Chapter 35 Mental Health in the Wilderness
Wilderness environments often have beneficial effects on the overall emotional health of many individuals. Individuals who choose to pursue wilderness activities are often seeking relief from the stress of their hectic urban lives (Figure 35-1). However, remote wilderness environments can present unique stresses of their own. Mental health and mental health problems might improve in the wilderness, but psychiatric problems can emerge or become worse in response to the demands of wilderness experiences. This chapter discusses the diagnosis and management of emotional problems in the wilderness, including the use of psychotropic medications, both in people who have preexisting psychological difficulties and in those who develop new emotional problems in the wilderness.
The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, fourth edition, text revision1 (DSM-IV-TR) is the most recent and widely used compendium of the nosology of psychiatric disorders. Most mental health problems can be thought of as falling into six broad groups of disorders: (1) anxiety disorders; (2) mood disorders; (3) psychotic disorders; (4) organic mental disorders; (5) personality disorders; and (6) substance abuse disorders. Specific diagnostic assessment with the use of the DSM-IV-TR and psychological testing in a wilderness setting is not practical. Appropriate triage and management in a wilderness setting depends on classifying emotional and behavioral problems as falling into one or more of these broad categories. Separating normal from abnormal human behaviors is the first step in the triage of emotional problems. It is not straightforward to differentiate what may be considered an adaptive response to the challenge of a wilderness experience from responses that are maladaptive and signal the onset of new emotional problems or the exacerbation of preexisting psychiatric problems. For example, at the end of a physically challenging day of backpacking with a group, one member of the group breaks down in tears. Such crying may be a healthy and adaptive response, or it may be a sign of depression or panic. The process of crying can relieve stress and result in the tearful backpacker receiving needed emotional support. Alternatively, such tears may suggest that the person feels mentally and physically overwhelmed. The person might be approaching a panic state, and, if appropriate interventions are not undertaken, the person’s mental state will deteriorate. The challenge is to determine whether a pat on the back and some encouraging words are all that are needed or if the individual has to be assisted out of the wilderness to prevent further emotional deterioration. In the following sections, four important topical areas for assessment and management of emotional problems in the wilderness are discussed: (1) the common characteristics of the six major categories of psychiatric disorders; (2) suicide and violence potential; (3) psychosomatic complaints; and (4) response to crisis (i.e., disasters and survival psychology). At the end of the chapter, Table 35-1 summarizes the triage of psychiatric problems in the wilderness.
Anxiety disorders | Provide reassurance, support, and lorazepam |
Mood disorders, mild | Provide support and encouragement |
Mood disorders, severe (e.g., mania, suicidal ideation, violence) | Observe constantly, contain or restrain, give lorazepam and haloperidol, and evacuate |
Psychotic disorders | Observe constantly, contain or restrain, give lorazepam and haloperidol, and evacuate |
Organic mental disorders | Identify the cause and eliminate it if possible, observe constantly, contain or restrain, give lorazepam and haloperidol, and evacuate |
Personality disorders, mild | Avoid overreacting to annoying behaviors and intercede to prevent conflicts within the group |
Personality disorders, severe (e.g., violence, extreme behaviors) | Expel the individual from the group if possible or obtain assistance and terminate the outing |
Substance abuse (i.e., no delirium or psychosis) | Confiscate drugs and alcohol |
Substance abuse or withdrawal, severe (e.g., unstable vital signs, delirium, psychosis) | Give lorazepam for withdrawal and haloperidol for psychosis or delirium, observe constantly, contain or restrain, and evacuate |
Suicidal or violent behaviors | Observe constantly, contain or restrain, give lorazepam and haloperidol, and evacuate |
Somatic symptoms of psychological origin | Exclude an organic cause and provide support, reassurance, and firm expectations |
Disasters and post-traumatic stress disorder | Ensure physical and psychological security and safety, provide support, and discuss the disaster as guided by the victim |
Wilderness survival | Stop, take time to develop a plan, attend to physical security (e.g., shelter, warmth, water), and avoid panic |
Psychiatric Disorders
Anxiety Disorders
The several types of anxiety disorders include generalized anxiety disorder, specific phobias, panic disorder, obsessive–compulsive disorder (OCD), and acute and post-traumatic stress disorder (see Response to Crisis, later). People with generalized anxiety disorder worry a lot. Their anxiety is out of proportion as compared with what most people would experience in similar circumstances. The afflicted individual may find it difficult to keep worrisome thoughts from interfering with attention that needs to be paid to current activities. The focus of the worries among people with generalized anxiety disorders are mundane and include such concerns as getting up on time for work, making appointments, and doing chores. These individuals experience somatic symptoms, such as sweating, nausea, and diarrhea. The prevalence of generalized anxiety disorders is approximately 1.5%.5 In a wilderness setting, the foci of worries might be bear attacks, getting lost, not keeping up, flash floods, and so forth. These anxieties will likely diminish the person’s enjoyment of a wilderness experience, affect his or her concentration, and drain his or her energies. People with generalized anxiety may negatively affect group morale. However, generalized anxiety problems are not emergencies; they are chronic problems that can be managed in the field. People with a generalized anxiety disorder require ample reassurance. A good leader can provide reassurance and appoint other group members to assist with reassuring the anxiety-ridden individual.4 Building rapport and trust with the afflicted person is a good first step to helping them. Trying to talk someone out of his or her worries is unlikely to be productive. In the field, a benzodiazepine (e.g., 0.5 to 2 mg of lorazepam two to three times a day) can be useful.11 Side effects include sedation, memory difficulties, and impairment of motor coordination. Sustained benzodiazepine use can lead to physical dependence and withdrawal symptoms with abrupt discontinuation. Thus, such medications must be used cautiously in the field, but they can provide short-term relief of anxiety-related symptoms.
Probably one of the more common specific phobias encountered during a wilderness outing is a fear of heights or exposure (e.g., to an edge with a drop-off). Other common phobias are to snakes, spiders, and water. A specific phobia is an unreasonable fear in anticipation of or on exposure to a particular object or situation.1 The intensity of anxiety with the exposure may vary from relatively mild to extreme panic. In some instances, phobias to heights cannot be overcome in the wilderness. For instance, a trail that crosses a bridge over a chasm or that involves a section of precipitous exposure might be more than can be managed by an individual with a specific phobia to heights. I have personally guided people who were so terrified of exposure that they were unable to complete some trails. Sometimes, gentle reassurance or distraction may be all that is required. Engaging height-phobic people in distracting conversations while backpacking in areas that involve dizzying exposure can be successful. However, if an individual is likely to respond with extreme anxiety and become unbalanced, then it is not safe to use such psychotherapeutic measures.
Panic disorders occur in approximately 1.6% to 5% of the population.5 Treatment with selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (e.g., fluoxetine, sertraline) or benzodiazepines (e.g., alprazolam, clonazepam) or with a combination of the two and with psychotherapeutic intervention can be successful for controlling panic disorder and agoraphobia.5 People with panic disorder whose symptoms are not problematic may safely enjoy a wilderness adventure without difficulty. However, remote locations, bad weather, or physical challenges may increase the stress on such individuals, thereby causing them to experience a resurgence of symptoms. Having panic attacks in the wilderness may precipitate agoraphobia. The afflicted person may want to escape from the wilderness, and he or she may be completely intolerant of being left alone, even for brief periods.
Obsessive–Compulsive Disorder: Repetitive Behaviors
A person with OCD may not be able to adhere to the requirements of a wilderness trip. For instance, the chronic hand washer may slow a group so profoundly that the group cannot make reasonable progress. The example of the person who tries to control his or her anxiety about acting violently by counting may present less of a problem. People with OCD are not typically violent, but a person who is observed to be constantly counting to ward off violent behaviors may have difficulty fitting in with a group. In the general population, the prevalence of OCD is 1% to 2.5%.5 People with OCD are often successfully treated with clomipramine and psychotherapy.5 It is unlikely that OCD symptoms will appear suddenly on a wilderness trip. Frank disclosure to a wilderness group about the OCD symptoms of a member of the group can diminish the group’s anxieties about the person’s odd behaviors and make the afflicted person less likely to be isolated by the group.
Mood Disorders
Depressed people have difficulty sleeping, lose their appetites, have poor energy levels, lose concentration, withdraw socially, cry for no reason, and have difficulty enjoying anything. The most common diagnostic term for this type of depression is major depression; the prevalence of this disorder is approximately 2.5% to 10%.5 At their worst, people with severe depression may become psychotic and suicidal (see Suicide and Violence Potential as well as Psychotic Disorders, later).1 People who are having mild problems are unlikely to develop severe symptoms rapidly, because severe symptoms gradually appear over a period of weeks or months. The more likely problem on a wilderness adventure is finding someone who started out with mild symptoms that are becoming worse. Such individuals may already be taking antidepressant medications (e.g., citalopram, paroxetine). These medications work slowly over a period of weeks, so a change in dose in the midst of a wilderness trip probably would probably not provide significant benefit. The most common problem that the wilderness group may face with a depressed person is that person’s overall impact on group morale. Emotional outbursts, crying for no apparent reason, and offhand comments about suicide will likely concern and distress others in the group. If group members provide encouragement and emotional support, this may help the depressed person to get through the trip safely. However, severe symptoms may not respond to ordinary support. A lack of response can anger others, who may begin to feel conflicted, because they recognize that they are punishing someone who is already suffering. As the symptoms grow worse, it may become necessary to hasten the depressed person’s departure from the wilderness, especially if there is suicidal ideation.
Individuals with bipolar disorder experience episodes of major depression that alternate with periods of mania over a period of months, often with normal functioning occurring between the abnormal episodes. The prevalence of bipolar disorder is approximately 1%.5 During periods of normal mood or during the early stages of a manic phase (i.e., hypomania), bipolar persons may participate in wilderness adventures with no difficulty. During a period of hypomania, a person is very positive, productive, hardworking, energetic, and expansive. However, as the person becomes manic, problems become readily apparent. There is often rapid and pressured speech that is difficult to interrupt. Sufferers might not sleep at all, or they may be excessively gregarious and begin to believe that they have superhuman powers. An individual may try to awaken a wilderness group in the middle of the night to hike up a nearby peak. When rebuffed, the manic person might take off alone with no water or protection from the weather because of the belief that he or she is superhuman. A guide described a participant on a wilderness trip who became manic and could not be dissuaded from climbing to the top of a mountain to talk with God. An individual with mania who is in the wilderness should be considered a medical emergency and should be evacuated as rapidly as possible.