CHAPTER 19 Dual disability
Dual disability refers to the coexistence of an intellectual disability (ID) or autism with mental health problems. Both ID and autism are classified as developmental disorders and require evidence of their presence in the first 18 years of life for a diagnosis to be made. However, the manifestations of these disorders extend into adulthood and the field of dual disability is concerned with the mental health of adults with either ID or autism. The need for this speciality arises because the presence of a developmental disorder both increases the risk of comorbid mental disorders, as well as complicates their assessment and management.
This chapter provides a brief overview of ID and of autism, before concentrating on dual disability.
Intellectual disability (ID)
The concept of an ID is that some people have difficulty in caring for themselves due to deficits in intelligence. The current DSM–IVTR diagnostic uses the term ‘mental retardation’. The criteria are shown in Box 19.1.
BOX 19.1 DSM–IVTR criteria for mental retardation (synopsis)
Population surveys usually find that about 2% of the population have an ID. People with severe ID are more likely to be identified early in life and are more likely to have an identifiable aetiology. Below the age of 6, the diagnosis is based on delay in achieving developmental milestones. Those with less severe ID may not be identified until they start school, when poor academic performance becomes evident. Some may not be identified until secondary school and may present with oppositional behaviours and truancy due to their inability to meet the demands placed on them. The diagnosis is confirmed by demonstrating the IQ and functional deficits. At any age it is important to exclude medical problems that may be contributing to impaired intellectual function (e.g. hypothyroidism).
Aetiology
Autism and autism spectrum disorders
These three functional deficits are referred to as the triad of impairments and can occur across a range of IQ scores. DSM–IVTR criteria are listed in Box 19.2.
BOX 19.2 DSM–IVTR criteria for autism (synopsis)
In DSM–IVTR, the term pervasive developmental disorders (PDD) is used as the overarching term that covers the autistic spectrum disorders. This group includes five specified conditions, as shown in Box 19.3. See also Chapter 16 for a comparison between autism and Asperger’s disorder.
BOX 19.3 Autism spectrum disorders/pervasive developmental disorders (PDD)
The earliest epidemiological studies used Kanner’s very narrow criteria and found a prevalence rate for autism of around 0.05%. Much higher rates (around 1%) have been recorded using current diagnostic criteria for autistic spectrum disorders. The diagnosis is a clinical one and consists of gathering evidence of impairments in the triad of domains. The manifestations of these deficits are broadly covered in the diagnostic criteria (see Box 19.1 above), but can present in many different ways depending on age, sex, IQ, personality and situational context. The more severe the autism, the earlier the diagnosis; the more subtle variations may never be formally identified.
Aetiology
A range of factors have been implicated in causing autistic spectrum disorders. Genetic factors seem to predominate, although no simple pattern of inheritance has been identified and there are thought to be a range of genes that contribute to risk. Some specific genetic disorders are also associated with a higher risk of developing autism; these include fragile X syndrome.