most affected individuals are homozygous for a 1.02-kilobase deletion in CLN3 with the remainder having a combination of the deletion and a second mutation. Molecular genetic diagnosis is routinely available.

DRUGS CAUSING RETINAL TOXICITY

ANTIMALARIALS

Chloroquine and hydroxychloroquine are used in malarial prophylaxis and treatment and as disease-modifying drugs in connective tissue disorders such as systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). Retinal toxicity can occur with both drugs but hydroxychloroquine is much less toxic and for this reason has now replaced chloroquine in rheumatic therapy. Although the drugs bind to melanin, their action appears to be related to their effect on protein synthesis. Toxicity is related to daily dosage in milligrams per kilogram and to duration of treatment. Patients can take chloroquine for many years for malaria prophylaxis without retinal toxicity provided the dosage regimen is not exceeded. Patients with SLE can take hydroxychlorqine in dosages of 6.5–7 mg/day (200–400 mg/day) for up to 10 years without problem provided they have normal renal and liver function. The first signs of toxicity are perifoveal granularity at the level of the RPE and loss of the foveal reflex; continued use may lead to a bull’s eye maculopathy and eventually to a retinitis pigmentosa-like appearance. Initial symptoms include decreased visual acuity and paracentral scotomata. Once toxicity is established, progressive retinal damage may continue despite ceasing therapy. Corneal epithelial whorls are seen with chloroquine but are of no visual significance (see Ch. 6).