Chapter 33 Botanical Medicine—A Modern Perspective
Introduction
For many people of the world, herbal medicines are the only therapeutic agents available. In the late 1990s, the World Health Organization estimated that about 80% of the world’s population relies on herbs for primary health care needs.1 This widespread use of herbal medicines is not restricted to developing countries, since it has been estimated that 70% of all medical doctors in France and Germany regularly prescribe herbal preparations.
Throughout the world, but especially in Europe, the United States, Canada, Australia, and Japan, a tremendous renaissance in the use and appreciation of herbal medicine occurred in the latter part of the twentieth century. For example, in the United States, the sale of herbal products skyrocketed from $200 million in 1988 to more than $3.5 billion in 1997 before leveling off in the $4 billion a year range (Table 33-1). Within the European Community annual sales exceeded $7 billion in 1997.2
TABLE 33-1 Total Estimated Herb Sales in the United States 1994-2005
YEAR | $ TOTAL SALES (MILLIONS) | % INCREASE (-DECREASE) |
---|---|---|
1994 | 2020 | |
1995 | 2470 | 22.3 |
1996 | 2990 | 21.1 |
1997 | 3557 | 19.0 |
1998 | 4002 | 12.5 |
1999 | 4110 | 2.7 |
2000 | 4260 | 3.7 |
2001 | 4397 | 3.2 |
2002 | 4276 | −2.8 |
2003 | 4178 | −2.3 |
2004 | 4320 | 3.4 |
2005 | 4410 | 2.1 |
Data from Ferrier GKL, Thwaites LA, Rea PR, et al. U.S. consumer herbal and herbal botanical supplement sales. Nutr Business J. 2006. http://www.nutritionbusiness.com.
The Role of Herbs in Modern Pharmacy
Plants still play a major role in modern pharmacy. For the past 50 years, about 25% of all prescription drugs in the United States and other developed countries have contained active constituents obtained from plants. Digoxin, codeine, colchicine, morphine, vincristine, and yohimbine are some popular examples. Many over-the-counter (OTC) preparations are also composed of plant compounds. Pharmacognosy, the study of natural drugs and their constituents, plays a major role in current drug development. Unfortunately, the standard path of the approval of a drug is a process that typically takes 10 to 18 years at a total cost of roughly $250 million (Table 33-2).
TABLE 33-2 Classic Examples of Drugs From Plants With a Correlation to Its Traditional Use
DRUG | CLINICAL USE | BOTANICAL SOURCE |
---|---|---|
Atropine | Anticholinergic | Atropa belladonna |
Caffeine | Central nervous system stimulant | Cola nitida |
Camphor | Rubefacient | Cinnamomum camphora |
Cocaine | Local anesthetic | Erythroxylon coca |
Codeine | Analgesic/antitussive | Papaver somniferum |
Colchicine | Antigout | Colchicum autumnale |
Digitoxin | Cardiotonic | Digitalis purpurea |
Digoxin | Cardiotonic | Digitalis lanata |
Emetine | Amebicide/emetic | Cephaelis ipecacuanha |
Ephedrine | Sympathomimetic | Ephedra sinica |
Gossypol | Male contraceptive | Gossypium spp. |
Hyoscyamine | Anticholinergic | Hyoscyamus niger |
Kawain | Tranquilizer | Piper methysticum |
Methoxsalen | Psoriasis/vitiligo | Ammi majus |
Morphine | Analgesic | Papaver somniferum |
Noscapine | Antitussive | Papaver somniferum |
Physostigmine | Cholinesterase inhibitor | Physostigma venenosum |
Pilocarpine | Parasympathomimetic | Pilocarpus jaborandi |
Podophyllotoxin | Topical wart remedy | Podophyllum peltatum |
Quabain | Cardiotonic | Strophanthus gratus |
Quinine | Antimalarial | Cinchona ledgeriana |
Reserpine | Antihypertensive | Rauwolfia serpentine |
Scopolamine | Sedative | Datura metel |
Sennosides | Laxative | Cassia spp. |
Theophylline | Bronchodilator | Camellia sinensis |
Tubocurarine | Muscle relaxant | Chondrodendron tomentosum |
Yohimbine | Male erectile dysfunction | Pausinystalia yohimbe |
Data from De Smet PA. Drugs 1997;54:801-840.
Because a plant cannot be patented, plants are screened for biological activity and then the so-called “active” constituents (compounds) are isolated and typically chemically modified to produce unique substances. If the compound is powerful enough, the drug company begins the process to procure Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approval. Of 520 new drugs approved by the FDA or comparable entities in developed countries, 30 came directly from natural product sources and another 173 were either semisynthetic from a natural source or modeled after a naturally occurring compound.1
Because of the expense and lack of patent protection, few clinical evaluations were done before 1980 on whole plants or crude plant extracts as medicinal agents per se. A key factor in contributing to more research into herbal medicines after this time was the development in Europe of regulatory policies and practices that made it economically feasible for companies to do research. For example, in Germany, regulations allow herbal products to be marketed with drug claims if they are proven to be safe and effective.3 Whether the herbal product is available by prescription or OTC is based on its application and safety of use. Herbal products sold in pharmacies are reimbursed by insurance if they are prescribed by a physician.
Originally, it was thought that hypericin acted as an inhibitor of the enzyme monoamine oxidase, thereby resulting in the increase of central nervous system monoamines such as serotonin and dopamine. However, it was later shown that St. John’s wort does not inhibit monoamine oxidase in vivo.4 The antidepressant activities appear to be related more to serotonin reuptake inhibition as occurs with the drugs Prozac, Paxil, and Zoloft; modulation of neuroendocrine function; downregulation of β-adrenergic receptors; and upregulation of serotonin receptors in the brain areas that are implicated in depression.4,5 In addition, it appears that although hypericin is an important marker, other compounds such as flavonoids are also thought to play a major role in the pharmacology of St. John’s wort. The key point here is that the further understanding and documentation of clinical effectiveness of St. John’s wort extract was largely the direct result of a commercial incentive created by the existence of Commission E.6
The Study of Herbal Medicine
The History of Herbal Medicine
A trend exists toward using natural substances, including compounds found in the human body, such as interferon, interleukin, insulin, and human growth hormone, as well as foods, food components, herbs, and herbal compounds. More and more researchers are discovering the tremendous healing properties of these natural compounds and their advantages over synthetic medicines and surgery in the treatment of many health conditions. Through these scientific investigations, a trend toward natural medicine is emerging. To better appreciate this evolutionary trend, this section presents some of the historical aspects of herbal medicine. Much of the following is derived from Barbara Griggs’ Green Pharmacy: A History of Herbal Medicine.7
In the Beginning
Plants have been used as medicines since the dawn of animal life. The initial use of plants as medicines by humans is thought to have been a result of “instinctive” dowsing. Animals in the wild still provide evidence that this phenomena occurs. Animals, with a few notable exceptions, eat plants that heal them and avoid plants that do them harm. Presumably humans also possessed this instinct at one time.
• Panax ginseng (ginseng): its roots bear a strong resemblance to a human figure, and its general use is as a tonic.
• Caulophyllum thalictroides (blue cohosh): its branches are arranged like limbs in spasm, indicating its usefulness in the treatment of muscular spasm.
• Sanguinaria canadensis (bloodroot): its roots and sap are a beautiful blood color, corresponding to its traditional use as a “blood purifier.”
• Lobelia inflata (lobelia): its flowers are shaped like a stomach, corresponding to its emetic qualities.
• Hydrastis canadensis (goldenseal): its yellow-green root signifies its use in jaundice as well as infectious processes.
Challenges to Galenical Medicine
The 1500s also saw a strong challenge to Galenical medicine from within the traditional circles. Specifically, Paracelsus, an alchemist who believed strongly in the doctrine of signatures, was responsible for founding modern pharmaceutic medicine. Paracelsus is probably most remembered for the development of laudanum (tincture of opium). After Paracelsus, Galenical preparations and treatments fell greatly out of favor.
The Thomsonian and Eclectic Movements
Thomsonians became locked in prejudice and dogma and insisted that all medical knowledge was complete and could be found in Thomson’s works. These and other claims roused scorn, indignation, rage, and resentment in the average North American doctor. Frequently based on purging through the use of herbal emetics, Thomson’s treatments were often as harsh as the standard treatments of the times (for further discussion, see Chapter 4).
Final Comments
1. De Smet P.A. The role of plant-derived drugs and herbal medicines in healthcare. Drugs. 1997;54:801–840.
2. Mahady G.B. Global harmonization of herbal health claims. J Nutr. 2001;131(suppl 3):1120S–1123S.
3. Keller K. Legal requirements for the use of phytopharmaceutical drugs in the Federal Republic of Germany. J Ethnopharmacol. 1991;32:225–229.
4. Thiede H.M., Walper A. Inhibition of MAO and COMT by hypericum extracts and hypericin. J Geriatr Psychiatry Neurol. 1994;7:S54–S56.
5. Perovic S., Muller W.E.G. Pharmacological profile of hypericum extract. Effect of serotonin uptake by postsynaptic receptors. Arzneim Forsch. 1995;45:1145–1148.
6. Butterweck V. Mechanism of action of St. John’s wort in depression: what is known? CNS Drugs. 2003;17:539–562.
7. Griggs B. Green pharmacy. A history of herbal medicine. London: Robert Hale; 1981.